When most people were dreading Lighters before the ep was released I was looking forward to it. Why? Because Bruno Mars is one of my favourite singers today. His mixtapes and his debut album had many incredible songs (ignore Just The Way You Are). I am saying this just to point out that I don't dislike the song because he is on it although my biggest reason for not liking the song is the hook.
First of all I want to say that Bruno Mars wasted his time on this song. The lyrics to the hook are cringeworthy and pathetic. No matter how well he sang it it was gunna sound cheesy and generic. But the way he sang it made it even worse. He sounded whiney and just annoying in gerneral.
Then the beat kicks in and although it is not awful it sounds like every other pop beat in the industry. It is terribly suited for these two
Eminem's verse unlike Royce's is not bad but it sounds awkward flow wise for most of the verse.
Royce's verse is just really sad. His verse is pretty much the definition of awkward. He sounds like hes babbling for a lot of it.
So this is pretty much why I think the songs bad. NOT because it doesn't fit well into the ep (which it doesn't). It is bad all by itself.