Do you think Recovery would be a classic if Dre produced it?

by **CLV22798** » Jun 22nd, '10, 05:03

I wanted to continue the interesting question I asked in my last thread. Now, I love how Recovery turned out. It was the Eminem album I was waiting for since The Eminem Show. I liked that he stepped out of his comfort zone, and worked with different producers and artists. But, one of the things I've seen people criticize the most is the production of the album. I have no problem with the production, I think it's one of his best all around produced album's he's ever done. What I want to ask is how do you think Recovery would have turned out if Dr. Dre produced the whole album? With they way Eminem sounded in Recovery, I think it would have been his best album period if Dre had produced most of it.

What do you people think?

by **slimsoxshady** » Jun 22nd, '10, 05:05

we would get a bunch of So Bad's so no

by **professor** » Jun 22nd, '10, 05:05

it would have been a lot darker album. Relapse was perfect for em and dre in my opinion

by **slimsoxshady** » Jun 22nd, '10, 05:06

honestly i'd love to have an Em Boi-1da album...i love Em's swag on his beats

by **CLV22798** » Jun 22nd, '10, 05:08

Guys, it was just a hypothetical question lol. I meant if Eminem had the same type of songs, but the difference being that Dre produced the album. How do you guys think Recovery would of turned out?

by **EminemBase** » Jun 22nd, '10, 05:12

Recovery is a classic because Dre didn't produce it.

by **EminemBase** » Jun 22nd, '10, 05:13

CLV22798 wrote:Guys, it was just a hypothetical question lol. I meant if Eminem had the same type of songs, but the difference being that Dre produced the album. How do you guys think Recovery would of turned out?

I think as usual Dre's beats would of been repetitive and drowned out Em's vocals. And slightly ruined the material for me.

If EM produced it though I think it would of been twice as goood.

by **titan23** » Jun 22nd, '10, 05:18

It would of turned out like so:

1. "Cold Wind Blows" Prod. Dr. Dre
2. "Talkin' 2 Myself" (featuring Kobe) Prod. Dr. Dre
3. "On Fire" Prod. Dr. Dre
4. "Won't Back Down" (featuring Pink) Prod. Dr. Dre
5. "W.T.P." Prod. Dr. Dre
6. "Going Through Changes"Prod. Dr. Dre
7. "Not Afraid" Prod. Dr. Dre
8. "Seduction" Prod. Dr. Dre
9. "No Love" (featuring Lil Wayne) Prod. Dr. Dre
10. "Space Bound" Prod. Dr. Dre
11. "Cinderella Man" Prod. Dr. Dre
12. "25 to Life" Prod. Dr. Dre
13. "So Bad" Prod. Dr. Dre
14. "Almost Famous" Prod. Dr. Dre
15. "Love the Way You Lie" (featuring Rihanna) Prod. Dr. Dre
16. "You're Never Over" Prod. Dr. Dre

And on the back of the CD case, it would say, "PRODUCED BY DR. DRE...
:facepalm

by **CLV22798** » Jun 22nd, '10, 05:19

EminemBase wrote:Recovery is a classic because Dre didn't produce it.

I love your answer!!!!! I just came up with the idea of Dre producing it for the people that didn't like the production in Recovery. I had no problem with the production on the album, to me it's a classic

by **infiniterap** » Jun 22nd, '10, 05:44

The only problem I have is that these beats are all Lil Wayne and Drake beats, not hip hop beats. Which is what Em used on SSLP, MMLP, and TES - HIP HOP beats not CLUB beats.

There is no way you can compare this album to those 3 simply because of that. This is a lot more mainstream beat type album. Sometimes Dre beats are repetitive, but at least he makes hip hop beats.

by **Emadyville** » Jun 22nd, '10, 05:45

EminemBase wrote:Recovery is a classic because Dre didn't produce it.

by **OMEGA** » Jun 22nd, '10, 05:48

What's with the Dre hate? :facepalm

So Bad is my favorite beat on the album.

by **titan23** » Jun 22nd, '10, 05:49

Omega wrote:What's with the Dre hate?

So Bad is my favorite beat on the album.

we got a Dran? :laughing:

by **CLV22798** » Jun 22nd, '10, 05:49

infiniterap wrote:The only problem I have is that these beats are all Lil Wayne and Drake beats, not hip hop beats. Which is what Em used on SSLP, MMLP, and TES - HIP HOP beats not CLUB beats.

There is no way you can compare this album to those 3 simply because of that. This is a lot more mainstream beat type album. Sometimes Dre beats are repetitive, but at least he makes hip hop beats.

You ever wonder that maybe that's what he was going for? Maybe he wanted to switch his style of production for once, which is why he went with so many different producers. I bet Eminem has the mindset that if people like the my old style better, then go back and listen to his old albums. Maybe he didn't want to make the type of music he's made before.

by **CLV22798** » Jun 22nd, '10, 05:51

Omega wrote:What's with the Dre hate?

So Bad is my favorite beat on the album.

I respect your opinion, but So Bad is in no way the best beat in Recovery. It sounded like the same old Dre, nothing new or fresh about it. I would have rather heard an Underground type beat. Now, that beat was just something else. It was fresh and different

Do you think Recovery would be a classic if Dre produced it?

Do you think Recovery would be a classic if Dre produced it?

Re: Do you think Recovery would be a classic if Dre produced it?

Re: Do you think Recovery would be a classic if Dre produced it?

Re: Do you think Recovery would be a classic if Dre produced it?

Re: Do you think Recovery would be a classic if Dre produced it?

Re: Do you think Recovery would be a classic if Dre produced it?

Re: Do you think Recovery would be a classic if Dre produced it?

Re: Do you think Recovery would be a classic if Dre produced it?

Re: Do you think Recovery would be a classic if Dre produced it?

Re: Do you think Recovery would be a classic if Dre produced it?

Re: Do you think Recovery would be a classic if Dre produced it?

Re: Do you think Recovery would be a classic if Dre produced it?

Re: Do you think Recovery would be a classic if Dre produced it?

Re: Do you think Recovery would be a classic if Dre produced it?

Re: Do you think Recovery would be a classic if Dre produced it?

Who is online