'The Eminem Show' or 'The Marshall Mathers LP'?

[gutawafang]

Eminem Show without any doubt imo.

[Relapse.LP]

MMLP was Em at his hungriest, imo. He laid down a ladder for himself with SSLP and took himself to the top of the roof with MMLP (lame metaphor...I know). MMLP was that Angry Blonde music we all grew to fucking love and the oldheads grew to hate. Em's most controversial moments spawned from this album...shit was fucking ruthless.

TES was Em's most reflective work to date and was definitely him at his peak of world notoriety. While I love the Eminem Show, the Marshall Mathers LP hands down is my favorite Eminem record and hiphop album of all time (and that beats out a lot of great rap records).

What are the "lot of great rap records" you're saying it beats?

[macdaddy019967]

MMLP it was hard as hell unlike that soft stuff on Eminem Show

[imhavingarelapse]

MMLP it was hard as hell unlike that soft stuff on Eminem Show

Soldier, Till I Collapse, White America, etc. are 'soft' songs?

[macdaddy019967]

MMLP it was hard as hell unlike that soft stuff on Eminem Show

Soldier, Till I Collapse, White America, etc. are 'soft' songs?

no but mockingbird and hailies song are

[imhavingarelapse]

MMLP it was hard as hell unlike that soft stuff on Eminem Show

Soldier, Till I Collapse, White America, etc. are 'soft' songs?

no but mockingbird and hailies song are

Mockingbird wasn't on TES..

Unless your just naming some random 'soft' songs lol. I like the emotional side of Em anyways.

[macdaddy019967]

^^^lol thats true ...i meant hailies song an my dadys gone crazy

[imhavingarelapse]

^^^lol thats true ...i meant hailies song an my dadys gone crazy

Fuck that shit, bitch, eat a motherfuckin' dick
Chew on a prick, and lick a million motherfuckin' cocks per second
I'd rather put out a motherfucking gospel record
I'd rather be a pussy-whipped bitch, eat pussy
And have pussy-lips glued to my face with a clit-ring in my nose

May not be gangster lyrics but not soft either.

[imhavingarelapse]

^^^lol thats true ...i meant hailies song an my dadys gone crazy

"fuck that shit bitch eat a motherfucking dick, chew on a prick & lick a million motherfucking cocks per second."
My Dad's Gone Crazy is by no definition a soft song.

copy cat

[macdaddy019967]

^^^lol thats true ...i meant hailies song an my dadys gone crazy

"fuck that shit bitch eat a motherfucking dick, chew on a prick & lick a million motherfucking cocks per second."
My Dad's Gone Crazy is by no definition a soft song.

compare it to the MMLP tracklisting and it is

[imhavingarelapse]

compare it to the MMLP tracklisting and it is

I think it'd be boring if Em didn' grow as an artist. Each album has had it's own sound, one of the reasons why the man is a genious.

[M-N-M]

Hard choice because I consider them equivalent. Have to go with MMLP by an inch, It's got Drug Ballad.

the eminem show bc it has drips on it..lol

[AliJack]

MMLP is the greatest Eminem album, emotion, attitude, flow, and lyric wise, imo.

[EminemIVLife]

Eminem Show is my favourite album of all time

[rudeawakening101]

MMLP, by far.

SSLP...then TES.

I love all three albums. I love TES. But, MMLP is easily Em's best piece of work. He fully developed after the SSLP -- and came hard. Like other posters have said...he brought everything on that LP: anger, humour, seriousness, and fire.

Classic, classic priceless album.

MMLP = Em in his prime.