Revolutionary wrote:Don't forget that the label had control over Em from the very first album.
But back then he was in a more hungry mind-state and made anthems like My Name Is and TRSS.
They only asked him to make something that the radio will play and he gave them those 2 songs, they didn't bother controlling the content so he clearly had full creative control.
So yeah, I do think they affected Em's direction but they had no control over the details of the project.
Like, they asked him to do something else other than Relapse, something that people might be able to enjoy more but they didn't tell him how to write things or what to write about. Not Afraid and LTWYL were clearly made because Em wanted to make them but the label might have made him work with producers that were hot at the moment.
Again, the label doesn't care about the details. They just want shit that's marketable, but because Em is better than most rappers, he doesn't compromise, he goes into an alternative road to reach his original destination (theme).
They didn't really have control though...
They trust him to do his shit as... they didn't know, and he was under the tutelage of Dr. Dre who had much success already, and they were trying to enter a new phase, so they let it organically happen; they didn't make him make "My Name Is" - that was simply an accidental hit which Em then used as a formula for his future lead singles. The Slim Shady LP is 100% pure; completely unfiltered concepts, lyrics and beats from Em, Bass Bros and Dr. Dre.
Then you have MMLP - the only compromised song is 'Real Slim Shady', but the only pressure they put on was for him to have a hit single to accompany the album... and I mean, any label wants that, that's a given, they're a business, they need shit to blow up and make money...
But they didn't control his content or effect the album in any other way, and RSS still totally fits the album, he just broadened himself a little bit, and made it catchier and more condensed - and exactly the same formula with TES but again, still ALL him, and so is Encore and so is Relapse.
Recovery is the first Eminem album with true outside influence on his actual perspective, lyrics, concepts and production; up until that point - it was all him and his team, which includes Dre; they made pure hip-hop - good or bad, we got what Em wanted us to get.
Recovery is a good album but I don't think it's a coincidence he just happened to work with the hottest producers AND hottest guest stars at the time and of the last couple of years... and whilst Em himself could of course have chosen to do that... (and ultimately, he did... it's not like he HAD to do it) - seems like a suggestion to make a broader, more worldwide album...
Tarantino said what movie studios will do is, not force him to work with people but just be like... "is there any reason you don't wanna work with x, as he's hot right now' etc. - so I'd imagine somehow that, that's the kind of discussions the label may have had with Em like "okay, Relapse did okay but it dropped off quick and got a mixed reaction with mediocre hits... is there any reason you don't wanna work with... Wayne, get some of these hot new producers etc.?"
And then maybe Em thought "okay yeah fuck it, I'm in my late 30s, I could be out of touch and fuck this all up, leme see what happens"... I'm completely speculating of course but from what he's said and from what we know... this seems like the most likely reality to me...
Prior to this - he just basically got pressure to make another hit, but they didn't actually care about the rest of the album or his style or his producers etc. as it had all worked in a BIG way, up until Relapse.