The TRshady Forum became read-only in December 2014. The 10 year history will live on, in this archive.
Continue the discussion with the new home for the Eminem and Hip Hop discussion: HipHopShelter.com.

Best dictator.. (stalin vs hitler)

Fellow ladies and fella Master-Debaters, discuss serious topics.

hitler or stalin

hitler
12
50%
stalin
12
50%
 
Total votes : 24

Postby yoshi » Feb 24th, '06, 19:58

Don't you guys think that what we learn at school is just bunch of facts, chosen by other ppl to show the bests sides of country? :confusion: Cause history is a subjective topic.. You can always 'forget' to mention some fact or somethin.. So don't abuse eachother..

I voted for Stalin. I think Hitler was.. well.. u know. Never been to camps founded in Russia, but visit in Auschwitz-Birkenau concetration camp made me feel that Hitler was one of the worst things which happened to ppl by far. Seeing pictures of prisoners, their personal stuff like glasses, shoes.. Even their hair.. It's all in there, in big paned recesses - the amount of ppl which were killed because of him still scares me..

But nowadays I don't hate on Germans and in my opinion ppl should not do it - it's not their fault. It's like in Russia in XIX century - some of ppl were obedient because of their beliefs, some because of scare. Plus it's more than 60 years, so we cannot blame the whole nation today of what happened during II WW..
Maybe wrote:I'm so awesome, I don't mind looking desperate.

Chet wrote:Fuck House. If I wanted to watch a sarcastic person in the medical field, I would stalk Yoshi :8)
User avatar
yoshi
Bad Influence
Bad Influence
 
Posts: 19405
Joined: Feb 9th, '05, 21:10
Location: Poland, Warsaw
Gender: Female

Postby Prodeo » Feb 24th, '06, 21:01

i go with stalin
since he didn't have a sick racial system
plus he liberated europe from the nazi's and not the americans, but thank god they reached my country :p

been reading a lot about the war
i was watching a documentary of bbc about WWII and , i could misheard, but for every german soldier 57russians died. correct me if i'm wrong
Last edited by Prodeo on Feb 24th, '06, 21:06, edited 1 time in total.
Prodeo
Trailer Trash
Trailer Trash
 
Posts: 219
Joined: Dec 10th, '05, 22:25

Postby AspirinE » Feb 24th, '06, 21:06

Prodeo wrote:i go with stalin
since he didn't have a sick racial system
plus he liberated europe from the nazi's and not the americans, but thank god they reached my country :p


lol u should have voted for hitler coz the poll is to determine whos a bigger monster.

I dont know wat kind of ignorant person ud have to be to vote Stalin over wat hitler did.
User avatar
AspirinE
Django
Django
 
Posts: 20230
Joined: Jun 4th, '05, 11:00
Location: Russia - Novosibirsk.
Gender: Male

Postby Ivy » Feb 24th, '06, 21:07

AspirinE wrote:
Prodeo wrote:i go with stalin
since he didn't have a sick racial system
plus he liberated europe from the nazi's and not the americans, but thank god they reached my country :p


lol u should have voted for hitler coz the poll is to determine whos a bigger monster.

I dont know wat kind of ignorant person ud have to be to vote Stalin over wat hitler did.



FINALLY.......someone finally states what I've been trying to state all along.....I've just been going around my elbow to get to my ass...but yeah...I've been trying to say this the whole time.... :smoking:
Image

"My life your entertainment, you watch it while I live it. I walk they folla (ay), I talk they holla (ay), just here for your amusement. My life your entertainment. you watch it while I live it. You waitin' for me to lose it, I guess I'm just here for your amusement..." ~ T.I. feat. Usher "My Life Your Entertainment"
User avatar
Ivy
Band Leader
Band Leader
 
Posts: 6173
Joined: Nov 27th, '05, 17:50
Location: Raleigh, North Carolina
Gender: Female

Postby yoshi » Feb 24th, '06, 22:16

But the point was to choose the best one, so I thought the one that didn't made as much harm as the other. :confusion: So I've chosen Stalin, it's obvious. Ok. I don't understand it anymore.. :whistle:
Maybe wrote:I'm so awesome, I don't mind looking desperate.

Chet wrote:Fuck House. If I wanted to watch a sarcastic person in the medical field, I would stalk Yoshi :8)
User avatar
yoshi
Bad Influence
Bad Influence
 
Posts: 19405
Joined: Feb 9th, '05, 21:10
Location: Poland, Warsaw
Gender: Female

Postby Hocky27 » Feb 24th, '06, 23:22

Both were pretty bad dictators. However I think Stalin was worse then Hitler.

Oh i also find it pretty damn sad that some people here didnt even know who Stalin was. :shakehead:
Image
Hocky27
Soldier
Soldier
 
Posts: 569
Joined: Nov 15th, '05, 10:05
Location: Australia

Postby AspirinE » Feb 24th, '06, 23:28

Hocky27 wrote:Both were pretty bad dictators. However I think Stalin was worse then Hitler.

Oh i also find it pretty damn sad that some people here didnt even know who Stalin was. :shakehead:



Stalin worse then Hitler ??!!!! u people are fucking rediculous. Id that wat they teach u at school?
User avatar
AspirinE
Django
Django
 
Posts: 20230
Joined: Jun 4th, '05, 11:00
Location: Russia - Novosibirsk.
Gender: Male

Postby AspirinE » Feb 24th, '06, 23:46

memyselforwho wrote:asp, dont even bother gettin mad, and yes thats what i learned for the past 5 years


Im not mad, im just suprised how brainwashed people actually are. I aint getting mad at nobody for their beliefs. But i mean Hitler and stalin are absolutely different. ughh... wateva, i cant argue with an image that was propogandised for almost 6 decades.
User avatar
AspirinE
Django
Django
 
Posts: 20230
Joined: Jun 4th, '05, 11:00
Location: Russia - Novosibirsk.
Gender: Male

Postby AspirinE » Feb 25th, '06, 00:02

memyselforwho wrote:
AspirinE wrote:
memyselforwho wrote:asp, dont even bother gettin mad, and yes thats what i learned for the past 5 years


Im not mad, im just suprised how brainwashed people actually are. I aint getting mad at nobody for their beliefs. But i mean Hitler and stalin are absolutely different. ughh... wateva, i cant argue with an image that was propogandised for almost 6 decades.



ok, books can be wrong....but i belive you :happy: i mean you make to much sense to not belive



Me - sence, no not always. lol i hope ur being sarcastic.

But yeah ur right books aint always right.
Books are simply an opinion from one person, and history is too taught from opinion. If they write something like "Putin killed 100 billion people" it doesnt mean that the history book is telling the truth. Its just like television, they are ways of spreading propoganda.
User avatar
AspirinE
Django
Django
 
Posts: 20230
Joined: Jun 4th, '05, 11:00
Location: Russia - Novosibirsk.
Gender: Male

Postby Mr. Cookie » Feb 25th, '06, 00:04

none...fuck them both...
Mr. Cookie
 

Postby Ivy » Feb 25th, '06, 01:38

:shocked2: When did Stalin or whoever the fuck and whatever the fuck that guy did become in the lead???????????????????????????????????? :confusion:
Image

"My life your entertainment, you watch it while I live it. I walk they folla (ay), I talk they holla (ay), just here for your amusement. My life your entertainment. you watch it while I live it. You waitin' for me to lose it, I guess I'm just here for your amusement..." ~ T.I. feat. Usher "My Life Your Entertainment"
User avatar
Ivy
Band Leader
Band Leader
 
Posts: 6173
Joined: Nov 27th, '05, 17:50
Location: Raleigh, North Carolina
Gender: Female

Postby Prodeo » Feb 25th, '06, 02:09

AspirinE wrote:
Prodeo wrote:i go with stalin
since he didn't have a sick racial system
plus he liberated europe from the nazi's and not the americans, but thank god they reached my country :p


lol u should have voted for hitler coz the poll is to determine whos a bigger monster.

I dont know wat kind of ignorant person ud have to be to vote Stalin over wat hitler did.


i voted wrong then sorry, i tought with best dictator he meaned who was the least cruel. Offcourse was hitler way worse then stalin...
the things stalin did, could be justified
while this will never be the case for the things hitler did
Prodeo
Trailer Trash
Trailer Trash
 
Posts: 219
Joined: Dec 10th, '05, 22:25

Postby Prodeo » Feb 25th, '06, 02:10

TaylorakaTiGGi wrote::shocked2: When did Stalin or whoever the fuck and whatever the fuck that guy did become in the lead???????????????????????????????????? :confusion:


the octoberrevolution in 1917 i think.
Prodeo
Trailer Trash
Trailer Trash
 
Posts: 219
Joined: Dec 10th, '05, 22:25

Postby Ivy » Feb 25th, '06, 02:13

Prodeo wrote:
TaylorakaTiGGi wrote::shocked2: When did Stalin or whoever the fuck and whatever the fuck that guy did become in the lead???????????????????????????????????? :confusion:


the octoberrevolution in 1917 i think.



Okay..you just 100% or 101% confused the hell out of me...it's okay though...it ain't hard to do... :sweating: :whistle: :sweating:
Image

"My life your entertainment, you watch it while I live it. I walk they folla (ay), I talk they holla (ay), just here for your amusement. My life your entertainment. you watch it while I live it. You waitin' for me to lose it, I guess I'm just here for your amusement..." ~ T.I. feat. Usher "My Life Your Entertainment"
User avatar
Ivy
Band Leader
Band Leader
 
Posts: 6173
Joined: Nov 27th, '05, 17:50
Location: Raleigh, North Carolina
Gender: Female

Postby Ivy » Feb 25th, '06, 02:19

Oh well...I could just go to wikipedia and read about him...but the autobiography is to damn long and I don't want to read that much...I'm to lazy right now..I'm in my lazy mood.... :sweating: :whistle:
Image

"My life your entertainment, you watch it while I live it. I walk they folla (ay), I talk they holla (ay), just here for your amusement. My life your entertainment. you watch it while I live it. You waitin' for me to lose it, I guess I'm just here for your amusement..." ~ T.I. feat. Usher "My Life Your Entertainment"
User avatar
Ivy
Band Leader
Band Leader
 
Posts: 6173
Joined: Nov 27th, '05, 17:50
Location: Raleigh, North Carolina
Gender: Female

PreviousNext

Return to Serious Debate



Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users