The Most Overrated Eminem Song?

[Trimss]

Mockingbird is overrated.

[Sla]

Yeah, all songs about Hailie probably. Is there anyone loving Hailie's Song? You know, I'm not saying these songs are really bad and awful, but a bit embarassing. I'm not a guy loving the full contact with parents, so maybe that's the reason. Maybe When I'm Gone is his best Hailie song.

[Master Chief]

Yeah, all songs about Hailie probably. Is there anyone loving Hailie's Song? You know, I'm not saying these songs are really bad and awful, but a bit embarassing. I'm not a guy loving the full contact with parents, so maybe that's the reason. Maybe When I'm Gone is his best Hailie song.

Not Afraid is embarassing.

Hailie's Song is not.

[classthe_king]

If you've ever played a sport Till I Collapse is not overrated.

[dR3]

How are Lose Yourself and Till I Collapse being overrated? They totally deserve the praise that they're getting.

[VenomBlackViper]

Wow you people are crazy. Sing for the moment? LTWYL?? LIKE TOY SOLDIERS?
Man.

IMO Lose Yourself is overrated..

So you think LTYL & Like Toy Soldiers are great songs that deserve all the praise they get, yet Lose Yourself is overrated?

GET
THE
FUCK
OUTTA
HERE































NOW!!!!!!

[Master Chief]

LTWYL is underrated by people on this forum.

Lose Yourself actually deserves more praise.

[Sla]

Yeah, all songs about Hailie probably. Is there anyone loving Hailie's Song? You know, I'm not saying these songs are really bad and awful, but a bit embarassing. I'm not a guy loving the full contact with parents, so maybe that's the reason. Maybe When I'm Gone is his best Hailie song.

Not Afraid is embarassing.

Hailie's Song is not.

Roflmao, come on. Troll attempt or are you serious?

difference betweel Lose Yourself and Love the way you lie is:

both blew up the charts, only one of them is in the best hip hop songs ever the other suck

Naaaah, come on. Lose Yourself is clearly Em's best song ever, but claiming that Love The Way You Lie sucks is a bit exaggerated. A dope song that made also HipHop history.

[VenomBlackViper]

Naaaah, come on. Lose Yourself is clearly Em's best song ever, but claiming that Love The Way You Lie sucks is a bit exaggerated. A dope song that made also HipHop history.

How did LTYL "made also hiphop history"? it's done nothing for hiphop aside from being an embarrassment.

[Sla]

Every successful song makes history in some way, so why shouldn't the most successful song of the last years do it? It was a great combination between a rapper and a pop artist, with a special and delicate theme. For sure it's not an average and generic HipHop song.

[BILI]

@BILI, SMH, on fire is not better than any song on tes, not better than half of relapse and encore, it's not even the best on recovery

[VenomBlackViper]

Every successful song makes history in some way, so why shouldn't the most successful song of the last years do it? It was a great combination between a rapper and a pop artist, with a special and delicate theme. For sure it's not an average and generic HipHop song.

It was a successful song yes, but did Mockingbird make history? did Like Toy Soldiers make history? did Beautiful make history? Nope. They were all successful songs but none of them made history, they're just popular Eminem songs. If you want a song that went down in history between a rap artist & pop singer look no further than Stan, that song was underrated by the public (even though overrated here) yet went down in history as one of the best mixtures of the rap & pop world, and this was at a time when Eminem was hugely against pop artists.

[BILI]

White America, Cleanin't Out My Closet, Till I Collapse, Sayin Goodbye to Hollywood, Soldier, No Apologies, Like Toy Soldiers, Mockingbird, Deja Vu, Beautiful, Stay Wide Awake, Underground, Love You More, We As Americans, When I'm Gone, Careful What You Wish For, My Darling, Music Box, Buffalo Bill, Elevator, Going Through Changes, 25 To Life

TIC,Deja Vu and GTC are the only ones that come close.

[Master Chief]

On Fire is very good technichally with the multies but that's all it has, production is horrid

Are you mentally stable?

That beat is the best beat Em has rapped on in a long time, matter of fact that's one of the main reasons the song is praised.

[VenomBlackViper]

@BILI, come on man:

White America, Cleanin't Out My Closet, Till I Collapse, Sayin Goodbye to Hollywood, Soldier, No Apologies, Like Toy Soldiers, Mockingbird, Deja Vu, Beautiful, Stay Wide Awake, Underground, Love You More, We As Americans, When I'm Gone, Careful What You Wish For, My Darling, Music Box, Buffalo Bill, Elevator, Going Through Changes, 25 To Life

and that's just naming a few ^

On Fire is very good technichally with the multies but that's all it has, production is horrid, delivery is mehhh (normal 2010 shouthing), lyrics were mehhhhhhhhh (em attempting punchlines...), hook suck and it has no subject

no way on earth it's THAT good, multies aren't the only thing to judge a song by

Dude what? On Fire is one of the best songs on Recovery, the beat was fucking great. The lyrics were some of his best in 2010. The delivery works over this beat almost perfectly. The hook isn't amazing nor is it bad, it's good enough for the song. The subject is just him straight spitting crazy shit to impress, similar to Hopsins Hot 16s or Eminems Role Model for example.
On Fire > Like Toy Soldiers, Mockingbird, Beautiful, Love You More, We As Americans, When I'm Gone, GTC, 25 To Life, Elevator.