The TRshady Forum became read-only in December 2014. The 10 year history will live on, in this archive.
Continue the discussion with the new home for the Eminem and Hip Hop discussion: HipHopShelter.com.

Detroit News: Eminem's 40 Greatest Songs

All questions and discussions on Eminem to be found here.

Detroit News: Eminem's 40 Greatest Songs

Postby Amaranthine » Oct 16th, '12, 06:29

Wednesday marks Eminem’s 40th birthday, but don’t go calling the Detroit rapper over-the-hill just yet.

While 40 was once an unthinkable age for a rapper, Em finds himself in good company in the “40” club: Jay-Z is 42, Em’s mentor Dr. Dre is 47, and Nas, 39, will join next year.

We’re marking the milestone by ranking Em’s 40 best songs. The criteria: We culled only from his studio albums, ignoring leaks, mixtape tracks and other songs floating around the Internet. We included the “8 Mile” soundtrack and his Bad Meets Evil project, as well, but left off his collaborations on other artists’ albums, which we’ll mark with a separate list.

The list is purely subjective, but takes into account impact, legacy and chart power. To our surprise, Em’s 2010 “Recovery” album notched the most entries, with eight, but “The Marshall Mathers LP” ranked the highest, earning four slots in the Top 10.

Overall, compiling the list proved Eminem has amassed an impressive body of work and he’s truly worthy of being called one of hip-hop’s all time greats.



40. “Stay Wide Awake” (from “Relapse”)

A grisly horror movie tale so vivid it conjures up images of nighttime fog rolling over gravestones.

39. “Mockingbird” (“Encore”)

Not the first or the best song dedicated to Em’s daughter, but the heart-wrenchingly honest storytelling — especially the part about her college fund getting stolen — hits home.

38. “Fast Lane” (“Hell: The Sequel”)

A propulsive beat backs this sturdy exercise in no-stakes, old-school rapping from Eminem and Royce da 5’9”.

37. “Rock Bottom” (“The Slim Shady LP”)

There weren’t a lot of good times to be had on “The Slim Shady LP,” and “Rock Bottom” was the album at its lowest, with Eminem rapping-for-broke about never being able to catch any breaks.

36. “My 1st Single” (“Encore”) :laughing:

“I’m at the top of my game,” Eminem raps — empty boasting at a time when his success was his biggest hindrance. He had nothing left to say by the time “Encore” came around, but he at least has fun getting meta on this song about not even having the discipline to stop belching long enough to make a single.

35. “White Trash Party (W.T.P.)” (“Recovery”)

Eminem has made many songs for Detroit, but here’s an anthem for Warren, a song about partying down trailer part-style and loving it.

34. “You’re Never Over” (“Recovery”)

A heartfelt tribute to Proof, whose death caused Eminem to spiral out of control, the bouncing back from which formed the basis of “Recovery.”

33. “Déjà vu” (“Relapse”)

An uncomfortably honest, harrowing chronicle of Em’s descent into drug abuse and lethargy.

32. “Rabbit Run” (“8 Mile” soundtrack)

For three tension-filled minutes, Eminem — as his “8 Mile” character B-Rabbit — breathlessly raps over a ticking clock that signifies his window of opportunity closing.

31. “My Mom” (“Relapse”)

Eminem takes a familiar subject — his mother — and flips it on its ear, spinning an absurdist tale and about his own drug problem and surmising, “I’m on what I’m on cuz I’m my mom.”

30. “Encore” (“Encore”)

The “Platinum Trio” — Eminem, 50 Cent and Dr. Dre — close out “Encore” with a raucous club-banger, one that, rather hilariously, teases the imminent release of Dr. Dre’s “Detox,” an album that has yet to materialize eight years later.

29. “A– Like That” (“Encore”)

The nadir of “Encore’s” pointless self-wankery, but notable in that Eminem raps the entire song in a Triumph the Insult Comic Dog accent which he at one point transitions into an Arnold Schwarzenegger impersonation.

28. “White America” (“The Eminem Show”)

“The Eminem Show’s” opening salvo is a seething statement on Eminem’s place in the culture as a result of the color of his skin, illustrating that he could both anger politicians and get hugs on the set of “TRL.” All in a day’s work.

27. “Not Afraid” (“Recovery”)

This 12-step program set to music, with Eminem thanking his fans and promising to not let them down again, was an important step in his “Recovery.” However, an unfortunate victim of his self-cleansing is his “Relapse” album, which he unfairly dismisses as “ehh.”

26. “Lighters” (“Hell: The Sequel”)

A soaring Bruno Mars chorus marks this unlikely inspirational ballad from the Bad Meets Evil duo.

25. “Cold Wind Blows” (“Recovery”)

Eminem gets struck with lightning mid-song — a first — but not even that can stop his momentum as he flows like lava over Just Blaze’s ice cold beat.

24. “Business” (“The Eminem Show”)

Utterly effortless, it’s a testament to Em’s hitmaking abilities at the time that this song sounds completely tossed off, and he knows it. “You ain’t even impressed no more,” he groans, “you’re used to it.”

23. “Drug Ballad” (“The Marshall Mathers LP”)

A very different commentary on drugs than on Eminem’s latter albums, “Drug Ballad” celebrates youth and drug culture with a carefree, live-for-today nonchalance.

22. “3 a.m.” (“Relapse”)

As a standalone single, “3 a.m.” didn’t work very well, but as the lead-in to “Relapse,” it was a portal into the demented, dark fantasy world the album inhabits.

21. “Won’t Back Down” (“Recovery”)

Rock guitar riffs and a valuable vocal assist from Pink help set the scene for this spirited “Recovery” barnburner.

20. “So Bad” (“Recovery”)

The only “Recovery” track produced by Dr. Dre has a lurching beat that is as thick as a tree trunk and stomps like a brontosaurus.

19. “Criminal” (“The Marshall Mathers LP”)

Some embarrassingly homophobic lyrics aside, Slim Shady is in top form here, switching rapidly between characters — he plays Gianni Versace, a concerned record exec and a philandering Southern preacher all within a few lines — while gleefully and venomously playing up his bad boy persona, even stopping to rob a bank mid-song.

18. “Square Dance” (“The Eminem Show”)

Coming on like a demented polka with a cheerfully inane chorus, “Square Dance” manages to slip in some subversive lyrics about post-9/11 America amid the craziness and Em’s complicated flow.

17. “My Dad’s Gone Crazy” (“The Eminem Show”)

Em enlists a vocal assist from his daughter on this hilariously profane track where he describes his dedication to rap in several amazingly unprintable stanzas.

16. “Kill You” (“The Marshall Mathers LP”)

The opening track from “The Marshall Mathers LP” establishes the album’s angry but playful tone, and Eminem deftly sums up his entire M.O. in nine succinct words: “Blood, guts, guns, cuts, knives, wives, lives, nuns, sluts.”

15. “Love the Way You Lie” (“Recovery”)

Some of Eminem’s more groan-worthy puns — “Now you get to watch her leave out the window, guess that’s why they call it window pane” (get it? Window pain?) — are rescued by Rihanna’s anthemic chorus on this monster hit which spent seven weeks at No. 1 on Billboard’s Hot 100 singles chart.

14. “Cleanin’ Out My Closet” (“The Eminem Show”)

“I’m sorry mama, I never meant to hurt you,” Eminem raps, but he’s far from burying the hatchet with her. He later says, “Hailey’s getting so big now, you should see her she’s beautiful/ but you’ll never see her, she won’t even be at your funeral,” proving while he may have cleaned out his closet, he was far from forgiving his mother for his tormented childhood.

13. “Without Me” (“The Eminem Show”)

By the time “The Eminem Show” came out, Em’s upbeat, celeb-skewing first single gimmick was old hat, but “Without Me” proved there was still some life left in the formula. Latter entries “Just Lose It” and “We Made You,” however, weren’t as fortunate.

12. “Guilty Conscience” (“The Slim Shady LP”)

Eminem goes toe-to-toe with Dr. Dre as they play the devil and angel, respectively, on a series of characters’ shoulders in three different situations. Em flips the script on his counterpart when he calls out his real life assault on TV host Dee Barnes, an early indicator that Em was a loose cannon willing to go say anything to shock his audience.

11. “No Love” (“Recovery”)

Spitting triple-time lyrical genocide, Eminem raps like he’s got something to prove, in this case that his guest Lil Wayne — at the time, considered by many to be the best rapper in the game — isn’t worthy to share his air space. To Em’s credit, by the end of his verse, you barely remember Wayne was even on the song with him.

10. “8 Mile” (“8 Mile” soundtrack)

Overshadowed by “Lose Yourself,” “8 Mile” is the unheralded gem of the “8 Mile” soundtrack, an in-character missive about the struggles he faced to make it in the rap game.

9. “My Name Is” (“The Slim Shady LP”)

The world’s introduction to Eminem, Slim Shady and Marshall Mathers established him as a pop-culture skewering psychopath with serious parental issues who could out-shock anyone put in front of him. Beyond that, it established his penchant for bizarre, complicated rhyme schemes (“extraterrestrial running over pedestrians”) and showed he was an MC first and foremost.

8. “Mosh” (“Encore”)

A pointed jab at George W. Bush, “Mosh” came out a few weeks before the 2004 election and found Eminem at his most political, slowing down his flow to make sure each word landed like a death blow.

7. “The Way I Am” (“The Marshall Mathers LP”)

So, how did Eminem enjoy the success of “The Slim Shady LP?” “I’m so sick and tired of being admired that I wish that I would just die or get fired,” Em seethes on this livid track from “The Marshall Mathers LP,” which acts as a bitter indictment of fame and the media spotlight.

6. “Till I Collapse” (“The Eminem Show”)

This “Eminem Show” cut has thematic similarities to “Lose Yourself” and an infectious militaristic stomp, and is hammered home by Nate Dogg’s confident chorus. Despite never being released as a single, the song has sold 2 million digital copies, in part because of its popularity in movie trailers (“Real Steel,” “Savages,” etc.).

5. “The Real Slim Shady” (“The Marshall Mathers LP”)

The song that marked Eminem’s pop peak and cemented him as a cultural force. The references are now dated — Tom Green, anyone? — but “The Real Slim Shady” is Eminem the celeb-skewer at his finest.

4. “’97 Bonnie & Clyde” (“The Slim Shady LP”)

This track — where Em calmly describes the murder of his daughter’s mother to his baby girl — established the bond between Eminem and his daughter, one of the most important themes in his work, and also proved Em to be both a scary-good storyteller and a good scary story teller.

3. “Stan” (“The Marshall Mathers LP”)

A story of demented fandom told from the prospective of an obsessed fan over three increasingly hostile verses and closing with a measured response from Em, “Stan” is a triumph of conceptual storytelling and one of Em’s most impressive efforts both as a rapper and a producer. It also helped break the career of Dido, whose tender “Thank You” forms the unlikely backbone of this dark, moody tale.

2. “Kim” (“The Marshall Mathers LP”)

A disturbing, shockingly violent murder fantasy that is the rawest, angriest song Eminem has ever recorded. It also contains his most complex, intricate rhymes ever; when he lays out the particulars of a grisly crime scene, he does so with a clarity and attention to detail that would make a “Law & Order” screenwriter proud. Truly haunting.

1. “Lose Yourself” (“8 Mile” soundtrack)

Eminem’s Oscar-winning masterpiece, “Lose Yourself” represents the peak of Em’s artistry and songwriting. Rousing and inspirational, it has become hip-hop’s “Eye of the Tiger”; listen closely and you can hear Em taking deep breaths between each line, as if he was losing himself in the music while recording. It worked; mom’s spaghetti hasn’t been the same since.

Source
Image
You should read this.
I break my back to give you my art, you steal my thoughts
It's like driving a spike through my heart

Geno wrote:I don't wanna have a kid with Zabe tbh.
User avatar
Amaranthine
Band Leader
Band Leader
 
Posts: 5833
Joined: Jun 2nd, '11, 14:18
Location: California
Gender: Female

Re: Detroit News: Eminem's 40 Greatest Songs

Postby EminemBase » Oct 16th, '12, 06:44

Lmao @ "No Love" at no.11 and above "Criminal" etc. absurd.

Also, how does "Kim" contain his most intricate rhymes :confusion:

Just read on the "Criminal" description, "Some embarrassingly homophobic lyrics aside" :facepalm, whoever wrote this totally doesn't get The Marshall Mathers LP, or Em.
Last edited by EminemBase on Oct 16th, '12, 06:52, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
EminemBase
Addict
Addict
 
Posts: 10007
Joined: Dec 10th, '09, 06:37
Location: Inside your mind famalamalamalam.
Gender: Male

Re: Detroit News: Eminem's 40 Greatest Songs

Postby cityfan31 » Oct 16th, '12, 06:49

In fairness, ranking songs downwards is a pretty tough job once you get beyond the top 5 or so.

Take out My First Single and Mosh. Not convinced by WTP rather than Cinderella Man / Almost Famous.

Impressed by the nods to Relapse though.

EDIT: No Sing for the Moment? A criminal omission. Can't take this list seriously any more.
Last edited by cityfan31 on Oct 16th, '12, 06:55, edited 1 time in total.
cityfan31
Soldier
Soldier
 
Posts: 1649
Joined: Jun 16th, '07, 12:26
Location: Leicestershire
Gender: Female

Re: Detroit News: Eminem's 40 Greatest Songs

Postby cityfan31 » Oct 16th, '12, 07:02

Geno wrote:They must have just forgot SFTM.

There's no way they looked at that song and said "Nah it doesn't make the list"


Has to be said, he has an incredible catalogue, if you can miss out a classic like that. Lose Yourself obviously wasn't in the rules, but that goes straight to number one for me.
cityfan31
Soldier
Soldier
 
Posts: 1649
Joined: Jun 16th, '07, 12:26
Location: Leicestershire
Gender: Female

Re: Detroit News: Eminem's 40 Greatest Songs

Postby Squiggles123 » Oct 16th, '12, 07:06

Déjà vu number 33 :/ But 'My Mom' number 31? Wadafaq! Lighters at number 26 too....better then not afraid? hhmmm.

I hate these lists, I'd hate to be the one to have to try and put them together, I prefer lists that are factual like "Top Selling Eminem Singles" or whatever, they're more interesting because there's facts behind them.

Also, no 'Like Toy Soldiers'? Certainly better then 'My 1st Single' anyway....Sing for the Moment missing too. Why was 'Lose Yourself' against the rules? I thought it said they were including 8 mile soundtrack.
User avatar
Squiggles123
Soldier
Soldier
 
Posts: 919
Joined: Apr 23rd, '12, 04:46

Re: Detroit News: Eminem's 40 Greatest Songs

Postby cityfan31 » Oct 16th, '12, 07:15

Squiggles123 wrote:Déjà vu number 33 :/ But 'My Mom' number 31? Wadafaq! Lighters at number 26 too....better then not afraid? hhmmm.

I hate these lists, I'd hate to be the one to have to try and put them together, I prefer lists that are factual like "Top Selling Eminem Singles" or whatever, they're more interesting because there's facts behind them.

Also, no 'Like Toy Soldiers'? Certainly better then 'My 1st Single' anyway....Sing for the Moment missing too. Why was 'Lose Yourself' against the rules? I thought it said they were including 8 mile soundtrack.


You are right.

Have they missed out SFTM and Lose Yourself?

This list has lost credibility faster than Canibus did when he battled that guy with a massive notebook.
cityfan31
Soldier
Soldier
 
Posts: 1649
Joined: Jun 16th, '07, 12:26
Location: Leicestershire
Gender: Female

Re: Detroit News: Eminem's 40 Greatest Songs

Postby Amaranthine » Oct 16th, '12, 07:20

cityfan31 wrote:
Squiggles123 wrote:Déjà vu number 33 :/ But 'My Mom' number 31? Wadafaq! Lighters at number 26 too....better then not afraid? hhmmm.

I hate these lists, I'd hate to be the one to have to try and put them together, I prefer lists that are factual like "Top Selling Eminem Singles" or whatever, they're more interesting because there's facts behind them.

Also, no 'Like Toy Soldiers'? Certainly better then 'My 1st Single' anyway....Sing for the Moment missing too. Why was 'Lose Yourself' against the rules? I thought it said they were including 8 mile soundtrack.


You are right.

Have they missed out SFTM and Lose Yourself?

This list has lost credibility faster than Canibus did when he battled that guy with a massive notebook.

Guys, Lose Yourself is number 1.
Image
You should read this.
I break my back to give you my art, you steal my thoughts
It's like driving a spike through my heart

Geno wrote:I don't wanna have a kid with Zabe tbh.
User avatar
Amaranthine
Band Leader
Band Leader
 
Posts: 5833
Joined: Jun 2nd, '11, 14:18
Location: California
Gender: Female

Re: Detroit News: Eminem's 40 Greatest Songs

Postby cityfan31 » Oct 16th, '12, 07:24

Amaranthine wrote:Guys, Lose Yourself is number 1.


:laughing: :facepalm

I'm a fucking idiot.

I'd actually stopped reading the list at Stan as I assumed it would be number 1.
cityfan31
Soldier
Soldier
 
Posts: 1649
Joined: Jun 16th, '07, 12:26
Location: Leicestershire
Gender: Female

Re: Detroit News: Eminem's 40 Greatest Songs

Postby flyingmonkey10 » Oct 16th, '12, 07:25

that top 10 is fairly solid
How can hip-hop be dead if Wu-Tang is forever?

Image ImageImageImageImage
User avatar
flyingmonkey10
Role Model
Role Model
 
Posts: 3345
Joined: Dec 29th, '09, 02:24
Location: Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Gender: Male

Re: Detroit News: Eminem's 40 Greatest Songs

Postby Coulter » Oct 16th, '12, 10:49

Yeah, this just keeps adding on to my suspicion that he's retiring.
Image
Miller wrote:
I'm gonna be pissed if Em finally beefs again and it's with fucking Iggy.
User avatar
Coulter
Soldier
Soldier
 
Posts: 575
Joined: Dec 20th, '11, 18:32
Location: United States
Gender: Male

Re: Detroit News: Eminem's 40 Greatest Songs

Postby Squiggles123 » Oct 16th, '12, 13:47

Amaranthine wrote:
cityfan31 wrote:
Squiggles123 wrote:Déjà vu number 33 :/ But 'My Mom' number 31? Wadafaq! Lighters at number 26 too....better then not afraid? hhmmm.

I hate these lists, I'd hate to be the one to have to try and put them together, I prefer lists that are factual like "Top Selling Eminem Singles" or whatever, they're more interesting because there's facts behind them.

Also, no 'Like Toy Soldiers'? Certainly better then 'My 1st Single' anyway....Sing for the Moment missing too. Why was 'Lose Yourself' against the rules? I thought it said they were including 8 mile soundtrack.


You are right.

Have they missed out SFTM and Lose Yourself?

This list has lost credibility faster than Canibus did when he battled that guy with a massive notebook.

Guys, Lose Yourself is number 1.


haha wow, I actually read the whole thing too :S

I did like how the guy mentioned Em unfairly dismissing Relapse as "ehh" as someone mentioned above. He's obviously a big fan but these lists will never work, everyone has there favourites. I'm sure some people wanted "yellow brick road" in there too, amongst others.
User avatar
Squiggles123
Soldier
Soldier
 
Posts: 919
Joined: Apr 23rd, '12, 04:46

Re: Detroit News: Eminem's 40 Greatest Songs

Postby Mathers » Oct 16th, '12, 15:30

Stopped reading after I saw My 1st Single on there. :facepalm
Fuck top five, bitch, I'm top four
And that includes Biggie and Pac, whore
And I got an Evil Twin
So who the fuck do you think that third and that fourth spot's for?
Mathers
Under The Influence
Under The Influence
 
Posts: 4147
Joined: Aug 26th, '11, 18:29
Gender: Male

Re: Detroit News: Eminem's 40 Greatest Songs

Postby Notalius » Oct 16th, '12, 17:45

Infinite :coffee:
Image

My Last Shoutout - My Last Will

http://forum.trshady.com/viewtopic.php?f=29&t=175438

So kids, am I worth it ? Did I put enough work in ?

#GiveCanadaPureTheDick | 04.12.2014 - The day TR was closed forever

We are here now --> http://www.hiphopshelter.com
User avatar
Notalius
Band Leader
Band Leader
 
Posts: 5578
Joined: Jul 26th, '12, 21:21
Gender: Male

Re: Detroit News: Eminem's 40 Greatest Songs

Postby TheGentlePlayer » Oct 16th, '12, 18:12

You know it's a bad list when you find Not Afraid on it..
I wanted an album so rugged nobody could touch it.
Spent a million a track and went over my budget.
Now how in the fuck am I supposed to get out of debt?
I can't rap anymore, I just murdered the alphabet.
User avatar
TheGentlePlayer
Band Leader
Band Leader
 
Posts: 7807
Joined: Sep 1st, '10, 23:34
Location: Norway
Gender: Male

Re: Detroit News: Eminem's 40 Greatest Songs

Postby UofLCard » Oct 16th, '12, 19:44

36. “My 1st Single” (“Encore”)


*eye twitch* AND they rated it ahead of Rock Bottom, and didn't even include Sing for the Moment. :shakehead:
Last edited by UofLCard on Oct 16th, '12, 19:48, edited 1 time in total.
LEVITIKUZ wrote:Did y'all know Eminem's initials are MM. Like his name!!!


TRshady's unofficial official Facebook page
https://www.facebook.com/trshadycommun
User avatar
UofLCard
Louisville's Finest
Louisville's Finest
 
Posts: 8419
Joined: Jun 5th, '09, 04:28
Location: The land of Shadymania
Gender: Female

Next

Return to Eminem



Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot]