Your Rating of Eminem Albums Out of 5

[Wreck]

include the 8 Mile songs/soundtrack if you want, and the Re-Up if you really want to. Doesn't have to be an exact number (like 4.5/5, 3.5, etc.)

SSLP- 4.56/5
MMLP- 5/5
TES- 5/5
Encore- 2.7/5
Relapse- 3.1/5
Recovery- 3.55

[Sam.]

I'll stick with the albums .

SSLP-5/5
MMLP- 5/5
TES- 4/5
Encore- 2.5/5
Relapse- 4.5/5
Recovery- 4/5

[Amaranthine]

I swear we had a thread exactly like this not too long ago.
But I like rating things, soo...

Infinite: 5/5 for lyrics, 1/5 for beats. I guess that makes it like 3/5?
SSLP: 4.5/5
MMLP: 5/5
TES: 5/5
Encore: 2/5
Relapse: 4/5
Recovery: 4/5
HTS: 3.5/5

[Wreck]

I'll stick with the albums .

SSLP-5/5
MMLP- 5/5
TES- 4/5
Encore- 2.5/5
Relapse- 4.5/5
Recovery- 4/5

I think, even though SSLP was outstanding lyrical content, that TES is a step up. And I disagree about Relapse being a 4.5/5 album, no way it's better than TES tbh, and Relapse sucked anyway. The accents were annoying after awhile, they weren't that lyrical at all, even though it had its moments. And I really liked Recovery, I would agree w/ that, idk, I'm in between on that rating. Not to pick apart your opinion or nothin, just was saying for argument's sake.

[DanWS]

lol SSLP gets a 4.56..... not quite a 4.57 album for you then bro?

[Amaranthine]

I'll stick with the albums .

SSLP-5/5
MMLP- 5/5
TES- 4/5
Encore- 2.5/5
Relapse- 4.5/5
Recovery- 4/5

I think, even though SSLP was outstanding lyrical content, that TES is a step up. And I disagree about Relapse being a 4.5/5 album, no way it's better than TES tbh, and Relapse sucked anyway. The accents were annoying after awhile, they weren't that lyrical at all, even though it had its moments. And I really liked Recovery, I would agree w/ that, idk, I'm in between on that rating. Not to pick apart your opinion or nothin, just was saying for argument's sake.

[Wreck]

I swear we had a thread exactly like this not too long ago.
But I like rating things, soo...

Infinite: 5/5 for lyrics, 1/5 for beats. I guess that makes it like 3/5?
SSLP: 4.5/5
MMLP: 5/5
TES: 5/5
Encore: 2/5
Relapse: 4/5
Recovery: 4/5
HTS: 3.5/5

I swear I don't give a fuck . And I forgot about HTS & Infinite.

Infinite (I really liked, and is underrated I think)- 3.2. Would have been better if the production was way better. They were plain, striped down, boring, simple beats tbh, but the lyrics and delivery I thought were good & above average. If he copied Nas & AZ's style I don't think it matters, cause a lot of artists have similar deliveries/flows, who agrees?

HTS- 3.85/5.

[SG.]

Infinite - 6/10
Slim Shady EP - 7/10
Slim Shady LP - 9/10
Marshall Mathers LP - 9.5/10
Eminem Show - 8.5/10
8 Mile - 8.5/10
Encore - 5.5/10
Re-Up - 7.5/10
Relapse - 8/10
Recovery - 7.5/10
Hell: The Sequel - 8/10

[Wreck]

I'll stick with the albums .

SSLP-5/5
MMLP- 5/5
TES- 4/5
Encore- 2.5/5
Relapse- 4.5/5
Recovery- 4/5

I think, even though SSLP was outstanding lyrical content, that TES is a step up. And I disagree about Relapse being a 4.5/5 album, no way it's better than TES tbh, and Relapse sucked anyway. The accents were annoying after awhile, they weren't that lyrical at all, even though it had its moments. And I really liked Recovery, I would agree w/ that, idk, I'm in between on that rating. Not to pick apart your opinion or nothin, just was saying for argument's sake.

So you guys think gory, dark, accent filled, raped type content in songs is good? Insane= terrible, for a good example.

And about the 4.56 rating, lol I'm weird like that. #Don'thateBro.

[RichardDiNozzo]

Infinite: 2,5/5
The Slim Shady LP: 4,5/5
The Marshall Mathers LP: 5/5
The Eminem Show: 5/5
Encore: 2/5
Relapse: 3/5
Recovery: 3,5/5

[djdixie]

Infinite | 2.5/5 (Production is great, Eye-Kyu was equal with Eminem on that album tbh, I wish he was a part of D12 instead of ... everyone lmao, Rhyming on this was great, only negative part about it is that he copies Nas and Kool G Rap so much .. which is okay for a debut, favorite track is 313)

I'd give it a little bit better of a score than that simply becuase i personally really like this album, i do agree with you about Eye-Kyu but if i had to pick some1 to drop from D12 so he could come back aboard. It would be Bizzare. Don't like him and never will.

I agree with your points on SSLP MMLP TES ENC so ill not bother writing them lol

Relapse | 3.9/5 (The hate for this album is amazing, I can't understand why people hate it so much, the storytelling is amazing and the Accent made the stories more real and looked better, improved them to look more fictional, the rhyming while he SMOTHERED multi's on this album wasn't as smooth as the previous 3 albums and seemed forced .. a pause here and a fast-forward there, that's what's faulting the album .. I believe this is one of the best storytelling albums to be ever released, favorite track is My Mom)

Personally i'd give it 4.5 basically for the reasons you gave but i didnt get the forced feeling you spoke about. I got the feeling he enjoyed making this album, aswell as persforming the track, altho he did do some shit while performing but that was probably still trying to get comfortable being back in the spot light sober.

Recovery | 2.9/5 (He applied Anger here in a horrible way and made it sound like he's pretending to do it, back in the days you can FEEL that the screaming was natural, but here it's pretty obvious that he's struggling to put that sound out except for some tracks where it sounds like Energy instead of Anger like Almost Famous, not to mention that the production is horrible, However the album itself is fantastic, some really memorable lines all over the album and some had some dope rhymes like "Slim Rothelsberger/beserker than a fed up/post office worker", the noticeable flaws outshined the hidden points that's why it got so much hate, it's still a medium Eminem album for me, favorite track is Almost Famous)

I really dont play this album, the only em album i have never bought. Downloaded and Deleted.

basically thank fuck for HTS. << witch wasnt close to his best album but from the feeling i got, it wont be long till another classic album comes.

[Sam.]

I'll stick with the albums .

SSLP-5/5
MMLP- 5/5
TES- 4/5
Encore- 2.5/5
Relapse- 4.5/5
Recovery- 4/5

I think, even though SSLP was outstanding lyrical content, that TES is a step up. And I disagree about Relapse being a 4.5/5 album, no way it's better than TES tbh, and Relapse sucked anyway. The accents were annoying after awhile, they weren't that lyrical at all, even though it had its moments. And I really liked Recovery, I would agree w/ that, idk, I'm in between on that rating. Not to pick apart your opinion or nothin, just was saying for argument's sake.

Well sslp for me was that album for that was full of songs that were like from crazy to jaw dropping ,the effortless rhymes,multis and story telling makes it perfect.

mmlp the album we all worship so nothing more to say .

tes-has comc ,my most fav sng of all time .

encore -

relapse- 4.5 /5 yeah that's surprising ain't it ,but yeah i loved the deep and dope lyricism in it ,the album when i heard it reflected the effort that he put up just to get back in the public eye ,the only album that reminded me of the old Eminem of the mmlp era ,so that is why the rating .

recovery -.. you know that .

[Relapse.]

MMLP- 5/5
TES- 5/5
Infinite - 5/5
Relapse - 5/5
Recovery - 3.5/5

[Sam.]

MMLP- 5/5
TES- 5/5
Infinite - 5/5
Relapse - 5/5
Recovery - 3.5/5

SSLP ???
&
Recovery - 3.5/5
Whatchu smoking son ?

[bigandy]

Infinite: 2.5/5
The Slim Shady LP: 4.5/5
The Marshall Mathers LP: 5/5
The Eminem Show: 4.5/5
Encore: 2/5
Relapse: 3/5
Recovery: 4/5