Do you think Recovery would be a classic if Dre produced it?

[Almostlity]

I think it'd be a classic if Eminem produced it.

this.

[shadyboymez]

I think it'd be a classic if Eminem produced it.

well i guess not many others had this idea, seeing as Eminem was the sole producer of ZERO tracks on Recovery...

[Heffernan]

Yes since I know who flavor flav is that must mean I'm a reality show fanatic...there is no other reason

Dre discovering eminem has no impact on how talented of a rapper he is...and how vetrsatile of a producer he is

The truth is he can not write his own raps...that's why people write them for him...there is no denying that...it has been proven time and time again that eminem, TI. Ludacris, lil wayne, drake, jay-z, DOC, fucking anybody else...have all written for him

And if you have ears...you know his beats all sound the same

Yes he was a member of NWA..and for that yes he is a legend..because they are the founders of gagnsta rap...which is now dead BTW

If dre writes his own music...to his own beats on every song on a CD...it will be fucking snoozeville USA cuz the raps will all suck...and all the beats will sound the same


Give me real reasons why u think dre is amazing, good, great, the best...w/e based on facts that can be supported

Not because he is a legend...there is no denying that...but of why he is a good rapper....


(I'm not sayingi don't like his beats either..cuz I do..I just think they all sound the same most of the time...)

[mart85]

obviously, it's all opinions, cause nobody knows what it would have sounded like, but I do think it would have been at least as good. I wasn't a fan of some of the Recovery beats cause of the drums and the mix, I much prefer Dr. Dre's mixing. I really wish Dre or Eminem would have "co-produced" a few of the beats, and improve the drums and overall mix.

And a lot of people say Dre's beats always sound the same, but Eminem is the one who picks the Dre beats he likes. It's not like Dre can't do any other type of beats, all he has to do is ask his musicians to come up with different ideas lol. Dre (and his team) can make pretty much any type of beats, but what I like from Dre is that his tracks always sound clean.

Some producers did bring fresh sounds and ideas for Eminem tho, like Khalil and Alex Da Kid.

[Heffernan]

Yes since I know who flavor flav is that must mean I'm a reality show fanatic...there is no other reason

Dre discovering eminem has no impact on how talented of a rapper he is...and how versatile of a producer he is

The truth is he can not write his own raps...that's why people write them for him...there is no denying that...it has been proven time and time again that eminem, TI. Ludacris, lil wayne, drake, jay-z, DOC, fucking anybody else...have all written for him

And if you have ears...you know his beats all sound the same

Yes he was a member of NWA..and for that yes he is a legend..because they are the founders of gagnsta rap...which is now dead BTW

If dre writes his own music...to his own beats on every song on a CD...it will be fucking snoozeville USA cuz the raps will all suck...and all the beats will sound the same


Give me real reasons why u think dre is amazing, good, great, the best...w/e based on facts that can be supported

Not because he is a legend...there is no denying that...but of why he is a good rapper....


(I'm not sayingi don't like his beats either..cuz I do..I just think they all sound the same most of the time...)

[shadyboymez]

obviously, it's all opinions, cause nobody knows what it would have sounded like, but I do think it would have been at least as good. I wasn't a fan of some of the Recovery beats cause of the drums and the mix, I much prefer Dr. Dre's mixing. I really wish Dre or Eminem would have "co-produced" a few of the beats, and improve the drums and overall mix.

And a lot of people say Dre's beats always sound the same, but Eminem is the one who picks the Dre beats he likes. It's not like Dre can't do any other type of beats, all he has to do is ask his musicians to come up with different ideas lol. Dre (and his team) can make pretty much any type of beats, but what I like from Dre is that his tracks always sound clean.

Some producers did bring fresh sounds and ideas for Eminem tho, like Khalil and Alex Da Kid.

Eminem just suits the clean crisp sound of Dre's production. So Bad & Ridaz are perfect examples.