Rock Bottom vs. If I Had

[Alaine]

sorry Rock Bottom shits on If I had but again I never liked If I had

[EminemBase]

Easily "Rock Bottom".

[MikeNUFC]

Rock Bottom is my favourite song of all time, so that.

If I Had gets some undeserved hate on here though. Great track.

[Alaine]

If I Had gets some undeserved hate on here though. Great track.

really? I personally don't like it but as far as this forum goes, I see lots of people love it here

[EminemInsider]

1) If I Had is very simple lyrically and has some lyrics that dont seem to be well thought out ie "Fart and cough."

He says "Im tired of..." WAY to many times in If I Had

Some people on here shouldn't be listening to music.

If I Had is in the format of a poem...kind of resembles Ginsberg's "America"...it's outside the box...and not even remotely "simple" lyricism. Per usual, the genius of that song sails over the heads of people who can't appreciate subtlety.

I prefer Rock Bottom, but that's just because of that song's pretty much unparalleled lyricism. If I Had is also brilliant.

[Jaz]

Well Rock Bottom is my number one favorite song of all time.. so obviously it wins, but really I thought this was a kind of off-balance comparison anyway. If I Had probably isn't even top 20 Em songs for me.

[tam_91]

Rock Bottom.

[accutub]

Rock bottom,but If I had is brilliant too.