Would Em be considered the greatest Rapper ever

[Mathers]

This is why I didn't post in this thread.
This question cannot be asked at all. To each his own and asking would only result in a stupid debate.
Some even think Wayne is the greatest rapper ever!

Yep, true. Only reason to properly end an opinion-based debate is to agree to disagree. I wasn't looking for a debate over the "greatest rapper ever" since I didn't post any names and shit.

Wayne used to be good man, I'm listening to The Carter II right now and he could've been a great nominee for GOAT title, thats until he released The Carter III and Rebirth.

So true.

[12characters]

I don't know, like couldn't you debate ability, versatility or originality/creativity?

[ThomasJ]

Voices make you the greatest? lol

[12characters]

I don't know, like couldn't you debate ability, versatility or originality/creativity?

To me, ability is to carve your music from scratch instead of taking a wood and making a statue out of it, deciding which musical elements to put in your track in order to ride it the way you're planning to ride it, and planning everything into perfection while making the content interesting enough to match your dream melody with a premium layer of words, the word "ability" to me is versatility and originality combined.

But the definition of all that shit is different from one person to another, some look at ability as something else, like thinking of unique punchlines and metaphors no one would've thought of, or choosing the right words to describe a situation, or flowing flawlessly while remaining on topic. And people will consider this element more important than the other element. Like Geno he says he thinks voice is an important element. I do think it's important but not as much, and TJ doesn't give a shit about it. No one will be convinced with the opposite of what he believes (unless an insecure hoe of course) so it's never valid tbh. But comparing two different artists based on one element will be a reasonable discussion imo.

but couldn't you debate a number of artist across as much elements as much possible?

[12characters]

but couldn't you debate a number of artist across as much elements as much possible?

Yeah but that would take a lot of time tbh.

True, but time would be required required sense it would be discussing such a heavy topic like, the greatest rapper "ever".

[WakeUpShow]

as much as i hate when people rank Em as #1 just because, if Em is below your top 20 you literally don't know anythin about rap technique and music artistry or the harder to define things like emotion, wit, rhythm, etc.

[J.R.]

By more people than he already which is alot to be fair but if he didn't have the gimmicky silly Slim Shady persona Songs and just had Emotional/Deep Songs in his catalouge of Albums the Songs that we all relate to and love from Em then i think he really would be considered the greatest Rapper ever by more people. i don't think there is anyone with the exception of 2pac that could make Emotional/Deep Songs as well as Eminem you can't feel the Emotion and Pain in other Rappers Music aside from 2pac like you can with Eminem that's what seperates him from the rest that you can feel his Music and what he saying in the Lyrics from the verses to the Hooks but just The Slim Shady Gimmick he ran with is the only downfall on Albums like Relapse and Bad Meets Evil EP and Songs like Big Weenie.

That's one long sentence.

[12characters]

Yeah but that would take a lot of time tbh.

True, but time would be required required sense it would be discussing such a heavy topic like, the greatest rapper "ever".

It ain't worthy of it though, cause who ever "wins" you'll still have your own greatest rapper of all time, and people will argue that some elements are too important or not important to be put in the measurement, it won't end m8.

I was assuming all measurements would be equal. But you're right about people not caring. I would just like something to use when people try to call my favorites garbage, especially when some are candidates for the GOAT.

[NextEpisode]

In my opinion, the question should rather be; Would Em be still be considered (one of) the greatest rappers ever, if it wasn't for the 'funny/comedy singles'?

Remeber, these singles played a huge factor to the success of Eminem.

Excluding the important factor, 'success' (which the singles obv played a huge part in). I would still suggest that, rather than degrading his legacy, it enriches it. Not many artists (rap or w/e genre) have the humor/wit like that of Eminem, which, also speaks to so many people. Being a multi-talented artist with a wide range of ingredients in your arsenal, is postive, not negative.

[flyingmonkey10]

duh!

[UofLCard]

I do think you have to be a stan to defend Songs like Big Weenie though i mean even Em knew Slim Shady is a Gimmick and the core Hip Hip community wether listeners, Rappers, DJs etc don't respect that kinda shock value.

You think BW is a Slim Shady song? Oh hell, Slim Shady hasn't made a true appearence since Devil's Night. Songs like BW are the result of pills and writer's block.

[Mr Change]

I do think you have to be a stan to defend Songs like Big Weenie though i mean even Em knew Slim Shady is a Gimmick and the core Hip Hip community wether listeners, Rappers, DJs etc don't respect that kinda shock value.

You think BW is a Slim Shady song? Oh hell, Slim Shady hasn't made a true appearence since Devil's Night. Songs like BW are the result of pills and writer's block.

Yeah Big Weenie is definitely in the Druggy-Em category. Slim Shady? pshtt

Slim Shady
Just Don't Give a Fuck
My Name Is
Kill You
Guilty Conscience
I'm Shady

Eminem
Business
'Til I Collapse
No Love
Stan
Lose Yourself

Marshall Mathers
Beautiful
Not Afraid
Cleanin' Out My Closet
Going Through Changes
Hailie's Song

Druggy Eminem
Big Weenie
My 1st Single
Rain Man
Just Lose It
etc etc

Just to name a few

[Devil'sAdvocate]

lol @ tupac

[Emadyville]

He's the greatest because he can do the most things well.

That aside, nobody touches his first three classics.

Obviously there are tons of other rap classics in history that are all up there, but, nothing by Jay-Z or Nas or 2Pac or many other legendary mainstream rappers I can think of tops his first three.

I think he's taken the craft to greater heights than many and pushed the envelope.

The Marshall Mathers LP is a truly unique album, in MUSIC, full stop. Masterpiece.

Well put

[Emshady2]

The Eminem Show