Rock Bottom vs. If I Had

[Fa-Q]

Both are loved by most Eminem fans but I lean towards Rock Bottom for several reasons

1) If I Had is very simple lyrically and has some lyrics that dont seem to be well thought out ie "Fart and cough." Rock Bottom on the other hand is amazingly lyrically and multi wise is top notch.

2) Emotionly it sounds like If I Had he was just mad and in Rock Bottom it sounds truly sad

3) If I Had's beat is way too loud compared to his voice

So Rock Bottom Wins by a landslide for me

[master360]

Rock Bottom

[murphmanny]

Rock Bottom

[ThomasJ]

Rock Bottom by a mile.

[RapName]

Oh man, no contest.
Rock Bottom destroys If I Had!

[xxTrigger1989xx]

Rock Bottom for the win

[DƎRDYPK]

If I Had

Rock Bottom is mega dope & all but...
If I Had is very underrated just because of the slow feel or whatever

[tjb]

if i had, just because of the hook.

"if i had a million dollars, id buy a damn brewery and turn the whole world into alcoholics"

[Spirit92]

Honestly can't decide,both are amazing.

[Shit Can Happen]

If I Had for me. The intro as someone else mentioned is great. Also, Rock Bottom is just depressing, whereas If I Had expresses sadness while at the same time delivering a somewhat uplifting "fuck the world" message. And the chorus being a sarcastic version of the Barenaked Ladies song is awesome.

[KillahBee]

If I Had for me - Rock Bottom is better technically, but where I'm at right now I can really relate to If I Had
Still, both tracks are some of the realest stuff you're ever going to hear on a rap album

[Sablesilk]

Rock Bottom, I like the emotion behind it. The only thing that I don't like about If I Had is that at the end he says "know what I'm sayin" like a hundred times.

[BILI]

Rock Bottom

[Sam.]

Bock Rottom

[Devil'sAdvocate]

Rock Bottom