The Eminem Show vs The Marshall Mathers LP

[Jdubem]

The marshall mathers lp cuz its more interesting and has more of a plot to it, but the eminem show might be slightly more complete. slim shady beats them both tho

[RainMan44]

This is like asking me to pick between my left and right nut.

[Blu]

This is like asking me to pick between my left and right nut.

LMAO.

[Mathers]

The Marshall Mathers LP.

[AbramIsaac]

I don't feel like The Marshall Mathers LP really has any weak points in it. So, overall, I'd say The Marshall Mathers LP is the stronger album.

The Eminem Show, however, is more unique and interesting in some aspects. It's not as reactionary, it's a more true expression of personal art. That's how I look at it, anyway.

[Slim Fiasco]

The Slim Shady LP.

[Kill You]

Better album-MMLP.
Favorate album-TES

This makes no sense. It's music so better=favorite.

Not necessarily. You can recognize that things are better, if you break it down technically, point by point. But favorites come with what you listen to more.

For example, Eminem is easily 1000x better than Waka Flocka Flame in all aspects, but plenty like him more than they like Eminem.

I believe in this as well.

Going Through Changes, for example...I can recognize how great it is and recognize that it's probably the best song off of Recovery. That does not mean it's my favorite. I hardly listen to the song because it kinda depresses me, but like you said, it's about being able to recognize what's better and what's your favorite. Same with Deja Vu from Relapse. I can recognize it's the best song from Relapse, but it's not my favorite and I hardly listen to that song as well for the same reason that I hardly listen to GTC.

OT: I like TES better but MMLP is probably better. IMO, TES takes it, but in general MMLP is ahead of it.

[slimshady18]

both are brilliant,epic..etc but Eminem show

[Jdubem]

The Slim Shady LP.

[Trimss]

i like TES more.

[UofLCard]

I don't feel like The Marshall Mathers LP really has any weak points in it. So, overall, I'd say The Marshall Mathers LP is the stronger album.

You put it into word perfectlys what I was trying to get out.

[LIL_B]

The Slim Shady LP.

[Jdubem]

Slim Shady LP has the most replay value. Songs like brain damage, as the world turns, still dont give a fuck, role model, rock bottom, just dont give a fuck, im shady just never get old.

[Cupid Stunt]

The Marshall Mathers LP is my favorite Eminem album, after TMMLP it's Relapse. ( Don't hate )

So, I have to go with TMMLP. :d

[Emadyville]

TES...mmlp is a close second tho