Master Chief wrote:It's BEEN in discussion because the OP states that. He just said that he would not show the song to a new listener because the song is 75% singing and Eminem is a rapper but that he believes it is a great song in itself.
Satire wrote:Master Chief wrote:It's BEEN in discussion because the OP states that. He just said that he would not show the song to a new listener because the song is 75% singing and Eminem is a rapper but that he believes it is a great song in itself.
I didn't read the OP, I was just making a prediction on what Venom's worst Eminem songs would be like.
But since we're already in this discussion, I don't think that Hailie's Song is that much of a turn off for new listeners, especially among the terrible songs listed in the OP (unless they have a personality that isn't akin to the song at all). It wouldn't create the ideal image of Shady's music for a first impression but that can be said for almost the entire Relapse album plus his rhyming and flow on the last verse is great for somebody who can appreciate it. It's not the right choice for a first listener, but I don't think it's top 10 worst. It's somewhere in the middle along with alot of forgettable songs. Plus Dre showed it to two of his bitches and they cried their heart out, it can't be that bad.
Menzo wrote:Lmao, you gotta love Zabe / SG...guy's so underrated.
StayWideAwake wrote:"Naturally handicapped, until proven intentionally retarded"
Painless wrote:Satire wrote:Master Chief wrote:It's BEEN in discussion because the OP states that. He just said that he would not show the song to a new listener because the song is 75% singing and Eminem is a rapper but that he believes it is a great song in itself.
I didn't read the OP, I was just making a prediction on what Venom's worst Eminem songs would be like.
But since we're already in this discussion, I don't think that Hailie's Song is that much of a turn off for new listeners, especially among the terrible songs listed in the OP (unless they have a personality that isn't akin to the song at all). It wouldn't create the ideal image of Shady's music for a first impression but that can be said for almost the entire Relapse album plus his rhyming and flow on the last verse is great for somebody who can appreciate it. It's not the right choice for a first listener, but I don't think it's top 10 worst. It's somewhere in the middle along with alot of forgettable songs. Plus Dre showed it to two of his bitches and they cried their heart out, it can't be that bad.
I didn't say I would put it on the list. I said it makes sense. (I'm trying to make up for the fact I got owned, don't tell anyone)
Satire wrote:Master Chief wrote:It's BEEN in discussion because the OP states that. He just said that he would not show the song to a new listener because the song is 75% singing and Eminem is a rapper but that he believes it is a great song in itself.
I didn't read the OP, I was just making a prediction on what Venom's worst Eminem songs would be like.
But since we're already in this discussion, I don't think that Hailie's Song is that much of a turn off for new listeners, especially among the terrible songs listed in the OP (unless they have a personality that isn't akin to the song at all). It wouldn't create the ideal image of Shady's music for a first impression but that can be said for almost the entire Relapse album plus his rhyming and flow on the last verse is great for somebody who can appreciate it. It's not the right choice for a first listener, but I don't think it's top 10 worst. It's somewhere in the middle along with alot of forgettable songs. Plus Dre showed it to two of his bitches and they cried their heart out, it can't be that bad.
VenomBlackViper wrote:Nice to see i'm the topic of discussion here.
My top 10 worst list:
1. Hailie's Song
2. Pistol Poppin'
3. Touchdown
4. LTWYL
5. My First Single
6. Spacebound
7. Beautiful
8. Mockingbird
9. Like Toy Soldiers
10. Who Want It
(Honorable Mentions: Big Weenie, Yellow Brick Road, When I'm Gone, Shake That, the forgettable songs with Em on them from D12 World that were horrible)
I agree with Satire though, Hailie's Song would cater to Drake's bitch audience quite well.
& in terms of Em singing hooks, Kim hook > Deja Vu hook.
VenomBlackViper wrote:Nice to see i'm the topic of discussion here.
My top 10 worst list:
1. Hailie's Song
2. Pistol Poppin'
3. Touchdown
4. LTWYL
5. My First Single
6. Spacebound
7. Beautiful
8. Mockingbird
9. Like Toy Soldiers
10. Who Want It
(Honorable Mentions: Big Weenie, Yellow Brick Road, When I'm Gone, Shake That, the forgettable songs with Em on them from D12 World that were horrible)
I agree with Satire though, Hailie's Song would cater to Drake's bitch audience quite well.
& in terms of Em singing hooks, Kim hook > Deja Vu hook.
Master Chief wrote:Satire wrote:Master Chief wrote:It's BEEN in discussion because the OP states that. He just said that he would not show the song to a new listener because the song is 75% singing and Eminem is a rapper but that he believes it is a great song in itself.
I didn't read the OP, I was just making a prediction on what Venom's worst Eminem songs would be like.
But since we're already in this discussion, I don't think that Hailie's Song is that much of a turn off for new listeners, especially among the terrible songs listed in the OP (unless they have a personality that isn't akin to the song at all). It wouldn't create the ideal image of Shady's music for a first impression but that can be said for almost the entire Relapse album plus his rhyming and flow on the last verse is great for somebody who can appreciate it. It's not the right choice for a first listener, but I don't think it's top 10 worst. It's somewhere in the middle along with alot of forgettable songs. Plus Dre showed it to two of his bitches and they cried their heart out, it can't be that bad.
So, you think Hailie's Song is forgettable? I thought the only person who underappreciated it was Venom![]()
His singing on it was great. I have always adored Eminem's hooks/singing. I wish he would do it more often. Deja Vu hook = Eminem's best.
Menzo wrote:Lmao, you gotta love Zabe / SG...guy's so underrated.
StayWideAwake wrote:"Naturally handicapped, until proven intentionally retarded"
Master Chief wrote:VenomBlackViper wrote:Nice to see i'm the topic of discussion here.
My top 10 worst list:
1. Hailie's Song
2. Pistol Poppin'
3. Touchdown
4. LTWYL
5. My First Single
6. Spacebound
7. Beautiful
8. Mockingbird
9. Like Toy Soldiers
10. Who Want It
(Honorable Mentions: Big Weenie, Yellow Brick Road, When I'm Gone, Shake That, the forgettable songs with Em on them from D12 World that were horrible)
I agree with Satire though, Hailie's Song would cater to Drake's bitch audience quite well.
& in terms of Em singing hooks, Kim hook > Deja Vu hook.
.....
Miller1121 wrote:VenomBlackViper wrote:My top 10 worst list:
1. Hailie's Song
6. Spacebound
7. Beautiful
8. Mockingbird
9. Like Toy Soldiers
VenomBlackViper wrote:Do I need to provide in depth explanations as to why I don't like each song now?
Satire wrote:VenomBlackViper wrote:Do I need to provide in depth explanations as to why I don't like each song now?
Do it in this thread so we can make a classic together. I'll defend you if the time arises.
Manly Moose wrote:Satire wrote:VenomBlackViper wrote:Do I need to provide in depth explanations as to why I don't like each song now?
Do it in this thread so we can make a classic together. I'll defend you if the time arises.
Don't try. Most people get mad when they think Venom is making a statement that those are the worst songs, once he explains its an opinion thing people won't care. Also, his reasons are lol worthy (Not saying he shouldnt think this way) so have fun backing them up.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users