The Marshall Mathers LP or The Eminem Show?

[Jay-19]

MMLP for me. Imo the best MMLP songs beat out the best TES songs (apart for 'Till I collapse). MMLP has a much more raw feel and sound while TES has a more complete and commercial sound and I prefer the rawer sound.

I agree to the fullest!
You just gotta love that raw, underground feel it has!

[cityfan31]

For a long time I put TES as my number one. However I realised that when i make a playlist of eminem's top songs i put Kill You, Stan, Who knew, way i am, Marshall Mathers, Criminal and I'm Back on it. From TES i put square dance, cleanin out my closet, SGTH, sing for the moment, superman and til' i collapse. And maybe soldier.

That makes it mmlp 7-6 (or maybe 7) TES

On second thoughts, i just cannot decide. Maybe I like the angrier marshall on MMLP a little more. AAAARGH don't make me choose!

Hopefully on June 22nd the choice of best album will become much more difficult