How would you feel if...

[taurmauk]

I've been catching up with alot of hip hop lately other than Eminem and something came to mind. Now I can't claim to know alot about the backstage beefs and in crowds etc. of the scene (it's not really daily news in Scotland lol) but I do notice patterns. Particularly one "pop" guy who got diss'd ALOT in Eminems earlier albums but has been showing up alot on Hip Hop and R'n'B tracks Lately. He started off on some Nelly tracks and Albums (which didn't bother me cos I don't care much for Nelly) then latel started showing up on Snoop's Album, Timbaland and even 50 cent.

So my question is, how would you feel if Justin Timberlake showed up on R2? Would you think it two faced of em? Or something to sell outside his market (like Ayo Technology seemed to be for)? Or would you just not care as long as it was good? After all, take Eminem, the greatest Hook writer of all time and Timberlake, a guy who can fire out a tune and who knows what you would get?

I think, personally, for the sake of the future it would be ok, but at the same time it would shit over great songs like Marshal Mathers :s

[classthe_king]

It would make em a hypocrite and a sellout.

[classthe_king]

It would make em a hypocrite and a sellout.

*thinks about that

yep sounds like something Em'll do

[Ella]

nahh he would neva do that... if he aint working with Madonna he aint woring with JT

[Dark Blue]

i think the song would be good if its prod by timbaland

[taurmauk]

Well after Snoop did it I was like WTF is he doing on a rap album? Then Timbaland did it and I was like... Ok, RnB i get that. Then 50 did it and somehow I wasn't surprised, so unless anyone knows of some behind the scenes personal deal with them is it so far stretched? I mean, Em was all over 50's album I guess with production etc. so he prob met him?

And also, if you want a club track on em's album, as was just said, a collab with timbaland and Timberlake could be ok I guess.

But again, it is sorta two faced. Come to think of it, off the top of my head I can only think of Marshal Mathers and Ain't Nothin' but Music where he mentions him (and just N Sync in MM)

[Emadyville]

nahh he would neva do that... if he aint working with Madonna he aint woring with JT

very good, I agree, and this shit ain't happening so we shouldn't even be discussing this

[gutawafang]

i think the song would be good if its prod by timbaland

this.

[EminemIVLife]

i think the song would be good if its prod by timbaland

this.

that
fuck jt

[Relapse.LP]

I've been catching up with alot of hip hop lately other than Eminem and something came to mind. Now I can't claim to know alot about the backstage beefs and in crowds etc. of the scene (it's not really daily news in Scotland lol) but I do notice patterns. Particularly one "pop" guy who got diss'd ALOT in Eminems earlier albums but has been showing up alot on Hip Hop and R'n'B tracks Lately. He started off on some Nelly tracks and Albums (which didn't bother me cos I don't care much for Nelly) then latel started showing up on Snoop's Album, Timbaland and even 50 cent.

So my question is, how would you feel if Justin Timberlake showed up on R2? Would you think it two faced of em? Or something to sell outside his market (like Ayo Technology seemed to be for)? Or would you just not care as long as it was good? After all, take Eminem, the greatest Hook writer of all time and Timberlake, a guy who can fire out a tune and who knows what you would get?

I think, personally, for the sake of the future it would be ok, but at the same time it would shit over great songs like Marshal Mathers :s

Did you seriously call Eminem the greatest hook writer? With hooks like Just Lose It, I just can't take that statement seriously. Sure, he has great hooks, but the GREATEST of all time? That's hard.

And Timbaland is whack, well, most of his beats. He said it himself, he turned mainstream to get the cash flow. And Eminem + Timbaland = Epic Fail. It wouldn't "mix like two dicks".

Justin Timberlake is another pop sell-out. Hate that fucker.

[EminemIVLife]

eminem is easily the greatest rapper when it comes to hooks. Ever hear the eminem show? I'm not counting guys like akon and nate dog

[EminemIVLife]

I'm curious as to which rapper u think can write better hooks or even has the potential to? usually they just put some rnb singer on the hook which kills hip hop

[Wic Kid]

nahh he would neva do that... if he aint working with Madonna he aint woring with JT

Word.

[Fa-Q]

Greatest Hook writer of all time....uhhh he's good but he's not GOAT because of his hooks

[Alaine]

Em better release that album this year or else we'll have to keep seeing retarded topics + fake tracklists till the end of the year.

Also, Em is not best hook writer. As much as I dislike 50, I think he always has dope hooks.