The Eminem Show Vs. Recovery (track by track) 'game'

[Heffernan]

white america vs. cold wind blows
business vs. talking to myself
cleaning out my closet vs. on fire (tie...i never liked COMC so much :/ )
square dance vs. wont back down
soldier vs. WTP
say goodbye hollywood vs. going through changes (tie both are amazing)
drips vs. not afraid
without me vs. seduction (tie...dont LOVE either)
sing for the moment vs. no love (i LOVE no love...but SFTM is one of his best ever)
superman vs. space bound
hailies song vs. cinderella man
when the music stops vs. 25 to life
say what you say vs. so bad (tie...ehh)
till i collapse vs. almost famous (til i collapse is obv better...i just cant give almost famous an L..so tie )
my dads gone crazy vs. love the way you lie
stimulate (only TES 'bonus' song i can think of) vs. youre never over (close)
*cant think of a song to put here...* lose yourself vs. here we go
(same era....so fuck it nahmeen)

[Jimmy Conway]

You can't really compare albums like that because Till I collapse is better than almost famous, but almost famous is still an amazing song.

After listening to Recovery basically every day since it has leaked I decided to listen to the Eminem Show.

After listening I just can't believe how good the Eminem Show is. I like Relapse, but The Eminem Show is amazing. Might be the best rap record to ever be released. And the fact that Em produced basically by himself is even more impressive.

[Jimmy Conway]

didnt we do this already?

This is a thread from a few days ago. I must of missed one that had more replies. But the "this thread has been made" thing is kind of lame. I mean I understand the frustration. But when a board gets as much traffic as this one does, you kind of have to expect it. I would rather have duplicate threads than the board be dead.

[Jimmy Conway]

lol nah im not pissed or anything i just thought ive seen it before

Hmm...you probably have. Easy to get lost in the flood of stans I suppose. I really enjoy the beats on Eminem Show. I went a few years there when I didn't listen to Eminem at all. But still, this album came out about seven years ago and it all still seems so fresh. The replay value on this album is nice. I'm not sure Recovery will hold up that well for me. Obviously a little early to say though.

[slimsoxshady]

^ Drips over Not Afraid?

[Jimmy Conway]

^ Drips over Not Afraid?

I would agree with that too. I like the beat on drips better and Em's verse is fire. Obie Trice makes me want to fall asleep, but the entire not afraid song makes me want to pass out from boredom.

[Jimmy Conway]

I think it would be more interesting to make a list of each album from best to worth and compare those side by side. I might do that.

[slimsoxshady]

white america vs. cold wind blows
business vs. talking to myself
cleaning out my closet vs. on fire
square dance vs. wont back down
soldier vs. WTP
say goodbye hollywood vs. going through changes
drips vs. not afraid
without me vs. seduction
sing for the moment vs. no love
superman vs. space bound
hailies song vs. cinderella man
when the music stops vs. 25 to life
say what you say vs. so bad
till i collapse vs. almost famous
my dads gone crazy vs. love the way you lie
stimulate vs. you're never over
i'm just gonna leave untitled off

TES---------6
Recovery----9

TES isn't as invincible as I thought it was
next up, Tech N9ne - Everready

[classthe_king]

white america vs. cold wind blows
business vs. talking to myself
cleaning out my closet vs. on fire
square dance vs. wont back down
soldier vs. WTP
say goodbye hollywood vs. going through changes
drips vs. not afraid
without me vs. seduction
sing for the moment vs. no love
superman vs. space bound
hailies song vs. cinderella man
when the music stops vs. 25 to life
say what you say vs. so bad
till i collapse vs. almost famous
my dads gone crazy vs. love the way you lie
stimulate vs. you're never over

Not even close for me

[14Shots]

it would make more sense to rate each song from each album from best to worst and then compare them.

[OMEGA]

I already did it, and Recovery stumps all over TES.

[classthe_king]

Wait was Stimulate an official bonus track of TES? I wasnt even aware of a deluxe edition.

No it wasn't, it was an 8-Mile bonus track. It was just originally intended to be on TES

[slimsoxshady]

can't believe all ya'll picking halie's song over cinderella man

[Jimmy Conway]

Eminem Show vs Recovery

1. Till I Collapse vs Almost Famous
2. Soldier vs Seduction
3. Square Dance vs Cinderalla Man
4. White America vs Talking To Myself
5. Business vs Space Bound
6. Cleanin Out My Closet vs 25 to life
7. Sing For The Moment vs On Fire
8. Say Goodbye To Hollywood vs Cold Wind Blows
9. Superman vs Going Through Changes
10. My Dad's Gone Crazy vs You're Never Over
11. When The Music Stops vs Love The Way You Lie
12. Say What You Say vs No Love
13. Halie's Song vs So Bad
14. Without Me vs WTP
15. Drips VS Not Afraid


I might edit this 20 times and still not be happy with it.

[classthe_king]

I love Hailies song