this gave me a laugh

[,-,'-{Bar}-',-,]

ok now think about this


Rolling stones magazine gave 50 cents new album 3.5/5

Rolling Stones Magazine Gave The Eminem Show 4/5

so theres only half a star bewtween Curtis and Eminem Show


really how the fuck can you justifie that lmao

[Big Proof 4ever]

they are really stupid then,eminem show 9----curtis3

[stevethetruth]

that is pretty fucked up for real, they need to shut up and do the reviews right

[4D]

ok now think about this


Rolling stones magazine gave 50 cents new album 3.5/5

Rolling Stones Magazine Gave The Eminem Show 4/5

so theres only half a star bewtween Curtis and Eminem Show


really how the fuck can you justifie that lmao

thats why ive never understod 5 ratings. 10 should always be the way its done because it showas a beter scale

Yeah 5 stars or mic's is shit. has to be 10, then we get a better idea about the gap between albums.

[Tash8]

yea w/e, rolling stone magazine doesn't mean shit, it's just what some critics thing, we know that TES was 100 times better. so who cares... I honestly didn't think Curtis deserved 1 star..

[mart85]

lol yeah, both albums aren't even in the same league... but it all depends on what they're judging when they're reviewing albums... I don't know that magazine a lot, but I think they're more like "pop music" reviewers, I mean, mainstream music.... so maybe lyrics aren't that important for them, and they're judging the overall product, how it sounds like...

like for example, movies, some people are real serious movie critics judging character development, camera angles etc... I'm not an expert with that but you know, the technical side and stuff etc... and other reviewers are giving their opinion on how entertaining a movie is... there's nothing wrong with both, it's just 2 different things... and it's the same thing with music I guess

[oOSporkOo]

You have to take into consideration the type of music that was around when eminem show dropped and now curtis. Im sure the critic doesnt have the exact same state of mind that he did back when eminem show dropped as he does now.

[Nu Syd]

all opinions,i never read reviews, i make up my own mind on things like that.

[jBouchh]

it should be out of 100 tbh, cuz then theres more differences between music

[,-,'-{Bar}-',-,]

lol yeah, both albums aren't even in the same league... but it all depends on what they're judging when they're reviewing albums... I don't know that magazine a lot, but I think they're more like "pop music" reviewers, I mean, mainstream music.... so maybe lyrics aren't that important for them, and they're judging the overall product, how it sounds like...

like for example, movies, some people are real serious movie critics judging character development, camera angles etc... I'm not an expert with that but you know, the technical side and stuff etc... and other reviewers are giving their opinion on how entertaining a movie is... there's nothing wrong with both, it's just 2 different things... and it's the same thing with music I guess

yeh ive seen that with movie reviews alot, so your probly right

[Slimm]

yea its weird cus curtis > eminem show

HAHAHA

-.-

i mean yea the scale of 10 is better

[Curtis]

Has to be 100.

[jBouchh]

i didnt laugh. =/

[navysealkid14]

2 words: man down

[shady4life!]

i hate it when that happens. It pissed the shit outta me. And believe me it happens a lot. Especially with Wii games on Gamespot. Sometimes i wish that i cud pull out a gun and just shoot the bastard who makes fucked up reviews like that and post them on the net for everyone to see. 50 Cents album is fuckin borin. Just a few alright tracks. I cud fall asleep listinin to that thing. and they gave it 3.5. Haha yeah right way over rated. And the Eminem Show was a great album and sold the most in that year,and they gave it a 4. Definitly underated. And its not funny at all but instead frustratin and annoyin, to see somethin good get so little recognition, and somethin bad, more publicity than it deserves. Wat a pitty...