Kanye Has THREE XXL Ratings?

[EminemBase]

I think that's absurd.

I'm a huge Kanye fan but no way has he had three perfect albums.

Only album I'd give that to is Graduation. Even that is maybe only a strong XL though. I've never loved The College Dropout as much as everyone else, Late Registration has some powerful songs but XXL? No way. Graduation... Maybe.

They gave My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy XXL too supposedly (just read). That's just bias IMO lmao. They love Kanye and just can't be as truly objective anymore. I like MBDTF but that album is no XXL. Musically it's ambitious but the ideas aren't that strong, and there's at least 1 or 2 questionable tracks. It's hardly ground-breaking content, beyond the musical scope and imagery.

And Em only got one? If Kanye deserves three, Em definitely does. Because Em's first three > Kanye. THE SLIM SHADY LP / THE EMINEM SHOW? "97 Bonnie and Clyde" alone is more ground-breaking and daring than Kanye's first three albums combined lmao.

[Brood]

I don't think XXL is that biased. MBDTF is receiving several perfect reviews from other websites, so it's not just XXL.

..but I'm in the same camp as you -- SSLP & TES should have gotten XXLs.