by 4Corners » Sep 1st, '13, 15:05
Let me put it to you like this.......we are so infatuated with the work Eminem did on his first 3 major label albums, which is where he crafted 3 classics, that no matter how dope MMLP2 or any Eminem album is, it could never match those. Same thing with Nas never matching Illmatic or It Was Written, same with Jay never matching Reasonable Doubt, Blueprint, or Black Album.
He's not the same exact guy he was at 26 years old, so the music won't sound the same. So we're always going to have those first 3 albums in our head when we're judging his work. Encore, Relapse, and Recovery work much better when you put those first 3 aside, and just listen to them for what they are. Encore had some good stuff, his worst stuff ever too. Relapse had some good stuff, some whack stuff too. Recovery had some real good stuff, too many girls on the chorus and too much production that doesn't suit Eminem though.
But even Hell the Sequel, which in my opinion was his best effort from start to finish since Eminem Show, is not near a classic. He hasn't really put it all together though since Eminem Show and 8 Mile. HTS came close, but still had a little too much shouting and some production was still off on a few songs. Still though, he spit fire a majority of that cd, Welcome to Hell, Fast Lane, Loud Noises, Living Proof for example. Even Above the Law and Echo, the shouting and the girl chorus worked on these, and even A Kiss had some classic clever shady lines.
But to even get people to potentially think MMLP2 matches his first 3, the album would have to be even better than those, which I don't think he can do. We're so infatuated with those albums that no matter how dope MMLP2 is, we'll never compare them unless it's even better, and I don't think Eminem at 40 can make something that good anymore. He can still make dope stuff, he's never made an album I completely hated at all. I think best case for Em is he makes something dope, something people call a return to that era. It doesn't have to match those 3, but it can build upon his legacy still.