Koolo2010 wrote:the ONLY stupid and weird cut...was eminem fallin throught that window...... if he had a shotgun..i could understand...but a revolver? wtf,.,,,
otherwise..the video is dope...
maybe that was a strong ass revolver
Koolo2010 wrote:the ONLY stupid and weird cut...was eminem fallin throught that window...... if he had a shotgun..i could understand...but a revolver? wtf,.,,,
otherwise..the video is dope...
EminemBase wrote:legokiba213 wrote:No, it's not true until proven false lmao. The burden of proof is on those who make the wild claim not those who believe reality.
It can't mean anything you want, you can believe that it does but that doesn't make it fact.
From the lyrics and video, the song is about a relationship with a woman, who he finds out is cheating and so kills her, and then commits suicide.
The lyrics and video PROVE that is the content. Anything OUTSIDE of that has to be absolutely proven true, or it's false and total speculation. There is no evidence for it meaning anything else, other than that. All these theories are using totally unsupported basis', guesswork and jumps.
So, until the artist says it's something more than it appears, it is what it appears. Especially with Eminem, and recent Em. People thinking he's that complex now are funny. It's a simplistic love story, just like "Love the Way You Lie". It's emotional content, not complex, metaphorical content.
Exactly, you can make it out to what you want it to be and you find your own proof so therefore fact in your eyes. You interpret the lyrics in your own way and what makes sense to you. Like WilyMo021 he saw in the video HIS interpretation of the video and now he believes that is what the video is about and do you have a statement from EM proving that he did not make the video the way WilyMo021 states it to be? But then again everyone is entitled to their own opinion and this is mine and you have yours.
That doesn't make it a FACT though. A fact is something that can be PROVEN with indisputable evidence and clearly observed outside of metaphor or individual interpretation.
I could personally believe The Simpsons is written by Al Sharpton, that the world is triangle and we've been lied to and that my skin is bullet proof, my belief doesn't make these things facts though does it. It makes them totally unfounded personal beliefs.
And any interpretation, outside of reality and what Eminem is clearly communicating (very clearly) and showing is a personal belief. Not a fact, and not reality. So sure, believe it's about whatever you like, but you cannot say that it actually is, or that it's just as true. As it's not.
One claim, that it's about a relationship where he finds out his girlfriend is cheating, kills her then himself is the REALITY. That is backed up by overwhelming evidence. Every single thing he says in the song, every lyric communicates that and the video then coincides with the lyrics exactly, to convey the exact thing that he is talking about.
Any other claim, is imaginary and unfounded. So until you can prove it with reality, and not wild leaps and guesswork and personal wishful thinking and links you're creating yourself, it's not reality. And it's not 'as true' or 'as possible' as the clear, obvious reality.
legokiba213 wrote:I can see what you're saying and just to let you know I agree with you on what the song is about it's just about a relationship and nothing more in my eyes but my interpretation is not some one else's so I was just trying to communicate to you that what you believe this song is about is not what someone else believe this song is about but that doesn't mean either of you are wrong. it is just an interpretation of what you believe the lyrics/video to be about but of course it is just speculation you yourself have no proof that the song is about a relationship and not a metaphor for his drug addiction. The interpretation of music is never proof just pure speculation.
Menzo wrote:WilyMo021 wrote:Why the wolf?
To correlate to his lonely state of being - a lone wolf.
EminemBase wrote:legokiba213 wrote:I can see what you're saying and just to let you know I agree with you on what the song is about it's just about a relationship and nothing more in my eyes but my interpretation is not some one else's so I was just trying to communicate to you that what you believe this song is about is not what someone else believe this song is about but that doesn't mean either of you are wrong. it is just an interpretation of what you believe the lyrics/video to be about but of course it is just speculation you yourself have no proof that the song is about a relationship and not a metaphor for his drug addiction. The interpretation of music is never proof just pure speculation.
No but what you're not getting is... it's not 'my' interpretation that the song is about that. It's the obvious reality! I didn't create this theory. The lyrics and video convey this story, not in my eyes, in the eyes of logic!.
I'm not connecting dots or inventing things, every single thing in the lyrics, logically conveys it's a song about a relationship, where he kills a woman and then himself. Anybody who understands English, is not retarded and can hear, can hear that.
It's like saying... that it's a personal interpretation that The Godfather is about an Italian mob family. No, that's the reality. That's what you can see, and what is clear.
So anything outside of that, outside of the reality, is a personal interpretation that is unfounded. Anything outside of it IS wrong, until proven right. As there's no reasons to believe it's true, no objective, provable, logical reasoning to it. So it's unfounded.
Where as the clear, obvious and intended storyline of "Space Bound" is visually and obviously apparent without the need of explanation. It is what it is. Would you say it's a 'personal interpretation' that "Stan" is about a crazed Eminem fan that kills himself... and that anybody who believes it's something else (anything else) is just as correct? that's silly.
WilyMo021 wrote:For the sake of discussion.
Do you not agree there are hints of a double meaning? Why would the girl have a gun? Why the wolf? Why even bother with the shot of the coffee cup overflowing? Why the approach they took at all when making this music video, pretty odd for a simple relationship song.
WilyMo021 wrote:Saying that Em doesn't think like this (I'm not sure what you actually said, so forgive me) is a bit unfair to him, the man who also created 25 to Life. Granted, in 25 to Life the comparison was more obvious, and he tells us at the end that "she" is hip hop, but that is also one of the biggest complaints listeners have for the song. Telling us that x stands for y takes away some of the magic. It makes the song less artsy, enjoyable, and relatable.
WilyMo021 wrote:Also, I think your comparison about the world being a triangle is a bit unfair, I do believe that there is enough in the song and the music video for the listener to atleast flirt with the possibility of a metaphor.
WilyMo021 wrote:A lot of the fun in music, art in general is had through ambiguous pieces. Each listener takes what they want from the piece, which is the beauty of art. (More of a general statement for the sake of blowing hot air, I realize you know this)
WilyMo021 wrote:Anyways, just having a little fun with the video. I didn't mean to sound condescending at all during that post, as I have a great deal of respect for you.
Like I said, for the sake of discussion.
BILI wrote:I just want to say that Ems acting was nice...he can pull another movie
EminemBase wrote:BILI wrote:I just want to say that Ems acting was nice...he can pull another movie
Yeah.
And watching this makes me realize how well he's pulled of 'mature rapping'. He's kind of the first to make rapping this mature / adult from my knowledge.
As, the language is just like normal language, not 'rapper' language and it's just like a real story being told, in an adult way by an adult narrator. Sounds real-life too. Doesn't even really feel like rap, just feels like music. And a little piece of art.
And he just seems / looks like a serious, grown-up actor in a little storytelling video. Rather than a middle-aged rapper trying to pull off something past his age, which is what you'd assume he'd sound / look like at this point.
Pulled it off well as, I never would of imagined back in the day that the guy rapping "My Name Is" could still be rapping authentically at 38 and not looking or sounding stupid. Especially as he's white which sounds weird but just the idea of a near 40 year old white guy rapping seems ridiculous. And yet, he looks fine.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users