Recovery VS All Other Albums

[mceddie]

its hard to say.

but

MMLP
TES/Recovery
SSLP
Relapse
Encore

But its wayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy to early to say yet.

i think i agree.
mmlp 10/10
tes/recovery 9/10
sslp 8/10
relapse 7/10
encore 4/10

Yeah, i agree with that.

marshall mathers had no bad songs, all songs are perfect.

TES and Recovery have one or two songs you'd skip.

SSLP had three or four.

Relapse had alot.

Encore has only 4 good songs.

exactly

[OneFallsRich]

TES
MMLP
Recovery
SSLP
Relapse
Encore
Infinite

[Manny_Boi]

Encore shouldn't even count. Fucking garbage.

Relapse shouldnt count either.

[Cube23]

The Eminem Show
The Marshall Mathers LP

The Slim Shady LP
Recovery

Relapse
Infinite


Encore

[Manny_Boi]

The Eminem Show>Recovery>MMLP>SSLP>Relapse>Encore

[SgtPepper]

Encore shouldn't even count. Fucking garbage.

Relapse shouldnt count either.

Insane, Beautiful, My Mom, Same Song & Dance, Underground, Careful What You Wish For & Elevator.


Not likely.

[gutawafang]

TES>MMLP>Recovery>SSLP>Encore>Relapse

I'm shocked now cuz Relapse jumped to last.

[CB Productions]

It's way to early to have a good judgment on Recovery, but after 1 and a half listens:

TES
MMLP

SSLP
Recovery
Relapse/Encore/Infinite


I did not get the same feeling that I got the first time I heard The Eminem Show. I'll never forget the way I felt when I heard that album for the first time. I'm hoping Recovery gets better the more I listen to it, which is definitely possible.

[Robbie G]

too early to tell imo

[Eminem4Life1006]

TES
MMLP
Recovery
SSLP
Relapse
Encore

[UzaKING]

MMLP
Recovery
TES
SSLP
Relapse
Encore

Im really liking Recovery so far

[Emadyville]

I always ranked them as

TES
MMLP
SSLP
Relapse
Encore

and I have to place this about mmlp, and because it sounds so great, obviously cause first listen, I'd have to put it number 1

[lh2shay]

for me its

TES
MMLP
RECOVERY


RELAPSE
SSLP
ENCORE

[8milestyle]

TES
MMLP

SSLP/Recovery(might be above SSLP)

Encore

Relapse

[EminemBase]

Currently I have them ranked as...

1. The Eminem Show
2. The Marshall Mathers LP
3. The Slim Shady LP
4. Relapse
5. Encore

As for Recovery, it's too early for me to say. But I'm on my... Sixth listen maybe and it's an incredible album. Gets better every time.

Again Em seems to parallel Tarrantino somewhat in the sense, he's come back from a bit of a career slump and this album feels pretty monumental and in a way better than anything he's done. Much like Inglourious Basterds did for QT.

But just like when I saw IG (and still), it's so hard to place it above already established classics. I really think it'll take me even... Years to properly place it and Relapse. Because the songs are so fresh, it's just so hard to truly rank them against older stuff.