Marshall Mathers LP vs Recovery - (Track by Track)

[tross840]

thank you, i swear some of yall need to go listen to SSLP and MMLP again (its seems most of you still listen to TES) those albums were absolutely ridiculous. If MMLP came out today we would be going APE SHIT.

[Kez]

thank you, i swear some of yall need to go listen to SSLP and MMLP again (its seems most of you still listen to TES) those albums were absolutely ridiculous. If MMLP came out today we would be going APE SHIT.

And i swear "some of yall" need to stop shoving your fucking opinions down peoples' throats

[slimsoxshady]

just listened to MMLP for the first time in about a year this evening
Recovery >>>>>> MMLP
it's not really that close for me either, and i've been listening to Em since the My Name Is video and witnessed the rise and the downfall and everything in between

TES is probably unbeatable for me as far as Eminem albums though

[Shit Can Happen]

I love how people think the best song is automatically whichever song has the superior rhymes and wordplay. Like there's nothing more to it and no emotional factor whatsoever.

[slimsoxshady]

I love how people think the best song is automatically whichever song has the superior rhymes and wordplay. Like there's nothing more to it and no emotional factor whatsoever.

exactly

[Emadyville]

just listened to MMLP for the first time in about a year this evening
Recovery >>>>>> MMLP
it's not really that close for me either, and i've been listening to Em since the My Name Is video and witnessed the rise and the downfall and everything in between

TES is probably unbeatable for me as far as Eminem albums though

I feel like the past 4 to 5 days, I have been agreeing with everything you say. And I, once again, have to agree with this statement entirely.

And we need to stop comparing songs to songs based on track numbers, it's just stupid sometimes, most of the time the songs are completely different

[slimsoxshady]

just listened to MMLP for the first time in about a year this evening
Recovery >>>>>> MMLP
it's not really that close for me either, and i've been listening to Em since the My Name Is video and witnessed the rise and the downfall and everything in between

TES is probably unbeatable for me as far as Eminem albums though

I feel like the past 4 to 5 days, I have been agreeing with everything you say. And I, once again, have to agree with this statement entirely.

And we need to stop comparing songs to songs based on track numbers, it's just stupid sometimes, most of the time the songs are completely different

you're probably about my age then...22?

[eminemshailie]

Kill You vs Cold Wind Blows
Stan vs Talking 2 Myself
Who Knew vs On Fire
The Way I Am vs Wont Back Down
The Real Slim Shady vs WTP
Remember Me vs Going Through Changes
I'm Back vs Not Afraid
Marshall Mathers vs Seduction
Drug Ballad vs No Love
Amityville vs Space Bound
Please 2 vs Cinderella Man
Kim vs 25 To Life
Under The Influence vs So Bad
Criminal vs Almost Famous
The Kids vs Love the Way You Lie
9-3. Mmlp wins

[Sam.]

Kill You vs Cold Wind Blows
Stan vs Talking 2 Myself
Who Knew vs On Fire
The Way I Am vs Wont Back Down
The Real Slim Shady vs WTP
Remember Me vs Going Through Changes
I'm Back vs Not Afraid
Marshall Mathers vs Seduction
Drug Ballad vs No Love
Amityville vs Space Bound
Please 2 vs Cinderella Man
Kim vs 25 To Life
Under The Influence vs So Bad
Criminal vs Almost Famous
The Kids vs Love the Way You Lie
9-3. Mmlp wins

well hello mister fancy pants

[ShadyVsEminem]

Off the list going through changes,space bound and 25 to life are the only one`s on Recovery id prefer

[slimshadylappin]

lol at some people saying Not Afraid > Im Back and almost as bad Kill You > Cold Wind Blows

[slimshadylappin]

lol at some people saying Not Afraid > Im Back and almost as bad Kill You > Cold Wind Blows

Not Afraid>>>Im Back
Kill You>>Cold Wind Blows


LOL at random member with random bump.

do u actually think that

[slimshadylappin]

Not Afraid>>>Im Back
Kill You>>Cold Wind Blows


LOL at random member with random bump.

do u actually think that

Yes. Im not saying it just to upset you. I actually enjoy listening to Not Afraid more than Im Back. I LOVE Im Back, but I LOVE Not Afraid more. Its ok, I have an opinion.

It is one thing to like a song more.

Its another to say that its better. I enjoy listening to Like Toy Soldiers more then SWA yet Stay Wide Awake is a better song

Im Back is miles ahead of Not Afraid no matter how much u enjoy listening to it

[VenomBlackViper]

Out of this i'd choose every song on MMLP over the Recovery song they were pitted against.

[slimshadylappin]

Out of this i'd choose every song on MMLP over the Recovery song they were pitted against.

This except I would put GTC over Remember Me

The rest isn't even close