Which song(s) on Recovery would you rate 10 out of 10

[The Shady Virus]

25 to life is his best song on the album IMO

[EminemBase]

Erm...

I'd say:
- Space Bound
- 25 to Life
- Almost Famous

And I'd probably say "Cinderella Man" too. Hook can get a bit annoying but the lyricism and rest of it is just too good. So maybe that too.

I'd say "Going Through Changes" is an 8 or 9 for me. People are just obsessed with his introspection. When I hit upon an introspective Em track now I'm just waiting for the next one. Because he's put so many spins on his own emotions, it's just repetitive now. I'm not really interested in following a soap opera, I want creativity.

[EminemBase]

and to the someone who said that this is false,what other songs are pefect?Maybe Till I Collapse even tho I cant listen to it anymore.

Sing For The Moment.

I wouldn't say that song is perfect. It's amazing but I think he slightly ruins the last verse with too many "motherfucks" lmao.

When you use swear words too much in a bunch they lose their potency and just become detractive from the quality I think. That's really his only fault sometimes, just cant stop himself lmao.

[MikeNUFC]

I wouldn't say that song is perfect. It's amazing but I think he slightly ruins the last verse with too many "motherfucks" lmao.

When you use swear words too much in a bunch they lose their potency and just become detractive from the quality I think. That's really his only fault sometimes, just cant stop himself lmao.

There's only one 'motherfucker' in the whole of Sing For The Moment - and thats in the second verse.

Cinderella Man has two many stupid lines to be considered perfect "your pussy lyrics, I cunt hear it" & "My filet is smoking weed, get back faggot, the steaks are high" in partiuclar.

Space Bound has wayy too much simplisitc lyricism to be called perfect.

25 To Life has some forced rhymes and Almost Famous, like Cinderella Man has lines like "I cum back like nut on your spine"

Out of those I'd only say AF is close to perfect.

[EminemBase]

I wouldn't say that song is perfect. It's amazing but I think he slightly ruins the last verse with too many "motherfucks" lmao.

When you use swear words too much in a bunch they lose their potency and just become detractive from the quality I think. That's really his only fault sometimes, just cant stop himself lmao.

There's only one 'motherfucker' in the whole of Sing For The Moment - and thats in the second verse.

Cinderella Man has two many stupid lines to be considered perfect "your pussy lyrics, I cunt hear it" & "My filet is smoking weed, get back faggot, the steaks are high" in partiuclar.

Space Bound has wayy too much simplisitc lyricism to be called perfect.

25 To Life has some forced rhymes and Almost Famous, like Cinderella Man has lines like "I cum back like nut on your spine"

Out of those I'd only say AF is close to perfect.

Okay then 'fucks and fucking's'. There's four in total in the second half of the third verse. Did we really need to splice semantics you knew the point lol.

As for the "Cinderella Man" lines I don't consider them stupid lines.

Also - On the rest of those songs and this point in general. When I give a song 10 / 10, I'm only saying, I'm not saying every aspect of the song, every single line is perfect. Truth is nothing he has done is perfect. Humans always make errors and given that taste can be so personal, it's impossible to create something we all see as perfect.

BUT, the point of giving songs 10 / 10 is to say, they're SO good in the exeuction and overall effect, they deserve that rating. It's like rating an album 5/5 too. Now the critic doesn't mean the album is absolutely, literally flawless with every single line and every single word. But they're just saying the things it gets right overwhelm the flaws to such a degree, it deserves a 'perfect' (in theory) rating. But with "Sing for the Moment" I think the overbearing of swearing especially in the third verse takes it down to a 9 to me. It's too much to ignore.

Which is what I'm saying with those songs. I also disagree on the flaws anyway. But that's besides the point and there's no point you coming back trying to convince me the lines are awful or explaining why. I know your reasons for thinking they are, I just disagree. I'm not going to try convince you they're great lines. We just have to accept neither of us will move on it and hold a different opinion on it.

[WakeUpShow]

I wouldn't say that song is perfect. It's amazing but I think he slightly ruins the last verse with too many "motherfucks" lmao.

When you use swear words too much in a bunch they lose their potency and just become detractive from the quality I think. That's really his only fault sometimes, just cant stop himself lmao.

There's only one 'motherfucker' in the whole of Sing For The Moment - and thats in the second verse.

Cinderella Man has two many stupid lines to be considered perfect "your pussy lyrics, I cunt hear it" & "My filet is smoking weed, get back faggot, the steaks are high" in partiuclar.

Space Bound has wayy too much simplisitc lyricism to be called perfect.

25 To Life has some forced rhymes and Almost Famous, like Cinderella Man has lines like "I cum back like nut on your spine"

Out of those I'd only say AF is close to perfect.

Okay then 'fucks and fucking's'. There's four in total in the second half of the third verse. Did we really need to splice semantics you knew the point lol.

As for the "Cinderella Man" lines I don't consider them stupid lines.

Also - On the rest of those songs and this point in general. When I give a song 10 / 10, I'm only saying, I'm not saying every aspect of the song, every single line is perfect. Truth is nothing he has done is perfect. Humans always make errors and given that taste can be so personal, it's impossible to create something we all see as perfect.

BUT, the point of giving songs 10 / 10 is to say, they're SO good in the exeuction and overall effect, they deserve that rating. It's like rating an album 5/5 too. Now the critic doesn't mean the album is absolutely, literally flawless with every single line and every single word. But they're just saying the things it gets right overwhelm the flaws to such a degree, it deserves a 'perfect' (in theory) rating. But with "Sing for the Moment" I think the overbearing of swearing especially in the third verse takes it down to a 9 to me. It's too much to ignore.

Which is what I'm saying with those songs. I also disagree on the flaws anyway. But that's besides the point and there's no point you coming back trying to convince me the lines are awful or explaining why. I know your reasons for thinking they are, I just disagree. I'm not going to try convince you they're great lines. We just have to accept neither of us will move on it and hold a different opinion on it.

Stan is completely perfect.

[shadysully22]

Almost Famous....no doubt

[Solace]

25 to Life and Almost Famous are 9.5

[classthe_king]

and to the someone who said that this is false,what other songs are pefect?Maybe Till I Collapse even tho I cant listen to it anymore.

Sing For The Moment.

I wouldn't say that song is perfect. It's amazing but I think he slightly ruins the last verse with too many "motherfucks" lmao.

When you use swear words too much in a bunch they lose their potency and just become detractive from the quality I think. That's really his only fault sometimes, just cant stop himself lmao.

Sing For The Moment doesn't even have that much cussing?

But I would say if any song is perfect it's this one.

[xBakedx]

All of these songs in my opinion are currently 10 out of 10 :

Going Through Changes
Space Bound
25 To Life
On Fire
Seduction

[Devil'sAdvocate]

Seduction and Almost Famous.

[classthe_king]

I think it all comes down to someone's standards on what a 10/10 is. For me a 10/10 is an absolute perfect song. I wound give only 6 songs ever a 10/10, maybe 7. Some people on here, obviously have lower standards.

[IrishShady]

Going Through Changes, Love The Way You Lie, Not Afraid, Space Bound, Talkin' 2 Myself, Cinderella Man and Almost Famous

[theJFKshow]

Going Through Changes
Not Afraid
No Love
Space Bound
Cinderella Man
25 To Life

[buffalo bill]

To you guys who think Recovery is full of 10/10 songs, (roughly) how many 10/10 would you say that Eminem has done in his career?