Do you think Em will ever just completley Sing on a Song

[Aftermathers]

Again possibley for his next album like he did on The Eminem Show? it's surprising he never did that again just Singing on a Song all the way through based on the positive reaction and how Hailies Song was so loved and praised.



Do you think that creativity of Eminem on his next Album is essential Rapping, Singing and doing all the Production and Mixing?

[Kill You]

If he does sing, it needs to only be for hooks. And he actually should do more hooks. Other than that, no, he should just stick to rapping. I'm sorry.

[_Hawk_]

Can he sing smoothly any more? I remember and Hailie's Song are pretty smooth, whereas 'You're Never Over' sounds quite rough (perhaps purposeful). It throws the question: is there any auto-tune involved? The original version of Kim is quite different from the album version, and I have yet to see any tangible evidence to show that he re-recorded it.

[Aftermathers]

I've been to an Eminem concert and he actually does Sing his Hooks live. Maybe not for every concert but the when i saw him perform he certaintly did and even when he was Singing live it really did sound good.

[Trimss]

You're Never Over is a bad exemple. Take ''Talk to Me'' or ''The Reunion'', he still has that cool singing voice.

[Aftermathers]

I've been to an Eminem concert and he actually does Sing his Hooks live. Maybe not for every concert but the when i saw him perform he certaintly did and even when he was Singing live it really did sound good.

Yeah, but that isn't similar to SINGING a song like "Hailie's Song". When he does any bridge or any singing-ish hook, he lip synchs.

Are you sure about this cos when i saw him it was at a small venue in Brixton and the Singing seemed real like no way he was lip synching

[_Hawk_]

I've been to an Eminem concert and he actually does Sing his Hooks live. Maybe not for every concert but the when i saw him perform he certaintly did and even when he was Singing live it really did sound good.

Yeah, but that isn't similar to SINGING a song like "Hailie's Song". When he does any bridge or any singing-ish hook, he lip synchs.

Are you sure about this cos when i saw him it was at a small venue in Brixton and the Singing seemed real like no way he was lip synching

You were at the Brixton gig? If I had a time machine that's the venue I would go back to to see him live (other than the show in California back in 2000). It must have been intense being that close to him and Dre.

[tadpole25]

layering the vocals is not the same as autotuning them.

[BigBoss]

He could, DMX has a fucked voice but he did it. (The Rain)