Rank Em's Albums...

[nathan123]

SSLP-10/10
TES-10/10
MMLP-9/10
Relapse-6/10
Recovery-6/10
Encore-4/10

u think encore deserves 4 lol?

[Johnny Quid]

1. The Marshall Mathers LP - 10/10
2. The Eminem Show - 9,5/10
3. The Slim Shady LP - 9/10
4. Recovery - 8/10
5. Relapse - 7/10
6. Encore - 6/10

[Shady50]

MMLP 10/10
TES 9.8/10
Recovery 9/10
SSLP 8.6/10
Relapse 7/10
Encore 6/10

[classthe_king]

SSLP-10/10
TES-10/10
MMLP-9/10
Relapse-6/10
Recovery-6/10
Encore-4/10

u think encore deserves 4 lol?

Should it be less?

[313]

Go for, ordering and also marks out of 10. Mine would probably be...

1. The Eminem Show - 10/10
2. The Marshall Mathers LP - 9/10
3. The Slim Shady LP - 9/10
4. Recovery - 7/10
5. Relapse - 7/10
6. Encore - 5/10

I wasn't gonna give TES 10 but, if I don't give that a 10 I don't know if 10 can exist lmao. I'm not saying it's totally perfect but, if anything deserves full marks it's that.

Also, I consider The Marshall Mathers LP a masterpiece and more important, but in terms of just pure musical / lyrical ranking of better and worse, I think TES beats it.

As for the Recovery / Relapse thing... That's hard even now. I don't think they're set-in enough yet. I actually love Relapse, probably more-so than Recovery but... I don't know, as a rounded album, in a list like this I think I'd have to rank Recovery higher.

But Relapse was fucked up by literally two songs. And could of been a classic.

List your rankings...

You said before that for you Recovery is classic. Now only 7/10?

[nathan123]

SSLP-10/10
TES-10/10
MMLP-9/10
Relapse-6/10
Recovery-6/10
Encore-4/10

u think encore deserves 4 lol?

Should it be less?

much less haha

recovery 6 ?

[classthe_king]

Recovery should be less too?

[nathan123]

Recovery should be less too?

c'mon man, give the guy a break

[EminemBase]

Go for, ordering and also marks out of 10. Mine would probably be...

1. The Eminem Show - 10/10
2. The Marshall Mathers LP - 9/10
3. The Slim Shady LP - 9/10
4. Recovery - 7/10
5. Relapse - 7/10
6. Encore - 5/10

I wasn't gonna give TES 10 but, if I don't give that a 10 I don't know if 10 can exist lmao. I'm not saying it's totally perfect but, if anything deserves full marks it's that.

Also, I consider The Marshall Mathers LP a masterpiece and more important, but in terms of just pure musical / lyrical ranking of better and worse, I think TES beats it.

As for the Recovery / Relapse thing... That's hard even now. I don't think they're set-in enough yet. I actually love Relapse, probably more-so than Recovery but... I don't know, as a rounded album, in a list like this I think I'd have to rank Recovery higher.

But Relapse was fucked up by literally two songs. And could of been a classic.

List your rankings...

You said before that for you Recovery is classic. Now only 7/10?

I've never called Recovery a classic.

In fact it was only recently that I made a post saying the sequencing is one of the things that stops it being so for me. Amongst other aspects.

When it first came out I think I gave it... 4.5/5 in a review. Much of what I said in the review still stands but I would perhaps re-rate it 3.5/5 now. Those ratings are kind of spurious anyway, I mean ratings in general. It's so hard to put a number on it.

But basically, I think Recovery is an excellent album. But not a classic and not approaching the quality of the first three. It doesn't all flow well enough in a musical theme to be a classic. If he had produced it all maybe it could of been. As lyrically, it's consistent.

[classthe_king]

Recovery should be less too?

c'mon man, give the guy a break

Why?

OMGshz guys, he almost died and was addicted to pills we should be thankful he's putting out music regardless of how shitty it is. We'll cut him a break too because he went though a hard time and call it a classic

[NicoleEM]

TES-10/10
MMLP-9.5/10(I'm back)
SSLP-9/10(My name is&Cum on everybody)
Recovery-8.5/10(I like all songs but replay value isn't too high)
Relapse/Refil-8/10(3am,We made you,My mom)
Encore-7/10(would be easier to say what i like lol)
The songs in parenthesis are the ones i don't like.

[nathan123]

Recovery should be less too?

c'mon man, give the guy a break

Why?

OMGshz guys, he almost died and was addicted to pills we should be thankful he's putting out music regardless of how shitty it is. We'll cut him a break too because he went though a hard time and call it a classic

i never said a recovery was a classic EVER, so dont quote me on that one, its a solid album, enjoyable to listen to, you just look into it too much man, you also said you listened to the album twice or so, barley a chance given there

[Robbie G]

1. The Eminem Show - 10/10
2. The Marshall Mathers LP - 9/10
3. The Slim Shady LP - 9/10
4. Recovery - 7/10
5. Relapse - 7/10
6. Encore - 5/10

I agree with this but I'd probably mark Relapse down to 6.5

[classthe_king]

i never said a recovery was a classic EVER, so dont quote me on that one, its a solid album, enjoyable to listen to, you just look into it too much man, you also said you listened to the album twice or so, barley a chance given there

I never said you said it was classic I was just mocking everyone who does. And I never listened to it again because for me it's replay value was 0. Making me give it a solid 6/10

[nathan123]

i never said a recovery was a classic EVER, so dont quote me on that one, its a solid album, enjoyable to listen to, you just look into it too much man, you also said you listened to the album twice or so, barley a chance given there

I never said you said it was classic I was just mocking everyone who does. And I never listened to it again because for me it's replay value was 0. Making me give it a solid 6/10

chance given 0, so that 6 isnt valid imo