Tracks 1-15 side by side comparison of TES vs Relapse

[M-Pyre]

I like your style, but no!

if your gonna do this then do it properly by putting the same theme-oriented songs together.

like for example:

insane - my dads gone crazy
beautiful - sing for the moment
medicine ball - white america
we made you - without me
dejavu - cleaning out my closet
stay wide awake - square dance
old times sake - business
hello - superman


something like that.

it's hard actually, cause the songs on relapse are mostly humerous and about killing. while the eminem show has it all you know?

[whtcrack]

WHAT??????????
I like this topic, but totally disagree with some of your answers....

I would pick TES on each and every choice except I do like Same Song and Dance better than Say Goodbye to Hollywood, but that is a pretty close contest.... and even on your draws...
I mean really.. BUSINESS is amazing... My Mom is good, but not close to Business
Square Dance is miles ahead of Baghpipes from Baghdad.. real talk
Underground is nice cuz it stands out on Relapse, but really??? Till I Collpase is classic Eminem.. no way that underground is better..
LOL LOL, this ones my favorite.. You really think CAB is better than My Dads Gone Crazy??? thats insane for real
Say what you say is way better than Beautiful....
Deja Vu is nice, but I'd take just Em's opening verse on When the Music Stops over Deja Vu...

Your choices are very strange to me, but hey its what you think.. I really think that you are just really into Relapse right now and that is blinding you.. You've probably heard TES so many times that the songs dont have the effect on you they once did... In like two years you might look back once you've listened to Relapse enough and change your mind on this...

[robollama]

Pretty good but for a couple of them I think you're wrong. IMO for #4 Square Dance wins, #5 Hello wins, #7 Drips wins, #14 My Dad's Gone Crazy wins, #15 Till I Collapse wins.

[Robbie G]

The only possible wins for Relapse are deja vu and just maybe beautiful and my mom.

[Jagsphan]

This is what i think:
1. White America vs 3 AM- White America TES
2. Business vs My Mom - My Mom Relapse (might be a draw for me)
3. Cleaning out my closet vs Insane- Cleaning out my closet TES
4. Square Dance vs Baghpipes- Square Dance TES
5. Solder vs Hello- Soldier TES
6. Say goodbye to hollywood vs same song and dance- Say goodbye to hollywood TES
7. Drips vs We Made You- Drips TES (EM's verse on that is sick IMO)
8. Without Me vs Medicine ball - Without Me TES
9. Sing for the moment vs stay wide awake - Draw I can't decide
10. Superman vs Old times sake - Superman TES wins
11. Hailies song vs must be the ganga - Must Be the Ganja Relapse
12. When the music stops vs Dejavu - Deja Vu Relapse
13. Say what you say vs Beautiful - Beautiful Relapse (It is close)
14. My dads gone crazy vs Crack a bottle - My Dads Gone Crazy TES
15. Till I collapse vs undergound. hmmm very hard to pick but I will go with Till I Collapse TES

[Chasingtimeagain]

The only possible wins for Relapse are deja vu and just maybe beautiful and my mom.

100% agree.

And also, the OP's "4. Square Dance vs Baghpipes- draw"...rofl. I really hope that was a joke.

[Slill_Slim_Shady]

I like your style, but no!

if your gonna do this then do it properly by putting the same theme-oriented songs together.

like for example:

insane - my dads gone crazy
beautiful - sing for the moment
medicine ball - white america
we made you - without me
dejavu - cleaning out my closet
stay wide awake - square dance
old times sake - business
hello - superman


something like that.

it's hard actually, cause the songs on relapse are mostly humerous and about killing. while the eminem show has it all you know?

that's the right comparation of the songs

[firepower]

14. My dads gone crazy vs Crack a bottle, to me Relapse wins

CAB over My dads gone crazy?
For that you're a idiot

[Damarkus]

1. White America vs 3 AM- white america
2. Business vs My Mom my mom
3. Cleaning out my closet vs Insane- insane
4. Square Dance vs Baghpipes- square dance
5. Solder vs Hello- soldier
6. Say goodbye to hollywood vs same song and dance- say goodbye
7. Drips vs We Made You- drips
8. Without Me vs Medicine ball - without me
9. Sing for the moment vs stay wide awake - draw
10. Superman vs Old times sake - superman
11. Hallies song vs must be the ganga - hailies song one of my fav
12. When the music stops vs Dejavu - deja vu
13. Say what you say vs Beautiful- say what you say one of the best collabs of all time
14. My dads gone crazy vs Crack a bottle - my dads gone crazy easy
15. Till I collapse vs undergound. oooo very close maybe just underground just

[Fa-Q]

I agree with everything but this

4. Square Dance vs Baghpipes- draw

Theres hardly any thing close to the fire on Square dance

[RealSickLindley]

I don't know how people can even compare these two albums, different times, different topics, we were all at a different age, different time passed for the albums for us to get to grips with them.


Let's compare it to Thriller while we're at, mayswell