FalseProphet wrote:So I'm not trying to get anyone riled up by asking this, but at the time wasn't the general reaction on here to Relapse a disappointment?
Was the reaction to Recovery even worse? I'm seriously asking because when Relapse came out I was reading this forum all the time, so I saw the reactions as they came out - but with Recovery I wasn't reading here at the time, so I missed all of the first reactions. I liked Recovery a lot more than Relapse, when did it become a negative thing for him to sound "Recovery'ish" with new stuff? Is it just that it was 3 years ago and it's time for something new? Or did people on here really view Recovery as a step in the wrong direction?
For me at least, Recovery was so much more commercial and accessible than Relapse. It was an easier listen the first go-round. But it got old. Quick. The screaming, the corny punchlines and cheap production, the inspirational "take my hand and follow me" shit just got annoying, and it didn't sound like the Eminem we'd all come to know and love.
Relapse, on the other hand, was a bit of a disappointment for me at first. The accents and subject matter kinda threw me for a loop. However, as time passed and I gave it more listens, the accents became less of a problem for me, and the unbelievable writing/production took center stage and made me fall in love with the album. I don't think the people that hate on Relapse ever really gave it much of a chance. But I've come to love it almost in its entirety. It has waaaaaaay more personality than Recovery and it seemed more genuine. Seems like that was the album Eminem truly wanted to make at the time. Recovery seemed more forced.
Anyway, Relapse > Recovery, all day

Somebody dropped me on my head and I'm for sure
That my mother did it but the bitch won't admit it was her
I slit her stomach open with a scalpel when she was six months
And said "I'M READY NOW BITCH!! AIN'T YOU FEELIN THESE KICKS CUNT?!
