I wonder how Em got away with...

[Trimss]

One of the most disgusting hook I've ever heard

[Jaba]

I will say he does have annoying puns in Recovery. Its like he wanted to rap like Lil Wayne or people like that, Not LIKE THEM, but LIKE THEIR STYLE. Uhhhh so annoying...

[Jaba]

see, the problem is that Lil Wayne is a great Lil Wayne (or at least he still was around that time), but Eminem is a completely pathetic Lil Wayne.

Welp, Lil Wayne being a good Lil Wayne still means he sucks ass. And Eminem wasnt a bad Lil Wayne but that just wasnt his style and it sounded wierd. DAMN he still had SOME annoying puns on HTS.

[Raul]

One of the most disgusting hook I've ever heard

[Jaba]

if you're one of those irrationally anti-Wayne stans, i'm not going to waste my time arguing this. i used to think he sucked too, but if you haven't heard Tha Carter albums, the first three are great and the fourth one still has some really good material. it's much better than Recovery. listen to those with an open mind before you say he "sucks ass" even at his best.

wait ... so Eminem wasn't bad at that style, but it wasn't his style, it sounded weird, and he relied too heavily on annoying puns? alrighty then.

Waynes first few Carters were good. But as a rapper, and even those albums, he isnt realy to good compared to people like Em, Kendrick, Nas, etc.

[Raul]

TC3 and TC2 > Recovery > TCIV

[Jaba]

TC3 and TC2 > Recovery > TCIV

Nah, not IMO. But I AM a pretty biased Stan. I love all Ems albums with a burning passion so... yeah.

[Jaba]

imo

TC2 > TC3 >>> TCIV >>>>>>>>>> [...] Recovery

LOL, TCIV SUCKED!

[Raul]

imo

TC2 > TC3 >>> TCIV >>>>>>>>>> [...] Recovery

TCIV had TOO MUCH shit songs. It has some good tracks, but the majority is wack. High points on Recovery are 10/10, best tracks on TCIV don't come close to that.

[Solace]

TC3 and TC2 > Recovery > TCIV

I can agree with this honestly

[Raul]

the high points on recovery are 8/10 at best

GTC and Almost Famous disagree

[kkaniff]

Probably the same way he got away with Kim, or the Ken Kaniff skit on MMLP, or any other off-the-wall artistic decision he has ever made; by not listening to whatever the less talented weed-carriers have to say about creativity.
I might be wrong, though.
Also, lol at the Carter 3/Recovery comparison.

[kkaniff]

@Menzo
Says you.
I'm pretty sure some people think it's as horrible as I/we think YNO is.

[slims]

they are definitely worlds apart.

[cement]

Kim is to me one of the best songs on one of the greatest albums ever