(poll2)When i'm gone vs Beautiful?

[Stanforever]

what is your pick?

tough one for me.but i'll go with when i'm gone.

for poll4
http://forum.trshady.com/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=143522

for poll3
http://forum.trshady.com/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=143486&p=1859580

for poll1
http://forum.trshady.com/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=143399

[Sergio M.]

For me, Beautiful.

[Mathers]

This one's hard, I'll vote for When I'm Gone.

[Amaranthine]

Holy shit, I have no idea. They're tied for me.

[Stanforever]

^make up your mind.

On the other thread people were like when i'm gone>>.so i tried to give a tough competition.
still looks a bit one sided.

[Guess_Who]

I voted "When I'm gone" but it's pretty close for me.

[KingDavid]

beautiful because it helped me through rough times and is more meaningful to me altho i love both

[mecuryball]

When I'm Gone >>>

[BigBoss]

Beautiful.

[LK5]

Quite a tough comparison. I chose Beautiful. However When I'm Gone video is much better.

[mecuryball]

beautiful because it helped me through rough times and is more meaningful to me altho i love both

yeah Beautiful is more meaningful,but musically,When I'm Gone is the better song imo.It was well crafted from the melodic beat to the story telling,then the hook.Eminem's delivery in this particular song is one of his best imho.

[IcedSlim Shady]

I think beautiful is almost as good as Lose yourself..the beat is just great and 3rd verse is awesome. So i voted for Beautiful..

[Kill You]

Actually a great question...I feel Beautiful was executed better though so that one.

[the real slim shady]

I went for Beautiful... theyre both good, but Beautiful is better in my opinion

[JustEnjoytheMusic]

I voted for Beautiful, but I love both.

The When I'm gone chorus chokes me up every time.