A correlation that I've noticed

[LordRain777]

I have noticed that fans seem to be equally split between liking TES more than MMLP and liking MMLP more than TES. And I know the whole TES vs MMLP thing has been done a million times but this is just to test my theory that people who favor TES over MMLP are more likely to like new eminem.

[Master Chief]

TES is my favorite album of all time, I cannot stress that enough. I very much enjoy new Em, and I cannot stress that enough.

MMLP is probably my second favorite album of all time though

[Satire]

I switch back and fourth between MMLP & The Eminem Show constantly. I liked his flow and the overall tone as well as the tongue-in-cheek humor more so on MMLP but track for track I enjoy TES more and the high points are just timeless.

New Em is alright. I don't hate him as much as some people on this forum seem to but I don't listen to him much anymore.

[Suicide]

MMLP and SSLP over TES for me. But, they're all pretty equal IMHO.

As for new Em. He's not as good as people claim, but he's not that bad either. Borderline average in my oppinion. But, he still has some brilliant moments.

[buffalo bill]

Don't you know anything about science? You shouldn't tell us what your hypothesis is. Now you're ruined the experiment completely

[buffalo bill]

Plus define "new Em". Post-comeback? Post-Recovery? What?

[RKOunion]

TES=MMLP and new eminem sucks(post-recovery).

[buffalo bill]

I can't pick between MMLP and TES. Once I would have said MMLP.. Now I simply can't decide. The amazing thing is that to this day they both keep growing on me.

[OMEGA]

Relapse is the album for the true men.

[Innovation]

TES is my favorite album of all time, I cannot stress that enough. I very much enjoy new Em, and I cannot stress that enough.

MMLP is probably my second favorite album of all time though

This.

[Berry]

I enjoy all stages of Em's catalogue. Except for Encore! (Minus Yellow brick Road & Love you more)

[Drug.Ballad]

MMLP > TES and 'new' Eminem is dope.

MMLP and SSLP over TES for me. But, they're all pretty equal IMHO.

I agree that they're all pretty equal. Its really hard to decide between the three.

[Sekou]

The Slim Shady LP is better than both The Marshall Mathers LP and The Eminem Show.

[Amaranthine]

So either way, new Em is dope. And I prefer TES to MMLP, but it's REALLY close.

[J.R.]

Relapse is the album for the true men.