Trshady's Top 25 Albums Of All Time 39 lists so far

[King Lance]

Last 5 years....?

Alright.

Why don't we do all time?

we all know that the list will be full of Eminem songs from TES, MMLP, SSLP

[CrashBand]

Isn't it one per artist.

[King Lance]

So, you all want agree to do a "top 50 songs of all time" list, one song per artist ?

should we keep these rules or not ?

How? Everyone post a list of 25 of your favorite hip hop songs of all time. I’ll be doing a weighted addition for each song. For example, putting a song as #1 on your list will give the song 25 points, and putting it as #25 will give it 1 point.

ONE song per artist !!!!!

[King Lance]

Top 50 songs of all time is to hard for me. Would much rather do top 25 songs of last 5 years.

That's the idea, everyone gives his top 25 of all time (1 song per artist).
All of us will have a different list I guest but it's obvious that some songs will be mentioned several times and these songs will have a spot in the top 25, the other songs will have a spot in the top 50.

You can do a top 25 songs of these last 5 or 10 years if you want, but those who want to mention Tupac or biggie will be able to do a top 25 of all time

Some people have been listening to hip hop for 3 years and others have been listening since the 90/2000s, it's obvious that all of us will have a different list. I’ll be doing a weighted addition for each song and make a "trshady top 50 songs of all time"

we just need to agree on the rules, top 50(25 ?) of all time ? of the last 5 years ?

[sbolli1]

Last 5 years....?

Alright.

Why don't we do all time?

we all know that the list will be full of Eminem songs from TES, MMLP, SSLP

I mean let's be honest nothing can beat the holy triumvirate.

[SG.]

Everybody do 25 songs and the final list will be 50?

[King Lance]

Everybody do 25 songs and the final list will be 50?

yep, they did it on KTT for an album list and it worked very well man.

with everybody making a list of 25 songs, it's obvious that a LOT of songs will be mentioned

KTT did the same for an album list, everybody was supposed to post a list of 15 albums and the final list had 100 albums on it.

This is also what Pitchfork and the other magazines do every year.
Each journalist gives a list of 10 albums and the final list = 50 albums.
http://pitchfork.com/features/staff-lis ... of-2012/6/


for example:

1. song (25 pnts)
2. song
3. song
4. song
5. song (20 pnts)
6. song
7. song
8. song
9. song
10. song
...
25. song (1 pnts)

Or everybody do 20 songs and the final list is 30 ?

[SG.]

Is it just hip-hop or everything?

[King Lance]

Is it just hip-hop or everything?

hip hop

we can make a "top ... songs of all time, all genre" list in the music section tbh




Does everybody agree with the "rules" ?

[King Lance]

Why don't we just do top 50 albums of all time then?

a list of 20 songs and a final list of 50 ?
yeah we can, I just thought that we weren't enough in the hip hop section to make a "big list" but i'm all for that.

But if you want everybody to make a list of 50 songs... I'm pretty sure that some members aren't able to name more than 30 artists


A top 40 was just a suggestion

[King Lance]

How about we make it a TRshady top 25 hip-hop albums of all time list? It'll make it easier to eliminate the albums that get mentioned once or twice....

Albums ? why not

everybody makes a list of 25 albums for a final list of 50? 100 ?

But you guys have to understand that people will post THEIR favorite lists, don't be surprise if you see Drake on a list.
viewtopic.php?f=6&t=157080

For example, this is the KTT final list : http://www.kanyetothe.com/forum/index.p ... c=448922.0

[SG.]

Albums might actually be easier tbh.

[King Lance]

We all know Eminem will have 3 albums in the top 5 tbh

Ppl will be mad, just like the KTT members were mad because Kanye had almost all of his album in the top 10

[SG.]

Then imply the last 5 years rule or make it so each artist can only be mentioned once.

[King Lance]

oh fuck, let's do that, everybody post a list of his 25 FAVORITE albums (music is subjective, isn't it ?), for a final list of 100.

let's see how it works and we can do a list of top songs later