The Eminem Show vs The Marshall Mathers LP

[trinell05]

Slim Shady LP has the most replay value. Songs like brain damage, as the world turns, still dont give a fuck, role model, rock bottom, just dont give a fuck, im shady just never get old.

Right, but this thread is about The Eminem Show and The Marshall Mathers LP...

[Emadyville]

Slim Shady LP has the most replay value. Songs like brain damage, as the world turns, still dont give a fuck, role model, rock bottom, just dont give a fuck, im shady just never get old.

Right, but this thread is about The Eminem Show and The Marshall Mathers LP...

is it tho

[trinell05]

Slim Shady LP has the most replay value. Songs like brain damage, as the world turns, still dont give a fuck, role model, rock bottom, just dont give a fuck, im shady just never get old.

Right, but this thread is about The Eminem Show and The Marshall Mathers LP...

is it tho

You better not change the thread title and make me look stupid.

[Emadyville]

hell no, i wouldnt dare, tho it would be funny

[Jdubem]

Slim Shady LP has the most replay value. Songs like brain damage, as the world turns, still dont give a fuck, role model, rock bottom, just dont give a fuck, im shady just never get old.

Right, but this thread is about The Eminem Show and The Marshall Mathers LP...

Wrong, the OP made the thread under the false assumption that these are his two best albums as you can see from him saying in the original post that he prefers the eminem show over the marshall marshall mathers lp as eminems best work.

My point is that if you are going to talk about his best album then the Slim Shady lp deserves to be mentioned as well. The entire discussion of the thread doesnt have to revolve completely around the title.

[trinell05]

Slim Shady LP has the most replay value. Songs like brain damage, as the world turns, still dont give a fuck, role model, rock bottom, just dont give a fuck, im shady just never get old.

Right, but this thread is about The Eminem Show and The Marshall Mathers LP...

Wrong, the OP made the thread under the false assumption that these are his two best albums as you can see from him saying in the original post that he prefers the eminem show over the marshall marshall mathers lp as eminems best work.

My point is that if you are going to talk about his best album then the Slim Shady lp deserves to be mentioned as well. The entire discussion of the thread doesnt have to revolve completely around the title.

Oh, so it's okay to go off topic? Thanks for letting me know.

Well, I think "The Writings on the Wall" was better than "Survivor", but probably because "Bills, Bills, Bills" was a trip,

[Jdubem]

Its not off topic when im adressing something he said in the original post. Can you say the same for that bullshit?

[trinell05]

Its not off topic when im adressing something he said in the original post. Can you say the same for that bullshit?

Yes, I can.

"The Same For That Bullshit"

[mdemaz]

MMLP, next Fred.

[dshady89]

Its not off topic when im adressing something he said in the original post. Can you say the same for that bullshit?

Yes, I can.

"The Same For That Bullshit"

LOL youre killing this forum

[Squiggles123]

It's a hard one for me considering the first album I ever thrashed as a kid was the eminem show, but after reflecting on both albums over the years I think MMLP is just more raw. I find it easier to listen to the eminem show through though tbh, can't listen to Kim, only when in a certain mood.