Ten Reasons Why Eminem Is A G.O.A.T (FAO EMINEMBASE)

by **ThomasJ** » Aug 24th, '10, 18:53

LilWayne4Life wrote:
TJthaGreat wrote:@LilWayne4Life An album that gets 8/10 reviews is great,not classic.

I'm sure you went on the one site that anyone can edit (wiki) to confirm that

The Carter 2
Tha Carer 3
Most of his mixtapes

where all in the majority of the music sites for top albums of the decade nough said.

Proof or GTFO.

by **LilWayne4Life** » Aug 24th, '10, 18:55

TJthaGreat wrote:
LilWayne4Life wrote:
TJthaGreat wrote:@LilWayne4Life An album that gets 8/10 reviews is great,not classic.

I'm sure you went on the one site that anyone can edit (wiki) to confirm that

The Carter 2
Tha Carer 3
Most of his mixtapes

where all in the majority of the music sites for top albums of the decade nough said.

Proof or GTFO.

Google the shit or GET THE FUCK OUTTA HERE.

by **xxTrigger1989xx** » Aug 24th, '10, 18:57

Don't feel like going off topic but,

Tha Carter 2 = Clasasic <--- proven
Tha Carter 3 = Mainstream Classic <--- Proven
2/3rds of his mixtapes = Classic <--- Proven

:wave:

[/quote]

Not here to debate on Lil Wayne, but you can't prove a classic just by saying it's proven. It has to be widely accepted as a classic by most hip hop fans and critics. Which none of those albums are. Tha Carter 2 is the best out of the mentioned, besides No Ceilings (which is okay at best) and it wasn't very good

That being said...
Lil Wayne has never had a classic <--- Proven :laughing:

Not trying to diss ya buddy, but you can't say an album's classic and put proven by it, when it's actually not proven[/quote]

ALOT of people (ranging from old school fans, new, mainstream, underground has said C2 is a classic) More people then less has said it from the hiphop sites i go on like hhdx, rapbasement etc...

It has been proven by reviews, Critics, fans, listeners and artists what else is there to prove?
Just because YOU don't think it's a classic you cannot speak for everyone as a whole.[/quote]

I've never heard anyone say C2 is a classic. I've never seen a review saying it or anything. I've seen reviews saying it's GOOD, but not a classic. Mediocre is not another word for classic

People, for instance, say Recovery is a classic. But, you probably don't think it is. Em fans think it's a classic, but Wayne fans may discard it. I personally think it's a classic in 2010 standards, which are not very high with Young Money being the most popular hip hop group. I'm sorry, I know you probably love YM, but their lyricism and subject matters are empty and emotionless. No album out past about...2002 is a real classic. The Marshall Mathers LP was a classic, THAT has been proven. C2 is regraded as the point where Wayne fell off afterwards, many hip hop heads know this, I've seen evidence. He recovered himself somewhat with No Ceilings. Wayne heads regard C2 as a classic, just like they consider everything else he puts out as a classic. It's simply a fact, any rapper's fanbase will say that their favorite rapper's album is a classic. Now, show me a review that says C2 is a classic, a major review like Allmusic , XXL, or Rolling Stone and I'll stop arguing

by **ThomasJ** » Aug 24th, '10, 19:03

Ok,so I googled it,and the first site I clicked put C2 over MMLP,TES,The Blueprint,Like Water For Chocolate,Stillmatic,Food and Liquor and Phrenology,just to name a few.
Talk about credibility.
Rapreviews,one of the best sites for rap reviews,gave C2 a 7.5/10.
That sure as hell ain't classic.

by **LilWayne4Life** » Aug 24th, '10, 19:10

TJthaGreat wrote:Ok,so I googled it,and the first site I clicked put C2 over MMLP,TES,The Blueprint,Like Water For Chocolate,Stillmatic,Food and Liquor and Phrenology,just to name a few.
Talk about credibility.
Rapreviews,one of the best sites for rap reviews,gave C2 a 7.5/10.
That sure as hell ain't classic.

Check out the rolling stone reviews for C2 & C3

by **slimsoxshady** » Aug 24th, '10, 19:12

i actually prefer C3 over C2

by **ThomasJ** » Aug 24th, '10, 19:17

LilWayne4Life wrote:
TJthaGreat wrote:Ok,so I googled it,and the first site I clicked put C2 over MMLP,TES,The Blueprint,Like Water For Chocolate,Stillmatic,Food and Liquor and Phrenology,just to name a few.
Talk about credibility.
Rapreviews,one of the best sites for rap reviews,gave C2 a 7.5/10.
That sure as hell ain't classic.

Check out the rolling stone reviews for C2 & C3

Rolling Stone gave SSLP a 3.5/5,MMLP & TES a 4/5.
Talk about credibility.

by **LilWayne4Life** » Aug 24th, '10, 19:19

TJthaGreat wrote:
LilWayne4Life wrote:
TJthaGreat wrote:Ok,so I googled it,and the first site I clicked put C2 over MMLP,TES,The Blueprint,Like Water For Chocolate,Stillmatic,Food and Liquor and Phrenology,just to name a few.
Talk about credibility.
Rapreviews,one of the best sites for rap reviews,gave C2 a 7.5/10.
That sure as hell ain't classic.

Check out the rolling stone reviews for C2 & C3

Rolling Stone gave SSLP a 3.5/5,MMLP & TES a 4/5.
Talk about credibility.

Rolling stone is known for it's reviews, changing the subject when the truth presents itself? GTFOH

by **DƎRDYPK** » Aug 24th, '10, 19:20

you all mad

by **BILI** » Aug 24th, '10, 19:22

LilWayne4Life wrote:
TJthaGreat wrote:Ok,so I googled it,and the first site I clicked put C2 over MMLP,TES,The Blueprint,Like Water For Chocolate,Stillmatic,Food and Liquor and Phrenology,just to name a few.
Talk about credibility.
Rapreviews,one of the best sites for rap reviews,gave C2 a 7.5/10.
That sure as hell ain't classic.

Check out the rolling stone reviews for C2 & C3

And they gave 3.5 to C2 and 3 to Carter :laughing:

I cant find C3 there tho
Recovery got 4,I dont want to even talk about other albums then

by **xxTrigger1989xx** » Aug 24th, '10, 19:23

LilWayne4Life wrote:
TJthaGreat wrote:Ok,so I googled it,and the first site I clicked put C2 over MMLP,TES,The Blueprint,Like Water For Chocolate,Stillmatic,Food and Liquor and Phrenology,just to name a few.
Talk about credibility.
Rapreviews,one of the best sites for rap reviews,gave C2 a 7.5/10.
That sure as hell ain't classic.

Check out the rolling stone reviews for C2 & C3

I've done this before, and neither reviews say the respective albums are a classic
Wayne will never be GOAT
What has he done for the rap community? Nothing. What impact has he had? None. Eminem broke down barriers of race. Pac influenced the entire black community. Biggie is a legend in his own right, only 2 albums and both are timeless classics. What has Wayne done? Come up with a few decent punchlines? The forementioned rappers are all on MTV's list of best rappers of all time. Jay is 1st, Biggie 2nd, Pac 3rd, Em is 9th...where's Wayne? Wayne puts out music to help himself, not his fans. His songs have no real message, other than that he gets pussy all the time and makes a lot of money...who really gives a fuck? It's really played out. Wayne doesn't have the versatility to be GOAT. He's a decent lyricist with a horrible rapping and singing voice. He's nowhere near Eminem, Biggie, Pac...others who are deserving of the title. Rappers who came from the bottom up, who earned where they're at now. Wayne has been blessed from the second he started rapping, he's been rich all his life. There's no realism there, he's never had the hardships that other's must go through
How will Wayne be GOAT? Ever be GOAT?
And what's funny is, people are starting to notice Eminem again, and notice that Em is better than Wayne. I've seen this all around the internet, people saying "I love Weezy, but Eminem is GOAT"

I'm done with this stupid fucking argument
:facepalm2

at this thread for getting sucked into this argument, AGAIN

by **LilWayne4Life** » Aug 24th, '10, 19:26

BILI wrote:
LilWayne4Life wrote:
TJthaGreat wrote:Ok,so I googled it,and the first site I clicked put C2 over MMLP,TES,The Blueprint,Like Water For Chocolate,Stillmatic,Food and Liquor and Phrenology,just to name a few.
Talk about credibility.
Rapreviews,one of the best sites for rap reviews,gave C2 a 7.5/10.
That sure as hell ain't classic.

Check out the rolling stone reviews for C2 & C3

And they gave 3.5 to C2 and 3 to Carter I cant find C3 there tho
Recovery got 4,I dont want to even talk about other albums then