Slim Cary wrote:I think that's label influence. Put Beautiful, have to have the sad emotional personal Em so people can relate. Put Crack a bottle, have to have the club hit. Put We made you, have to have something for MTV.
I definitely think that's true about "Beautiful". I don't buy what Em said about putting it on there to 'remind himself' of that place. It's the song which is most like his older material on there, and an emotional track... the label need some singles and beyond "We Made You", everything else was psychotic or really harsh and fucked-up, they needed normal Em.
I also think Em may have done it like a kind of, decision for direction... as in, he put it there to see 'if they don't like the new stuff... will they like this', as I think he was initially planning to go that direction back in like 2007 with King Mathers, but then wanted to try something new with Relapse ; but when people didn't like it but liked "Beautiful" - that's the direction he took.
As if you look at Recovery, it's basically one giant template of "Beautiful". He raps differently, but he realized the majority wanted emotion and that big rock-tinged kind of sound, and that's exactly what Recovery is. So I think that song was like a back-up.
With "Crack a Bottle" that's just obvious as it was a #1, such a shame though.
I don't even mind "We Made You", as it still totally fits the album, it sounds absolutely right there and blends with the rest. Doesn't feel like a compromise, and the rapping is really good. And the production and the hook in fact, I quite like the song even on its own.