MMLP2 >> Recovery, Relapse, Encore (and it ain't close)

[Ares]

I'm listening to Relapse now and... oh my god. No way.

MMLP2 doesn't touch Relapse.

It's easily better than Encore and Recovery though.

But Relapse >>

More Relapse threads coming.

Admins should create Relapse section.

[4Corners]

To me at least, it's not even close. I can listen to MMLP2 and then listen to Relapse, and I can hear at least that it's MMLP2 all the way.

The thing I find funny is the Relapse fans that overrate the fuck out of it here.....they talk shit about Underground, Beautiful, Old Time's Sake, Crack A Bottle, We Made You, and then most everyone hates Bagpipes too unless you're really overrating it. That's 6 out of 15 tracks right there. The only songs you can do that with on MMLP2 are really Berzerk, Survival, The Monster. The rest are either good, great, or really good and every single bonus song is at least good or solid.

[Satan]

I'm listening to Relapse now and... oh my god. No way.

MMLP2 doesn't touch Relapse.

It's easily better than Encore and Recovery though.

But Relapse >>

Relapse is 5.5/10. MMLP2 is 8.5/10.

Sorry Marshall, but there's only so much shit that can be on an "ah-bahm" til it starts to "maugh-taugh". Insane, Bagpipes, We Made You, Medicine Ball, Old Time's Sake, Must Be the Ganja's first & second verse, Beautiful, Crack a Bottle, & Underground suck dick. That's 9 out of 16 songs that are godawful. And 3 A.M & Stay Wide Awake are only good for their beats, rhyming, and flows, the lyrics range from bland to nothing special to shit. My Mom, Hello, Same Song & Dance, & Deja Vu are the only above 7 tracks on the album.

MMLP2 has 3 bad tracks, Survival, STIW, & The Monster.
























Oh yeah, I forgot, Relapse has imagery, which makes it an instant classic just like Shakespeare.

[metsfan1121]

Relapse could've been a masterpiece if they went another route. No, not if they made the sequel. No, not if they switched some refill tracks for bad ones. No, not if they deleted the bad tracks all together and made no refill. It would've been a masterpiece if it was an 8 song EP, and promoted to be an EP, not an album. Something like this
3 AM
My Mom
Insane
Same Song & Dance
Stay Wide Awake
Deja Vu
Music Box
Underground
/album

[4Corners]

My Relapse tracklist that I listen to is this....yeah let the hate roll in

1. Dr Wesr
2. 3AM
3. Hell Breaks Loose
4. My Mom
5. Insane
6. Hello
7. Tonya
8. Same Song & Dance
9. Elevator
10. Must be the Ganja
11. Mr Mathers
12. Deja Vu
13. Music Box
14. Beautiful (Fuck ya'll, I love this song and what it represents)
15. My Darling
16. Drop the Bomb On Em
17. Crack A Bottle (album would need a first single, this is still better than We Made You)
18. Careful What You Wish For
19. Underground (you guys can hate, but the flow is undeniable)

[Kill You]

I'm listening to Relapse now and... oh my god. No way.

MMLP2 doesn't touch Relapse.

It's easily better than Encore and Recovery though.

But Relapse >>

Eminem on MMLP2 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Eminem on Relapse

Now, if we're talking about as albums...maybe or maybe not but I wanna say MMLP2 is superior.

[Cinderella Stan]

To me, it's obvious.

MMLP
TES
SSLP
MMLP2
Relapse
Recovery
Encore

thumbs up if you agree

[kpprasa]

I'm listening to Relapse now and... oh my god. No way.

MMLP2 doesn't touch Relapse.

It's easily better than Encore and Recovery though.

But Relapse >>

Eminem on MMLP2 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Eminem on Relapse

Now, if we're talking about as albums...maybe or maybe not but I wanna say MMLP2 is superior.

This

[Wic Kid]

I'm listening to Relapse now and... oh my god. No way.

MMLP2 doesn't touch Relapse.

It's easily better than Encore and Recovery though.

But Relapse >>

Eminem on MMLP2 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Eminem on Relapse

Now, if we're talking about as albums...maybe or maybe not but I wanna say MMLP2 is superior.

This.

Now, it's easily better than Encore and Recovery, I think every rational person can agree. My problem with Relapse is mostly the accent. I just cant get passed it. Yeah, this album might have the strongest cohesion in the matter of concept, but what good does that do if I cant stand his pronounciation of almost every word? Hello is unlistenable for me. Im not sayin it didnt work for every song. SWA and 3 AM still remain badass.

While MMLP2 doesn't really have that cohesion throughout, in the terms of storytelling, its songs kinda have the same feeling, same vibe. Which was the case with MMLP. At first it seemed like bunch of incoherent songs where Eminem rants about shit, but after you absorb this vibe, you can see what he wanted to accomplish here. Same with MMLP2.

I think that some people dont realize the artist's intention behind the project. If they try to make a concept album, and they fail, you can talk shit about it. Em didnt go down that road, he played the vibe card, at least from what I hear.

My list:
TES
MMLP
SSLP=MMLP2
Recovery=Relapse
Encore

[Kill You]

It's not even the accent for me because I don't mind it. It's just MMLP2 is so much more "Eminem" than Relapse is if we're being honest here...it's the best he's been since 2002.

[superman11]

It's not even the accent for me because I don't mind it. It's just MMLP2 is so much more "Eminem" than Relapse is if we're being honest here...it's the best he's been since 2002.

This. And the fact that when everyone praises it, they mention the bonus tracks and refill and ignore the duds.Relapse is so overrated here, It's not bad, but MMLP2 shits on it and it's not even close to me. To me..

MMLP
TES
MMLP2
SSLP
Relapse/Recovery
Encore

[slimsoxshady]

I really like Recovery so for now, MMLP2 = Recovery >>> Relapse >>> Encore

[B.A.D.]

MMLP > The Eminem Show = MMLP2 > Relapse > Encore > SSLP > Recovery

thats how it is (Fur me)

[Raul]

MMLP > The Eminem Show = MMLP2 > Relapse > Encore > SSLP > Recovery

thats how it is

[Kill You]

MMLP > The Eminem Show = MMLP2 > Relapse > Encore > SSLP > Recovery

thats how it is