If you could swap Without Me and My Dads Gone Crazy

[SajN]

I find him and his voice and his verses boring... from all the songs I've heard from him... and no, it's not only with Eminem Im talking about.

[Aftermathers]

Aftermathers, why did you pick these two songs in the first place? Both are great.

Only Songs i don't enjoy compared to the rest just not the kind of Music i liked compared to the rest which was magical.

[SajN]

Not even this?

That flow definitely isn't boring imo.

After 1.04 or it got better... but meh.

Biggest problem I think is his voice. I just can't like it.

[Aftermathers]

Aftermathers, why did you pick these two songs in the first place? Both are great.

Only Songs i don't enjoy compared to the rest just not the kind of Music i liked compared to the rest which was magical.

I personally think Say What You Say is the worst on TES.

Why do you hold it higher than WM and MDGC?

Just didn't like the Subject Matter at all. Too unbearable for me.

[Bedtime Stories]

I love Without Me, and I do like My Dad's Gone Crazy and wouldn't swap them, but if I HAD to, then with Lose Yourself and 8 Mile Road.

Basically this.

[Kill You]

Just didn't like the Subject Matter at all. Too unbearable for me.

Without Me is understandable because you're not into comedy rap, but My Dad's Gone Crazy? Have you heard the 3rd verse? Any of the verses? They're not comedy verses or serial killing or anything like that. How is the content of My Dad's Gone Crazy worse to you than Say What You Say or Drips?

[Man1x]

None of these songs would fit on TES, it would ruin the album even though the songs are classics. So, no I wouldn't change these songs out for anything. The only one that you could make an argue for would be Stimulate because it has that TES sound and would fit. Even then, I wouldn't take a track off of TES because I honestly think Drips gives the album an overall better sound even though it's the weakest link. When you have an album filled with perfect to nearly perfect classics, no matter how good the weakest track is it will look like shit. I would've probably added Stimulate to a bonus disk with one other amazing track or shove it in the album somewhere where is doesn't disrupt the flow and where it makes sense, that would be if I was Eminem.

[EminemBase]

I definitely wouldn't swap "Without Me". It's a pure classic, and totally represents the album.

And...

"More pain inside of my brain than the eyes of a little girl inside of a plane...
Aimed at the World Trade, standing on Ronnie's grave,
Screaming at the sky, till clouds gather, it's Clyde Mathers and Bonnie Jade
And that's pretty much the gist of it - parents are pissed, but the kids love it"

That part alone makes "My Dad's Gone Crazy" worth being there.

Nothing from the 8 Mile Soundtrack would fit, stylistically either. Also, I think Encore sh ould have basically been like "Lose Yourself", musically. That felt like the next step, it felt bigger - more cinematic. If he had made an album in that way, he could have progressed from The Eminem Show.

[Kill You]

^ If he made an album that way it would have been a masterpiece. Probably his best album ever too.

[Mr Change]

I definitely wouldn't swap "Without Me". It's a pure classic, and totally represents the album.

And...

"More pain inside of my brain than the eyes of a little girl inside of a plane...
Aimed at the World Trade, standing on Ronnie's grave,
Screaming at the sky, till clouds gather, it's Clyde Mathers and Bonnie Jade
And that's pretty much the gist of it - parents are pissed, but the kids love it"

That part alone makes "My Dad's Gone Crazy" worth being there.

Nothing from the 8 Mile Soundtrack would fit, stylistically either. Also, I think Encore sh ould have basically been like "Lose Yourself", musically. That felt like the next step, it felt bigger - more cinematic. If he had made an album in that way, he could have progressed from The Eminem Show.

I've never really thought of this but, dang.

A 'bigger than life' cinematic Eminem album?

[UofLCard]

I wouldn't want to sawp MDGC and Without Me (the third verse of the former alone makes the song). If anything, I would swap Drips and SWYS.

[Emadyville]

It wouldnt make as much sense as an album tho

[Mr.DGAF]

Switch Without Me for My Dads Gone Crazy and then take My Dads Gone Crazy out for Without Me.

[UofLCard]

Same goes for the 8 Mile tracks. They're on 8 Mile because they fit that theme more so than TES. He wrote all the songs around the same time didn't he? On the set of the movie?

IMO, Love Me would've fit better on TES.

[Emadyville]

Same goes for the 8 Mile tracks. They're on 8 Mile because they fit that theme more so than TES. He wrote all the songs around the same time didn't he? On the set of the movie?

IMO, Love Me would've fit better on TES.

It doesn't feel like a TES track though.

I think it'd fit on Encore.

Agree with the OP by geno on this 110% and with your newest comment geno i also agree, reminds me of the track on encore with 50 stat and someone else i think? cant remember the name, the love song sorta...shows how much i remember encore