My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy vs Recovery

[UnIquEEniGma]

While Eminem skill wise & lyrically destroys Kanye anyday...the production on MBDTF and the way he gets back at all the haters really does make me prefer it to recovery. Thoughts?

[Cube23]

My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy is so much better that this comparison is laughable.

[FreeSpeech]

While Eminem skill wise & lyrically destroys Kanye anyday...the production on MBDTF and the way he gets back at all the haters really does make me prefer it to recovery. Thoughts?

Discussed a million times, this debate will be pointless.It all comes down to taste and Em and Kanye aren't really similar enought to compare.

Now everybody proceed to get all pissy at each other...

[shadyboymez]

2 great albums, but artistically MBDTF takes it (though it may have been a tad overrated by the industry)

[slimshadylappin]

While Eminem skill wise & lyrically destroys Kanye anyday...the production on MBDTF and the way he gets back at all the haters really does make me prefer it to recovery. Thoughts?

Im sorry are you saying that production and getting back at haters is more important then lyrics and flow.
Think before you post shit

[StoneyLodge]

2 great albums, but artistically MBDTF takes it

[Berry]

My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy is so much better that this comparison is laughable.

IT IS SO MUCH BETTER * cue over-the-top poncey English laughter*

[UnIquEEniGma]

While Eminem skill wise & lyrically destroys Kanye anyday...the production on MBDTF and the way he gets back at all the haters really does make me prefer it to recovery. Thoughts?

Im sorry are you saying that production and getting back at haters is more important then lyrics and flow.
Think before you post shit

Well it's not shit at all. Recoverys production was very average & MBDTF was amazing. Sure the lyrics and flow on recovery were dope, but it doesn't beat MBDTF.

[mdemaz]

What the fuck...
-.- Both are good tbh..

[buffalo bill]

Substance > production

[Rash J]

Funny, I was just listening to Recovery and MBDTF back to back yesterday. Kanye's stood out in terms of production (esp since I listened to Recovery first, MBDTF's beats seemed more amazing) but my personal preference lies with Recovery as it's more enjoyable from start to finish.

[xxTrigger1989xx]

Recovery, lyrically, destroys MBDTF

But MBDTF has got production in the bag

I'm gonna have to be a little bias and say Recovery, because while MBDTF is a modern classic, Recovery's substance wins over MBDTF's production

Both are extremely great albums, but MBDTF bores me at times. Recovery never bores me

[slimshadylappin]

Substance > production

Thank You! Finally someone who thinks straight.

[Ugetnolove]

Both are great albums. But I do prefer the substance>production.

Now an Eminem album mainly produced by Kanye West (provided good chemistry) would equal one of the greatest of all time if we go by both of their strengths and their most recent work.

On a side note- I hope Em goes back to producing some of his own tracks along with the Bass Brothers.

[Cube23]

Substance > production

Wait a minute.. Someone with the name "Buffalo Bill" says that "substance > production"?



Buffalo Bill's substance is incredible, I guess!