Why do some people here think Eminem is the GOAT?

[true rue]

I was with you, but you lost me at "allot."

[SliK]

Who gives a shit if he's trolling? Let my point still stand for anybody who actually agrees with the original poster.

Saying something stupid on purpose to get people to call you stupid is not funny, impressive or interesting.

Why respond at all? As far as I'm concerned if you argue with a troll you sound just as stupid as them. Except, you're doing it accidentally, which really is no better...

[EminemInsider]

Hi I have been lurking on here for awhile usually just to here the new em songs as I am a big fan.

The reason I wanted to post this (sorry if it's in the wrong section?) is that allot of people here think Slim is the GOAT ( I know some don't but allot do) or even the greatest rapper alive. I mean as I said I think eminem is a great rapper and I can really relate to him, I mean I know this is a fan site for him and all but isn't there a difference between who you like and who has more skill. but I don't get all hype he gets. I really want to stress this before I start asking questions I don't want to offend anyone.

I know that eminem is very skillful and honestly one of the best currently but I just can't help to feel he is just hyped up because he is white.

Stopped reading right here.

It's amazing to me how many dipshits out there are completely oblivious to just how hackneyed a given (idiotic) argument is. Like, really...what the fuck goes through these dolts' heads telling them, "DuhhhhhOOIiiiii, people haven't said this millions of times before on the internet already...I should post this, and people will all have to think about this thing they never thought about before?!"

Tomorrow I'm going to start a thread about how George Bush was a bad president because he took us to war with Iraq when they didn't even have any WMDs, and the economy tanked.

Then on Thursday, I think maybe I'll start a thread about how "beauty is only skin deep," and how you should never "judge a book by its cover."

Then Friday, it's time for a lesson on how hard work is the key to success...how you can't achieve in life unless you work hard.

Stand back, everyone, intelligent paint chip-eating doofus coming through!

[KingDavid]

"Let's be real eminem as an MC is unbeatable. His range of lyrical content, delivery, vocabulary, and his ability to change the mood of his music in a split second makes him my favorite rapper alive. If you check out my posts I had made a topic earlier this year why I thought he was GOAT"

Ok I will check it out. Also do you believe eminem is better than nas, jay z , among others?

I Am a big rap enthusiast and Am a big fan of both J and Nas. Hell tho, I would put Big L above both of them. Jay has great rymes and plays his own style which is great, and the same can be said for Nas. I feel eminem's delivery more, and as a lyricist can relate a lot more which I enjoy.

Eminem's music can touch me personally, where J and Nas I'd listen to chillen, ya know?

My top 5 is Eminem, Tupac or Biggie, Big L and Immortal technique. ~

[KingDavid]

"Let's be real eminem as an MC is unbeatable. His range of lyrical content, delivery, vocabulary, and his ability to change the mood of his music in a split second makes him my favorite rapper alive. If you check out my posts I had made a topic earlier this year why I thought he was GOAT"

Ok I will check it out. Also do you believe eminem is better than nas, jay z , among others?

I Am a big rap enthusiast and Am a big fan of both J and Nas. Hell tho, I would put Big L above both of them. Jay has great rymes and plays his own style which is great, and the same can be said for Nas. I feel eminem's delivery more, and as a lyricist I think he's more advanced. I can relate a lot more which I enjoy.

Eminem's music can touch me personally, where J and Nas I'd listen to chillen, ya know?

My top 5 is Eminem, Tupac or Biggie, Big L and Immortal technique. ~

[M22XXT]

GOAT threads are stupid. It's all subjective and when people think it's one rapper another group thinks it's some other guy.

[true rue]

I was with you, but you lost me at "allot."

I hate when people do this. So what, there was a spelling/grammar error. Now you're just gonna disregard the whole post? You know exactly what was meant.

Dude, it's too long. Part of being a fan is appreciating or trying to appreciate everything an artist does. Some people obviously put blinders on for the crap--true of any artist.

[Devil'sAdvocate]

I think Eminem is the G.O.A.T because i fucking can and you cant fucking do shit to stop me! HUH! HUH! HUH!

fucking dickhole! BOOOOOO

[gintokisan]

Looks like we're dealing with a 16 year old idiot. Those three rappers are garbage.

Wow your calling me and idiot when you didn't even read my post.I never said anything about those three rappers being good I said they were better than Eminem at the Westwood show, In fact I even said above in my post which you clearly failed to read that Asher Roth is awful.Eminem can't be the best at everything even rappers worse than him can be better at somethings, heck even Lil Wayne can do somethings better than SS. Calling yourself an idiot would be more appropriate.

[AmmoHaze]

Hi I have been lurking on here for awhile usually just to here the new em songs as I am a big fan.

And what I don't get about eminem is how people say he raps about his real life, well so do 95% of rappers, and eminem only recently started rapping about "life" and in that respect is just a carbon copy of Kanye West, in fact I could only name about 4 songs on Recovery that could be classified as his real life, and it's horrible to see people on here dissing Lil Wayne for being fake, I honestly don't like Lil Wayne but I don't see how what he is rapping about is fake, he did the same thing as em and became mainstream, I actually used to like the early Wayne, before all of this YM shit.


Sorry if I offended anyone, I just needed to get this off my chest as I have been arguing with someone over this.

It's Ok, Tonite, Jealousy Woes, Never 2 Far, Searchin, Backstabber, Rock Bottom, If I Had, Murder Murder, 97 Bonnie & Clyde, The Way I Am, Marshall Mathers, Stan, Who Knew, Cleaning Out My Closet, Hailies Song, Say Goodbye To Hollywood, Superman, Soldier, Square Dance, White America, When The Music Stops, Till I Collapse, Sing For The Moment, Drips, Like Toy Soldiers, Mockingbird, Yellow Brick Road, Mosh, Spend Some Time, Crazy In Love, We As Americans, Ricky Ticky Tock, Never Enough, Beautiful, Be Careful What You Wish For, Deja Vu, My Darling, Not Afraid, Seduction, Cold Wind Blows, Cinderella Man, Spacebound, 25 To Life, You're Never Over, Talkin To Myself, Going Through Changes, Almost Famous, Lose Yourself, Rabbit Run, 8 Mile Road, Love Me, No Apologies, Public Enemy Number 1, Difficult, When Cocaine, I'm Gone



Every song Eminem has done about his real life experiences based on experiences like poverty, single parent home, being a father, drug addiction, politics. The Eminem Show which came out in 2002 10 years is a personal album where every track is deep and personal based on his life aside from With Out Me. Rock Bottom, If I Had, Brain Damage were also deep and personal songs about his life from his first Album The Slim Shady LP. The Way I Am, Marshall Mathers, Stan were deep and life experience tracks from his second Album.

[gintokisan]

Hi I have been lurking on here for awhile usually just to here the new em songs as I am a big fan.

And what I don't get about eminem is how people say he raps about his real life, well so do 95% of rappers, and eminem only recently started rapping about "life" and in that respect is just a carbon copy of Kanye West, in fact I could only name about 4 songs on Recovery that could be classified as his real life, and it's horrible to see people on here dissing Lil Wayne for being fake, I honestly don't like Lil Wayne but I don't see how what he is rapping about is fake, he did the same thing as em and became mainstream, I actually used to like the early Wayne, before all of this YM shit.


Sorry if I offended anyone, I just needed to get this off my chest as I have been arguing with someone over this.

It's Ok, Tonite, Jealousy Woes, Never 2 Far, Searchin, Backstabber, Rock Bottom, If I Had, Murder Murder, 97 Bonnie & Clyde, The Way I Am, Marshall Mathers, Stan, Who Knew, Cleaning Out My Closet, Hailies Song, Say Goodbye To Hollywood, Superman, Soldier, Square Dance, White America, When The Music Stops, Till I Collapse, Sing For The Moment, Drips, Like Toy Soldiers, Mockingbird, Yellow Brick Road, Mosh, Spend Some Time, Crazy In Love, We As Americans, Ricky Ticky Tock, Never Enough, Beautiful, Be Careful What You Wish For, Deja Vu, My Darling, Not Afraid, Seduction, Cold Wind Blows, Cinderella Man, Spacebound, 25 To Life, You're Never Over, Talkin To Myself, Going Through Changes, Almost Famous, Lose Yourself, Rabbit Run, 8 Mile Road, Love Me, No Apologies, Public Enemy Number 1, Difficult, When Cocaine, I'm Gone



Every song Eminem has done about his real life experiences based on experiences like poverty, single parent home, being a father, drug addiction, politics. The Eminem Show which came out in 2002 10 years is a personal album where every track is deep and personal based on his life aside from With Out Me. Rock Bottom, If I Had, Brain Damage were also deep and personal songs about his life from his first Album The Slim Shady LP. The Way I Am, Marshall Mathers, Stan were deep and life experience tracks from his second Album.

When you say "Every song Eminem has done about his real life experiences based on experiences like poverty, single parent home, being a father, drug addiction, politics." Do you mean every single song he raps about , or only the ones about his real life.Also I said songs from when he was rapping earlier, you listed songs like Not Afraid.

[DƎRDYPK]

not only is FreeSpeech back but Aftermathers too!?

[AmmoHaze]

Every Song i listed is Eminem's songs about his life struggles


You gotta learn to read cos Rock Bottom, If I Had, Mockingbird, Hailies Song etc are old Eminem songs about his life you fail to realize Eminem been Rapping about his life on these songs from his first album. The Eminem Show was an album from 2002 where every song was about his life and what he going through.

[AmmoHaze]

Eminem songs about his life, experiences, struggles from 1999 on his major label debut Rock Bottom, If I Had, Brain Damage


from 2000 The Way I Am, Stan, Marshall Mathers


From 2002 pretty much the whole Eminem Show Album and songs from the 8 Mile soundtrack like 8 Mile Road, Lose Yourself, Rabbit Run


From 2004 Mockingbird, Like Toy Soldiers, We As Americans, Never Enough, Yellow Brick Road, Crazy In Love, Love Me, Ricky Ticky Tock, Mosh



So your point makes no sense or you haven't ever listened to his Music because he been making songs about life since 1999 made an entire album based on his life issues in 2002 so this is why your thread makes no sense he been doing it all the way from 1999 with Rock Bottom up till now with Recovery.

[kiki]

Why do some people think he isn't?