RapName wrote:EminemBase wrote:Em's popularity wasn't declining with The Re-Up. Well, if at all only because he wasn't making solo music.
But considering Curtain Call was just a greatest hits and sold nearly half a mill 1st week (in 2005) and had two top ten singles AND the fact The Re-Up was basically a fucking mixtape and still did what it did... I think it's safe to say he was still very popular lmao.
He took a self-imposed break, he didn't fizzle out. But yeah wouldn't be surprised if Recovery did like 800k now.
Well, Em was still selling a lot of records, but he had to some degree lost touch with hip hop listeners and maybe even the community in general. The mouth to mouth (i know you know the importance of it) wasn't just positive anymore and to me it seemed like a lot of people had given up on him. His decline started with Encore, but after Re-Up he disapeared and he fell you off the mainstage completely for four year, as you said.
And btw, I really believe Em will do a milli. Everyone who bought Relapse will buy Recovery, but this time around he'll appeal to the mainstage aswell. 400k ekstra? No problem...
Well I don't agree that he lost touch with hip-hop listeners. Maybe with people who just like gangsta rap or strongly disliked his silly shit but a lot of people that were really into him, remained into him. Again, I'm talking about the hardcore base, not casual music fans or screaming teenagers.
Everybody has ups and downs, I know of no artist, Hip-Hop or other that literally just got better and better with every single album and no missteps. Encore had some missteps but still had a lot of forceful artistry and impressive lyricism. Even if not upto previous standards.
Also, most people are Em-stans constantly but just never admit it. Only difference between a hardcore Em fan and a general hip-hop fan who bashes on Em is that one admits he's a genius and the other pretends he's too cool to like him lmao. Happens with everybody when they get too big. People like to pretend they're on the fringe and have a defined taste that nobody else can tap into.
But notice how every rap forum has been bashing Em, calling anyone who likes him a 'stan' then with this "Despicable" freestyle and "Not Afraid" I'm already seeing 90% of those people shout he's the GOAT and saying Recovery will be the greatest thing in history lmao.
People's memories are fickle and the last thing you do is usually the most remembered but Em never really lost it. He just had a few self-imposed dips.