Recovery is no better than Relapse

[Berry]

I only read the first post on this thread and i saw:
Not Afraid = We Made You

Exactly. We Made You is far better.

Third verse of Not afraid is enough to show it's a far more meaningful/impressive song than We made you.

[Mikey1990]

Exactly. We Made You is far better.

[MikeNUFC]

3rd verse of Not Afraid is terrible.

More meaningful, yes, but terrible. It's not as impressive becuase the whole song is really poorly written compared to the rest of Recovery and Relapse. (bar one or two Relapse tracks)

LOL at the love Not Afraid gets on here.

I suppose a "hater" who doesnt like Not Afraid can "make like bees with no stingers and drop dead". "Fuck them and feed them beans, they're gassed up." Not Afraid "raises the bar like lifting liquor counters."

[buffalo bill]

Not Afraid and We Made You aren't really directly comparable but WMY is the less embarrassing of the songs. Seriously.

[theJFKshow]

Not Afraid and We Made You aren't really directly comparable but WMY is the less embarrassing of the songs. Seriously.

Yes because a 36 year old rapping with a forced accent about irrelevant celebrities is less embarrassing than a song about personal struggle.

[buffalo bill]

Not Afraid and We Made You aren't really directly comparable but WMY is the less embarrassing of the songs. Seriously.

Yes because a 36 year old rapping with a forced accent about irrelevant celebrities is less embarrassing than a song about personal struggle.

Yes because the actual songs don't matter, you can tell everything about them just by reading someone's one-sentence very general description of them.

[pfati]

no... relapse was ok... definitly not wat i wanted for his comeback... i liked relapse but to say it was better then recovery.... NAHHH SONN,,,
em said this before,, the thing that relapse was missing was emotions.... yeah u got a few sick tracks about killing ppl and pills and shit but that wasnt what made me an eminem fan,,, it was the way that he was able to express his feelings and all kinds of emotions in his songs

dont get me wrong i love his fucked up gettin high doing pills lets get fucked up and kill ppl songs... but they arent what makes me an eminem fan,,, and two of my fave songs from relapse?refill are same song and dance and buffulo bill... ridiculous wordplay.. but they dont compare to alot of the songs on recovery

and now i feel like a huge stan for havin written this post....

[slimsoxshady]

I can't believe people are comparing the quality of We Made You and Not Afraid
We Made You is at most 4/10 song and one of the worst tracks he's ever recorded
Not Afraid on the other hand is 9/10 or 10/10 bangin anthem