The Eminem Show Vs. Recovery (track by track) 'game'

[ku53v]

white america vs. cold wind blows
business vs. talking to myself
cleaning out my closet vs. on fire
square dance vs. wont back down
soldier vs. WTP
say goodbye hollywood vs. going through changes
drips vs. not afraid
without me vs. seduction
sing for the moment vs. no love
superman vs. space bound
hailies song vs. cinderella man
when the music stops vs. 25 to life
say what you say vs. so bad
till i collapse vs. almost famous
my dads gone crazy vs. love the way you lie
curtains close vs. you're never over

[Emadyville]

I don't think you can put songs together based on where they located on the album, cause a lot of times they are completely different, like business and talkin 2 myself

Overall it'd be tough to do either way

[slimshady13]

white america vs. cold wind blows
business vs. talking to myself
cleaning out my closet vs. on fire
square dance vs. wont back down
soldier vs. WTP
say goodbye hollywood vs. going through changes
drips vs. not afraid
without me vs. seduction
sing for the moment vs. no love
superman vs. space bound
hailies song vs. cinderella man
when the music stops vs. 25 to life
say what you say vs. so bad
till i collapse vs. almost famous
my dads gone crazy vs. love the way you lie
stimulate vs. you're never over

TES 7
Recovery 9

[Shit Can Happen]

white america vs. cold wind blows
business vs. talking to myself
cleaning out my closet vs. on fire
square dance vs. wont back down
soldier vs. WTP
say goodbye hollywood vs. going through changes
drips vs. not afraid
without me vs. seduction
sing for the moment vs. no love
superman vs. space bound
hailies song vs. cinderella man
when the music stops vs. 25 to life
say what you say vs. so bad
till i collapse vs. almost famous
my dads gone crazy vs. love the way you lie
stimulate vs. you're never over

[Dr.Lecter]

i don't understand how you can make these comparisons... each track on there can't possibly be compared to the other track since both tracks are completely different in content and mood.

soldier - is not a song about some white trash party
hailey's song - is not about gaining some time of redemption
superman - in no way shares the same context as space bound
my dad's gone crazy - has nothing to do about a fucked up love life ....etc.

wouldn't it make more sense to compare tracks with similar content?

[Mxracer6y]

i don't understand how you can make these comparisons... each track on there can't possibly be compared to the other track since both tracks are completely different in content and mood.

soldier - is not a song about some white trash party
hailey's song - is not about gaining some time of redemption
superman - in no way shares the same context as space bound
my dad's gone crazy - has nothing to do about a fucked up love life ....etc.

wouldn't it make more sense to compare tracks with similar content?

I was thinking the same thing and i agree 100%

for instance..WTP should be compared with a song like 'business' (not content but the overall feel of the song)


also addressing other peoples ratings heres my ratings for TES

white america is an untouchable song
cleaning out my closet is untouchable
soldier is untouchable
superman is untouchable
say goodbye hollywood is untouchable
sing for the moment.. untouchable

^^ thats the way i see it... i dont know why you're comparing the records heads up.. thats unfair.. but if thats how you wanna do it.... how many songs on recovery are untouchable?

[Robbie G]

Recovery is a great album but people are over hyping it. It's no Eminem Show, but that's not a diss because what is?

[bozothe1]

every tes song is better than recovery track by track, but I think like if you were to make a disc from all em albums besides TES, to be better than TES, you couldn't do it. TES is kobe bryant in the 3rd quarter today.

[Le Tunisien]

the eminem show is obviously better than recovery,and also,you cant compre albums like that
but lets try:

white america vs. cold wind blows
business vs. talking to myself
cleaning out my closet vs. on fire
square dance vs. wont back down
soldier vs. WTP
say goodbye hollywood vs. going through changes
drips vs. not afraid
without me vs. seduction
sing for the moment vs. no love
superman vs. space bound
hailies song vs. cinderella man
when the music stops vs. 25 to life
say what you say vs. so bad
till i collapse vs. almost famous
my dads gone crazy vs. love the way you lie
stimulate vs. youre never over
lose yourself vs. here we go

so its 12 for TES
5 for recovery
basically the truth lol

[Drucifer]

The Eminem Show was always a mixed bag for me, because It has some of my favorite Em tracks(Cleaning Out My Closet, White America, Sing for the moment, Till I collaspe, Soldier), while also having songs I cant stand(Without Me, Buisness, Drips)........Great album but that was the first Eminem CD that made me discover the skip button, the first 2 I listened 2 all the way through

So Far, I'm playing this one all the way through cause theres nothing that cheesy on it....... I dont think theres anything on Recovery that I like as much as Cleaning Out My closet(A few come close), but theres nothing on there I dislike as much as "Without Me"......So, in my honest opinion, this album is better, but music is subjective so everyones entitled to their opinion

[paradigmal]

white america <<<< cold wind blows
business >>>>> talking to myself
cleaning out my closet <<<<< on fire
square dance >>>>> wont back down
soldier >>>>> WTP
say goodbye hollywood >>>>> going through changes
drips <<<<< not afraid
without me <<<<< seduction
sing for the moment = no love
superman <<<<< space bound
hailies song <<<<< cinderella man
when the music stops >>>>> 25 to life
say what you say <<<<< so bad
till i collapse = almost famous
my dads gone crazy <<<<< love the way you lie
stimulate <<<<< youre never over
lose yourself>>>>here we go

TES - 6
Recovery - 7
Ties - 1

[DƎRDYPK]

Recovery is a great album but people are over hyping it.

I wonder what Stans did what Encore came out.....

[CLV22798]

I want to judge both albums more fairly, putting tracks that are most similar next to each other and see which album I like more



White America vs Cold Wind Blows

Business vs WTP

Cleaning Out My Closet vs Love The Way You Lie (Tie)

Square Dance vs Not Afraid

Soldier vs Almost Famous (Tie)

Say Goodbye Hollywood vs 25 To Life

Drips vs So Bad

Without Me vs Won't Back Down (Tie)

Sing For The Moment vs Going Through Changes (Tie)

Superman vs Seduction

Hailie's Song vs You're Never Over

When The Music Stops vs No Love

Say What You Say vs Talkin 2 Myself

Till I Collapse vs Cinderella Man

My Dad's Gone Crazy vs Here We Go

Stimulate vs Space Bound



So, That's 11-9 in favor of Recovery

[luquew]

both dope albums, eminem show is still my fav tho