How do you rate Recovery?

[Scrubz]

Oh and il give it a 9/10 cuz no ones perfect.

[dR3]

viewtopic.php?f=3&t=89123&hilit=rate+recovery

PHUK U!!!!!

[ch_ch_chainsaw]

Slim Shady LP - 10/10
Marshall Mathers LP - 10/10
The Eminem Show - 10/10
Encore - 4/10
Relapse - 5/10
Recovery - 7/10

I'm sorry but to give sslp a 10 is crazy, as a rap album it wasn't that good. Don't get me wrong I loved it cuz I'm an eminem fan but it's no were close to the level of mmlp and tes. And on top of it you rated it better than recovery... Ayyyyy. But it's your opinion so oh well.

It's not crazy at all. Lyrically it's far better than Recovery. Rock Bottom is far better than anything on Recovery. SSLP is raw and lyrical, has personality and style. It's totally unique. You can hear his hunger. Recovery is very mainstream sounding, very reliant on hooks and samples and doesn't have the lyrics that SSLP has. It is a great album but in my opinion doesn't even approach those first 3.

[slimsoxshady]

I rate it 5000


(check post count)

[Jimmy Conway]

Eminem Show - 9.5/10
Marshall Mathers LP - 9/10
SSLP 8/10
Recovery 7 / 10
Relapse 6 /10
Encore 5/10
Infinite 3/10

[Scrubz]

Slim Shady LP - 10/10
Marshall Mathers LP - 10/10
The Eminem Show - 10/10
Encore - 4/10
Relapse - 5/10
Recovery - 7/10

I'm sorry but to give sslp a 10 is crazy, as a rap album it wasn't that good. Don't get me wrong I loved it cuz I'm an eminem fan but it's no were close to the level of mmlp and tes. And on top of it you rated it better than recovery... Ayyyyy. But it's your opinion so oh well.

It's not crazy at all. Lyrically it's far better than Recovery. Rock Bottom is far better than anything on Recovery. SSLP is raw and lyrical, has personality and style. It's totally unique. You can hear his hunger. Recovery is very mainstream sounding, very reliant on hooks and samples and doesn't have the lyrics that SSLP has. It is a great album but in my opinion doesn't even approach those first 3.

mehh, I don't agree at all. Recvery is just as lyrical as any other album, and has personality and style, maybe a different personality and maybe not your style. I still think nastalgia(sp?) has got your leg. But again our opinions different, that's a good thing about em, his fans like different things. Actually that's what makes him great.

[Solace]

9/10

[Jaz]

mehh, I don't agree at all. Recvery is just as lyrical as any other album, and has personality and style, maybe a different personality and maybe not your style. I still think nastalgia(sp?) has got your leg. But again our opinions different, that's a good thing about em, his fans like different things. Actually that's what makes him great.

Personality and style is subjective, but lyrically there's no way Recovery is on par with the other albums. Luckily it's got enough other shit to sort of balance out.

I've never heard a track from Em I liked as much as Rock Bottom, so my opinion of SSLP may be biased solely based on that.. but metaphors are not part of lyricism in my eyes. I think that's a whole 'nother skill. In terms of multis, wordplay, and structure.. SSLP has some of his best work.

At least 3-4 of my top 10 Em tracks come from SSLP. It will probably always be my favorite of his albums

Although I do hate corny ass tracks like My Name Is.