If this was the Relapse tracklist, would it still be hated?

[CLV22798]

The one thing that I noticed when I first heard Relapse was that it was the first Eminem album where I noticed that I disliked alot of songs. In his first 3 albums, there weren't many songs that I didn't like. Which made me love those albums even more. So, I decided to come up with my own tracklist that I think would have made Relapse better, and not as hated as it actually was. Now, I still don't think it would be a great album, but it would have at least have been way better than Encore. Here is what I think Relapse should have been:


1. Careful What You Wish For
2. My Darling
3. 3 AM
4. Stay Wide Awake
5. Insane
6. Bagpipes From Baghdad
7. Hello
8. Music Box
9. We Made You
10. Hell Breaks Loose
11. Must Be The Ganja
12. Deja Vu
13. Beautiful
14. Elevator
15. Underground


To me, this wouldn't have been the comeback that Recovery was. But, it would have been a comeback to his roots. This would have sounded like something that would of come out in the late 90's or early 00's. Now, I didn't make this thread to see what other people thought the tracklist should have been. I just wanted to see what people's reaction to Relapse would have been if this would have been the tracklist instead of what Relapse ended up being. Would you have had a better reaction towards Relapse? or would still think it was a weak comeback?

[Solace]

So many topics with their stupid little edited Relapse tracklists just to defend the fucking album.

[buffalo bill]

Wtf, you removed Same Song & Dance?

You must be crazy.

[CLV22798]

So many topics with their stupid little edited Relapse tracklists just to defend the fucking album.

It's not that I'm trying to defend Relapse, because I thought the album just sucked. I just think the album could of been way better than it was. and I think my tracklist proves that, and I wanted to see if other people thought the same.

[CLV22798]

Wtf, you removed Same Song & Dance?

You must be crazy.

I didn't like the song at all, didn't really like the beat or the lyrics. I would of put Same Song and Dance as a bonus song if anything.

[abed]

i think the original relapse tracklist is dope and doesn't need a change, but music box could have made the album even better

[Devil'sAdvocate]

ive never seen this topic made before.

[Omar Khalid]

if you changed the tracklist or not people will still bitchin about it. Every album Eminem had put people were bithcin about it.

[theJFKshow]

Yes.

[Fa-Q]

Relapse is the New Encore

[goblue418]

Wtf, you removed Same Song & Dance?

You must be crazy.

i like relapse as it is.

[Elision]

So many topics with their stupid little edited Relapse tracklists just to defend the fucking album.

[Sam.]

1st encore topics
2nd relapse topics
next year recovery

[ShadyVsEminem]

Its very easy to say an album would of been better with different songs,,i liked it the way it was if it had of had the best of Relapse and Refill it would of been better but it DIDNT.

Same with people saying Encore would of been so much better with The Straight form the lab songs(2 of which were bonus songs) all the time

[Emadyville]

Relapse is the New Encore

I never thought of it that way, but you're right