Ranking Marshall: Stage 1 - The Marshall Mathers LP

[mrjizzbomber]

Time to rank the second album. Once again, the singles are left out - as the singles will all go head to head with each other.

For an explanation of what I'm trying to do: viewtopic.php?f=3&t=89292
Obviously this won't really settle anything, but we will see what the TR consensus seems to be.

One final thing, I want to give everyone a chance for Recovery to sink in - particularly those who are waiting for June 22nd (fools!). So, I'm not going to post the next poll until Monday, and try to space them out a bit more. Plus, it will give everyone a chance to vote on everything.

Here is the SSLP poll: viewtopic.php?f=3&t=89327

Good Luck!

- The Bomber

[Solace]

Drug Ballad.

[Shit Can Happen]

I am so torn between Kill You and Criminal.

[SliK]

I love this album, GOAT in my opinion.

Who Knew just shits in the face of EVERYONE, and the beat is dope as fuck, he just goes so hard here.

"It'll make you go get a gun and shoot at a cop
I just said it, I ain't know if you'd do it or not"

"I'm sorry there must a mix-up
You want me to fix up lyrics
while the president gets his dick sucked?"

So many great lines like that, and the song as a whole, it's amazing.

Having said that, Nothing can top The Way I Am. The (genuine) emotion, the flow, the content, the rhymes... And the only song credited only to M. Mathers.

I can't say enough good things about this album, or any of Em's verses.

[OMEGA]

Voted for Marshall Mathers.

PS: Drug Ballad sucks balls

[theJFKshow]

Voted for Marshall Mathers.

PS: Drug Ballad sucks balls

You must not have ears.


Kill You is amazing.

[Solace]

Voted for Marshall Mathers.

PS: Drug Ballad sucks balls

I'm sorry that my music taste isn't good enough for you, master.

[DƎRDYPK]

Drug Ballad

[OMEGA]

I didn't say it because of you, apprentice.

Never liked that song, never will. Rae ruined it for me.

[Dazed]

Marshall Mathers

[Solace]

I didn't say it because of you, apprentice.

Never liked that song, never will. Rae ruined it for me.

Doubt you would've mentioned it unless someone else said it was their favorite among a bunch of songs you think shit on it.

But whatever.

[ku53v]

criminal

[Edge]

im drunk... but im gunna say it regardless... everyone always says how this is his best.... i feel like the eminem show is so much better... fuck it, its still to early to say it but im gunna anyhow... recovery is better than this.... *waits for abuse*

[SliK]

im drunk... but im gunna say it regardless... everyone always says how this is his best.... i feel like the eminem show is so much better... fuck it, its still to early to say it but im gunna anyhow... recovery is better than this.... *waits for abuse*

i respect your opinion but disagree

[macdaddy019967]

Marshall Mathers