Recovery or Eminem Show?

[Drucifer]

Little to early to tell, but I can say honestly say theres nothing on this album thats annoying, Like Buisnes and Without Me........Never liked them joints, I just gotta let the album settle in before I decide if the highs on recovery can touch the highs on TES.......I do like Ems Ozzy remake about as much as his aerosmith remake tho

[DƎRDYPK]

Erm.

I think they're just too different. Recovery is far more experimental. TES is pure workoholic beauty though.

TES was my fave Em album. Probably still is at the moment, it's too hard to rate Recovery against it at this point. Need it to sink in.

Exactly what he said
I was waiting for this thread though

[Le Tunisien]

for me its

MArshall Mathers lp
The Eminem Show
Recovery
The Slim Shady LP

[dbeauluvswomen]

Recovery. I'm not a big fan of The Eminem Show. When I got to song 3 I already knew I liked it better.

[Trey]

It's such a hard choice for me.... Give me a year or so and I can give a definite answer so:

Marshall Mathers LP
Recovery/Eminem Show
SSLP
Relapse
Encore
Infinite

[Jimmy Conway]

1.Eminem Show
2.Marshall Mathers LP
3.Recovery
4.Slim Shady LP
5.Relapse
6.Encore
7.Infinite

[Mxracer6y]

That's an easy question. Eminem show. This one did not really live up to expectations really.

you're right... it absolutely blew expectations out of the water

[Dnvl]

ES

[Bistnal]

Too hard to decide. Right now I'm biased towards recovery cause its new. Granted, some of my still all time fav. Em songs are on TES. I'll make a final decision in a few months/weeks lol.

[Drama Setter]

Too soon to answer it should stick in your head

[James Deuce]

It's pretty early, but most likely in the end of it all, I'd rate The Eminem Show higher.

[slimsoxshady]

i'm still patiently waiting for the REAL haters to show up...so far it's been a few people that didn't really like the album as much as all of us, but i'm still waiting for someone to really trash Recovery

should be good...

[Norway kills]

I really like that smilie. It's not really caring about anything else but that snack, and at the same time, it point's an interested ear in our direction.

[macdaddy019967]

i'm still patiently waiting for the REAL haters to show up...so far it's been a few people that didn't really like the album as much as all of us, but i'm still waiting for someone to really trash Recovery

should be good...

oh if your waiting for haters just wait for the Review for the album on the hip hop site HIPHOPDX
because those dudes always rating eminem's shit real low

[paradigmal]

Not even close, The Eminem Show.

There's something that JUST cannot be denied : where's the versatility in flow? He has the same flow/voice on more than half the records on there. Every flow and voice tone were different in The Eminem Show, that's why it's untouchable.

/sigh. Did you hear how people were complaining about his angry voice? accent? etc etc? People can't make up their fucking minds as to how they want shady to sound. All we hear is QQ. So assuming Em sounded different on Recovery, the forums will be like ," Yo son, Em was using a squeaky voice on track 2, he sounded angry on 3, fragile on 4, singing on 5, and Nasal on 6" I think he hit recovery perfectly. It is THE 2010 Eminem show. He shows emotion on Recovery, you just have to LISTEN to the album. Right now, we all got taken by surprise. We have listened to he album, but we haven't HEARD it. TES did not have the appeal the first day that I listened to it compared to months later.