What if Em wasn't the one to make it?

[BigBangBazinga]

Yeah, it would've been the Justin Timberlake/NSYNC, Beyonce/Destiny's Child, Fergie/Black Eyed Peas effect lol He would've eventually gained the most popularity and out-shined them all.

Whaaaa? Fergie is what ruined the group, how does she stand out (Besides the boobs)

Her ass too. God damn.

[NicoleEM]

I think he would still have stood out..not that many good white rappers back then.
Listening to his albums/mixtapes, i think Proof could have made it big.

[shadymathers313]

if he didnt make it im sure he would have gotten notice on D12 first major cd if they followed the same idea of someone making it, coming back for them all and dropping a D12 album. if not then who knows?

[Sam.]

there would have never been a d12 because under this situation Eminem would have blew up big time .

[BigBangBazinga]

there would have never been a d12 because under this situation Eminem would have blew up big time .

What? If say Proof would've blown up like Em in 1999 there would be no D12? I don't get your point.

[M-Pyre]

oke, you have to be realistic here. jimmy was the one who heard and wanned em first. soooo, if eminem became (a little bit) famous by being in the group, jimmy would have heard him and try to contact him after.

all via dre off course, cause jimme was the one who gave him his SL EP.

[Sam.]

there would have never been a d12 because under this situation Eminem would have blew up big time .

What? If say Proof would've blown up like Em in 1999 there would be no D12? I don't get your point.

d12 would have broken up after maybe their 1st album ,because eminem would have gotten himself noticed and would have moved to an another lable ---> lol wat ?

[BigBangBazinga]

there would have never been a d12 because under this situation Eminem would have blew up big time .

What? If say Proof would've blown up like Em in 1999 there would be no D12? I don't get your point.

d12 would have broken up after maybe their 1st album ,because eminem would have gotten himself noticed and would have moved to an another lable ---> lol wat ?

Doubt it.

[Sam.]

i think i remember i read some where that when Eminem blew up proof got jealous and shit but latter maade up soo.

[BigBangBazinga]

i think i remember i read some where that when Eminem blew up proof got jealous and shit but latter maade up soo.

So? That's the reason they would've broken up? Not plausible. And I love the "I THINK I read SOME WHERE that..."

[Sam.]

i think i remember i read some where that when Eminem blew up proof got jealous and shit but latter maade up soo.

So? That's the reason they would've broken up? Not plausible. And I love the "I THINK I read SOME WHERE that..."

wht you dont know that ?

[BigBangBazinga]

i think i remember i read some where that when Eminem blew up proof got jealous and shit but latter maade up soo.

So? That's the reason they would've broken up? Not plausible. And I love the "I THINK I read SOME WHERE that..."

wht you dont know that ?

Know what? That Proof got jealous?

[Sam.]

yes .

[Blu]

Everyone already stated it but, Eminem would sure stick out like a green hat with an orange bill.

[Sam.]

Everyone already stated it but, Eminem would sure stick out like a green hat with an orange bill.

lol wat ?