Do you think Eminem should just go MMLP style on next album?

[Willy]

Definitely. This is a really good idea.

[Mr.DGAF]

Nope. I really don't think he could capture any of the magic he made with the MMLP. Then we'd have an album that tried to recapture something incredible he did in the past and fail. And that's a no-no.

[BigBoss]

It's impossible to do what he did on MMLP again because pretty much everyone has come to terms with Eminem nowadays. They don't exactly freak out the same way they used to. They don't want him banned from everywhere and have picket signs and people protesting in the streets. He has no reason to draw that sort of emotion out, and if he tried to, it'd sound forced.

he might be able to pull off something like "you fucks dont think im still the same old slim...im a sell out...im a pussy? yea...well guess whose back mothafuckas" then rap about killing kim, "the reunion" type shit, just get hella personal with people he doesnt like... maybe not the way i put it, but close enough to it

[Mr.DGAF]

I think he could make a few tracks directed at the criticism now. I just have doubts about if he could sustain that for a full album. That's why I'd rather see something conceptual as opposed to spitting about real life stuff. But at the same time, that's how he's made his living. If he can find a creative way to do it, and I'm sure he can, then I'd love something about his life.

[BigBoss]

Yeah, that's true. He could try something like that drawing off his criticism and lashing at the fans. That'd be dope, and fresh.

I think the only way for the "old Slim" to come back is for a D12 album to happen. At least a dark, funny D12 song.

fuck. yes.

[BigBoss]

Yeah, that's true. He could try something like that drawing off his criticism and lashing at the fans. That'd be dope, and fresh.

I think the only way for the "old Slim" to come back is for a D12 album to happen. At least a dark, funny D12 song.

I think I've said this before too. I really want this. D12 are the only ones who I think can pull it out of him. No sexual innuendo intended, if there was any. Just making sure.

seriously though, if they're all still such great friends what the fuck happened, i know proof is gone but cmon they need to get themselves together, it was 6 fucking years ago, it sucks VERY much yea, but they still making dope songs individually so wtf

[Atone]

why does everybody wanna hear shit he's already done? i love when he does somethin new

[Mathers]

Yeah, that's true. He could try something like that drawing off his criticism and lashing at the fans. That'd be dope, and fresh.

I think the only way for the "old Slim" to come back is for a D12 album to happen. At least a dark, funny D12 song.

I think I've said this before too. I really want this. D12 are the only ones who I think can pull it out of him. No sexual innuendo intended, if there was any. Just making sure.

seriously though, if they're all still such great friends what the fuck happened, i know proof is gone but cmon they need to get themselves together, it was 6 fucking years ago, it sucks VERY much yea, but they still making dope songs individually so wtf

Because they're probably not that close anymore.

[Relevancy]

Yeah I bet a person can completely replicate what they did in there pasts. It's like throwing a rock 2 times, Im not gonna match the speed of my swing on the 2nd try. Just let Eminem be him.

[UofLCard]

What I like is that he's switched up his style every time. No two albums have sounded alike.

[xnoxiousx]

Not in 2012.

Sadly pussy music is popular

[Emadyville]

yer. i think eminem should go and do MMLP stuff...

cuz on that album he was Marshall. which is why its called Marshall Mathers LP...and he's good whenever he is marshall. maybe he should be slim shady on a few tracks as well.. and then on the last track he can be eminem if he wants to

if hes being shady though, he better make sure he does some good shock value stuff... the kind of stuff that makes people go "OMG DID HE JUST SAY THAT??? OMG" like in the good old days. remember when eminem got a lot of controversy? its because he was slim shady. he cant be marshall all the time.

fuck i am worthless lol

the better question is, can he be that controversial anymore?

he got a lot of flack for saying "faggot" on that album, as well as from the song "kim". He wont do a kim again, and he says the word faggot still, which people expect, and doesn't garner any flack anymore. He tried to be shocking on relapse, which he was in a lot of ways, but he didnt again become controversial, which brings me to my original question...and maybe a new topic, can he be controversial again?

[Kill You]

yer. i think eminem should go and do MMLP stuff...

cuz on that album he was Marshall. which is why its called Marshall Mathers LP...and he's good whenever he is marshall. maybe he should be slim shady on a few tracks as well.. and then on the last track he can be eminem if he wants to

if hes being shady though, he better make sure he does some good shock value stuff... the kind of stuff that makes people go "OMG DID HE JUST SAY THAT??? OMG" like in the good old days. remember when eminem got a lot of controversy? its because he was slim shady. he cant be marshall all the time.

fuck i am worthless lol

the better question is, can he be that controversial anymore?

he got a lot of flack for saying "faggot" on that album, as well as from the song "kim". He wont do a kim again, and he says the word faggot still, which people expect, and doesn't garner any flack anymore. He tried to be shocking on relapse, which he was in a lot of ways, but he didnt again become controversial, which brings me to my original question...and maybe a new topic, can he be controversial again?

Well I also think no one took him too seriously with the accent...a controversial album with this new style could work. As I have said before, I want him to go back to the Relapse lyricism only use his normal voice. I liked his attitude a lot better back then. Which I think he's probably trying to do now and he's getting shit for it...he's starting to focus a lot of rhymes while telling a story...reminds me of Relapse a little.

[Relevancy]

yer. i think eminem should go and do MMLP stuff...

cuz on that album he was Marshall. which is why its called Marshall Mathers LP...and he's good whenever he is marshall. maybe he should be slim shady on a few tracks as well.. and then on the last track he can be eminem if he wants to

if hes being shady though, he better make sure he does some good shock value stuff... the kind of stuff that makes people go "OMG DID HE JUST SAY THAT??? OMG" like in the good old days. remember when eminem got a lot of controversy? its because he was slim shady. he cant be marshall all the time.

fuck i am worthless lol

the better question is, can he be that controversial anymore? A controversial album? at 40 years of age.

he got a lot of flack for saying "faggot" on that album, as well as from the song "kim". He wont do a kim again, and he says the word faggot still, which people expect, and doesn't garner any flack anymore. He tried to be shocking on relapse, which he was in a lot of ways, but he didnt again become controversial, which brings me to my original question...and maybe a new topic, can he be controversial again?

Well I also think no one took him too seriously with the accent...a controversial album with this new style could work. As I have said before, I want him to go back to the Relapse lyricism only use his normal voice. I liked his attitude a lot better back then. Which I think he's probably trying to do now and he's getting shit for it...he's starting to focus a lot of rhymes while telling a story...reminds me of Relapse a little.

[dead prez]

Tried that with Relapse and look how that turned out.