by EminemBase » Jun 28th, '10, 22:33
Probably not as his music is too confrontational and divisive.
There will always be people for example that think he's homophobic because they're too stupid to understand what he's doing and they never actually listen to what he's saying anyway. They just read a few headlines and make up their mind.
Also, MJ was a pop star. Eminem makes hip-hop and always has, to the core. Other rappers who have a problem with him like to call him a pop star but in reality, that's nonsense. Pop is its own genre. You're not a pop star because you're a popular artist. Eminem is a RAP star because he makes rap music, period.
Because of that, hip-hop will never be as... Easy to swallow as pop for most. It's a harsher music made mainly from harsh times. It's got grungy overtones and is full of individual opinions, where as pop is literally watered down for the masses. It's purposely drained of these qualities for the sake of being as accepted by as many people as possible.
So no, Em will never be an MJ for those reasons.
But that's the way it should be. Given what he does and how he does it, it's only right it should be that way. Like Gervais said - If you're doing anything right as an artist, you should assume as many people hate what you're doing as love it. Being safe, is not artistic. MJ is called an artist because he was very unique of course. He was an immortal dancer and was also involved with a lot of his visuals so in that sense he was an artist and it's what helped craft his iconic status.
But in terms of true artistry, with music; Eminem is the more reputable candidate for a legendary artist. MJ turned entertainment into an art. Eminem turns his thoughts into an art, he's been playing puppet master with the minds of millions for so long, to such a brilliant degree. He's much more impressive in that sense. What MJ did required a lot of practice but what Em does requires not only a lot of practice but consistent, individualistic, intellectual innovation. It's as good as your brain can make it. But what he does doesn't agree with everybody, it's not sugorcoated.