Poll9-Cinderella man VS Bagpipes from baghdad VS White ameri

[RKOunion]

The poll thing isn't bad, but I wish the he'd compare songs that aren't random. Bagpipes from Baghdad and White America?

How about something like White America vs Kill You?

On-topic: White America, it's not even close. The way he was addressing the issue, his flow, rhyming and delivery were on another level. The other 2 songs don't even come close.

Perfect way to start TES, just like how Kill You was the perfect way to start MMLP.

[Kill You]

^ Not a bad idea. I agree that it should be songs that are a little more in common lol. All of his intro songs have been kinda in the same vein so a poll with all the intro tracks would make sense.

[Stanforever]

^ and ^^
will try to put more relative songs from now on.

Any suggestions for next poll?

[CrashBand]

^ and ^^
will try to put more relative songs from now on.

Any suggestions for next poll?

This was the most random assortment of em songs you could have thought of.

ALSO there was no competition. White America shits on those songs for 95% of Eminem fans.

(Lose Yourself v SFTM v Stan) (My Name Is v Without me v Real slim shady) (Kill You v WA) (Deja Vu v rock bottom) (renegade v no apologies v if i get locked up?) (d12 songs?) (Sauce v Warning) (the way i am v cleaning out my closet)

hmmm I dunno if my suggestions look any better doe. some of those could be pretty one sided

[xnoxiousx]

^ and ^^
will try to put more relative songs from now on.

Any suggestions for next poll?

This was the most random assortment of em songs you could have thought of.

ALSO there was no competition. White America shits on those songs for 95% of Eminem fans.

(Lose Yourself v SFTM v Stan) (My Name Is v Without me v Real slim shady) (Kill You v WA) (Deja Vu v rock bottom) (renegade v no apologies v if i get locked up?) (d12 songs?) (Sauce v Warning) (the way i am v cleaning out my closet)

hmmm I dunno if my suggestions look any better doe. some of those could be pretty one sided

If you going to do My Name Is v Without me v Real slim shady you should add we made you that would be all 4 of the funny first singles of his albums.

[Emadyville]

white america but i enjoy them all, they def all represent the era/album of eminem

[EG.]

White America >>>>>

[UofLCard]

It's better than having nothing at the moment.

I'll forever remember Sac_jb's threads about what Em eats for breakfast, when we weren't getting any "Relapse 2" news.

[ShAdYTiLIDie]

Had to go with cindarella man! all songs are sick though.

[Innovation]

White America > Cinderella Man > Bagpipes from Baghdad.

[CrashBand]

Bagpipes shits all over Cinderella Man. By miles.

Cinderella Man isn't THAT bad and Bagpipes isn't THAT good. imo

[Mathers]

Cinderella Man isn't bad at all except for the chorus.

[Mathers]

^^
The beat is too loud? You must not like Till I Collapse.

[CrashBand]

Don't get me wrong Bagpipes definitely > Cinderella Man. But my point still stands. I don't feel the distance between the songs is that huge.

Looking at your pro's and con's.

-Both had an annoying voice
-With the beats, I dont mind CM's production but that's opinions at the end of the day
-The Humor in Bagpipes is a pro. But your implying Bagpipes gets a nudge ahead because it has humour and Cinderella Man doesn't.
Humour =/= better. (The Real Slim Shady doesn't beat TIC because it has humour).
-So yes Cinderella Man doesn't have humour
-Flow and Rhyming are better in Bagpipes (but CM wasn't awful in these departments)
-and yes the corny punches are pretty bad. But as you highlighted there are some pretty good ones.

So yes Bagpipes > Cinderella Man
But not by miles

[CrashBand]

Bagpipes was aiming to be a funny song with sick rhyming and serial killer lyrics. It achieved that goal.

Cinderella Man was aiming to be an uplifting, energetic song with sick punchlines and good rhyming. It failed to deliver sick punchlines and its rhyming wasn't that good.

Yes true. Definitely think Bagpipes is the better song.

Although CM had lots of corny punches, there is definitely some good material. You even alluded to a few dope lines in your earlier post. But no doubt CM is far from a 5 star effort.

Arsenic flow, saliva fluid, what can ya DO?
Go get your CREW to hype you up
Stand behind you like WOO! (Force)
That boy's hot enough to melt hell, burn Satan TOO
Fry his ass[/i] and put his [i]ashes back together with GLUE
You can hate him, he don't blame you, frankly he would TOO
This game could ill-afford to lose him, how 'bout YOU?
Now guess WHO? Here's a CLUE

I added a few but yeah that is pretty shit lmao.
I spose in the past, the song just never jumped out to me as being 'bad'.

How about Bagpipes beats it by half a mile?